Shopping from the USDA’s MyPlate sample grocery list is trickier than it sounds, especially when the four gallons of milk fall out of the cart. (Jennifer Bardsley)

Shopping from the USDA’s MyPlate sample grocery list is trickier than it sounds, especially when the four gallons of milk fall out of the cart. (Jennifer Bardsley)

Grocery shopping with MyPlate’s Thrifty Meal Plan in mind

The goal: Spend no more than $158.30 at Fred Meyer on a week’s worth of food for a family of four.

This month, my family is revisiting a challenge I originally wrote about for The Daily Herald in 2013 called MyPlate on My Budget. Could my family of four follow the USDA’s MyPlate requirements and also stick to its thrifty budget as defined by the USDA Food Plan: Cost of Food Report?

In 2013, that meant spending $144.80 a week on food. Now, the budget has risen to $158.30.

The first time I did this challenge, I planned all of the meals myself. This time around, I’m using resources available at ChooseMyPlate.gov; specifically the sample menu plans and grocery shopping lists. According to MyPlate: “These sample two-week menus can be used by any person or family wanting to follow a healthy diet at a modest price. The menus are designed to meet nutrition needs on a budget.”

I’m blessed to live in a neighborhood with several grocery stores and to also own a car so I can drive to them and transport goods home. Plus, since my son is 14, I can leave both kids at home while I go grocery shopping.

On Day 1, I drove to Fred Meyer with my Week 1 grocery list in hand, along with the second list of pantry staples. The grocery list had 63 items on it, and the pantry list had another 46.

I was extremely grateful to be shopping alone. Every choice meant reading labels, checking prices and sometimes downloading digital coupons. None of that is new to me, but since the list was so long, it took an hour and a half. Plus, I bought products I was unfamiliar with like precooked turkey sausage and whole wheat tortillas.

When I finished shopping, my cart had four gallons of milk, three dozen eggs, dinner rolls, English muffins, tortillas, lentils, rice, couscous, spaghetti, oatmeal, cereal, corn meal, 5 pounds of chicken, pork chops, ground beef, round steak, two pounds of fish, five bags of frozen vegetables, frozen juice concentrate, 20 bananas, potatoes and lots of fresh vegetables.

As I pushed my bloated cart around the store, it became crystal clear that this list was not friendly to people with food allergies. There was so much milk that it kept falling off the bottom rack. Since I’m gluten intolerant, instead of buying two loaves of whole wheat bread, I bought one loaf of whole wheat and one gluten free. I also picked the more expensive gluten-free spaghetti.

When I got to the checkout stand the final tally was $182.45. That was $24.15 more than the USDA’s thrifty budget. If I had gone to WinCo, I probably could have come in on target, but perhaps the produce wouldn’t have been able to last a full week.

Loading the groceries into the car, bringing them into the house and putting them away took me another hour. I didn’t have room in my refrigerator for all of the milk, so I put two gallons in the freezer.

Could MyPlate’s sample two-week plan really be used for “any person or family” like they claimed? Yes — any person with a car, access to a grocery store, the physical ability to lift heavy things and an extra $24.15 to spend at the last minute.

Read Jennifer Bardsley’s original MyPlate on My Budget articles from 2013:

www.heraldnet.com/life/can-a-family-eat-thrifty-and-healthy-lets-find-out

www.heraldnet.com/life/the-challenge-of-eating-by-the-usda-guidelines

www.heraldnet.com/life/myplate-on-my-budget-good-food-costs-money/www.heraldnet.com/life/eating-well-on-a-budget-is-one-tough-recipe

Explore resources available from the USDA:

www.choosemyplate.gov

www.fns.usda.gov/cnpp/usda-food-plans-cost-food-reports-monthly-reports

www.choosemyplate.gov/budget-sample-two-week-menus

Talk to us

More in Life

Homemade pot stickers are filled with seasoned ground pork and served with a garlicky dipping sauce. (Gretchen McKay/Pittsburgh Post-Gazette/TNS)
Make these pork pot stickers with soy-garlic dipping sauce

These dumplings are a toothsome marriage of crispy (on the outside) and tender (on the inside).

Caleb McArthy, 17, left, and Hank McCarroll, 15, right, wear bandana masks while skateboarding on Friday, May 8, 2020 in Langley, Wa. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
5 reasons to wear a mask even after you’re vaccinated

Health experts explained why Americans should hold on to their masks until the pandemic is over.

Keep watch for studies about the benefits of wine and cheese

More research looks at certain components in food that may be helpful to our thinking as we age.

Rocky Oliphant gets a flu shot at the Everett Clinic on Tuesday, Oct. 2, 2018 in Everett, Wa. (Andy Bronson / The Herald)
COVID precautions are helping to keep the flu in check

Evidence suggests that infections are down, likely due to COVID-19 social distancing and mask wearing.

Ask a pediatrician: How much gaming is too much for children?

About 10% of teens had symptoms of unhealthy gaming that got worse over time. They have a few things in common.

Piselli (braised peas in tomato) from "Frugal Mediterranean Cooking" by Melanie Lionello (Page Street Publishing Co., 2020).

(Courtesy of Melanie Lionello)
Frozen peas, canned tomatoes a healthy, penny-pinching dish

An Italian grandmother’s recipe for piselli — braised peas in tomato sauce — costs 91 cents per serving.

John and Rebecca Roberts have been trail angels for the Pacific Northwest Trail since 2012.  (Kevin Clark / The Herald)
Whidbey wandering on the rugged Pacific Northwest Trail

The trail snakes down the island on its often-confounding route from the Rocky Mountains to the Pacific Ocean.

Trapped in her room by a tricky doorknob, a sixth-grade girl relies on her brother to hear her cries for help. (Jennifer Bardsley)
A family comes together to solve a middle-of-the-night crisis

She was grateful that her son had heard his sister’s call for help. His late-night hours had proven useful.

Rue Cler’s stores make picnic-shopping fun in Paris.
Rick Steves’ Europe: Fine living at a Paris street market

Parisians shop almost daily because their tiny kitchens have tiny refrigerators, and fresh produce makes for a good meal.

Most Read