Jessica Rothe is stalked by “Babyface” in the horror sequel “Happy Death Day 2U.” (Universal Studios)

Jessica Rothe is stalked by “Babyface” in the horror sequel “Happy Death Day 2U.” (Universal Studios)

‘Happy Death Day 2U’ revisits ‘Groundhog Day’-meets-mayhem gimmick

The formula is tweaked a tad, but it’s just a setup for another movie, provided this one makes money.

  • Thursday, February 14, 2019 4:25pm
  • Life

By Pat Padua / The Washington Post

The 2017 thriller “Happy Death Day” took a “Groundhog Day”-like concept — a young woman must relive the same day, over and over — and put it in service of a largely uninspired college-set horror movie. (Turns out the day in question is the day of the protagonist’s murder, which she must re-experience until she solves the crime.)

But unlike the 1993 Bill Murray comedy, some people never learn from their mistakes, no matter how often they repeat them. Case in point: the sequel “Happy Death Day 2U.” The new film may seem unnecessary — and it is — but it actually does a bit more than just regurgitate the premise of the first film.

The story begins at the fictional Bayfield University with Ryan (Phi Vu), a gifted science major, waking up in his car. After experiencing a sequence of minor incidents that you can bet will be repeated — a dog barks, a skateboarder nearly hits him, etc. — Ryan joins a group of friends at the high-tech lab where they’re working on what amounts to a time machine: the kind of spark-throwing electromagnetic behemoth that drives countless sci-fi films, and that in this case creates not only an unintentional time loop, but also alternate timelines in which the identity of a killer (yes, there’s another one) changes.

At first, Ryan seems to be the focus of this crisis in the space-time continuum, but soon the young woman from the first film — Tree (Jessica Rothe), or as Ryan calls her, the “crazy white chick” — is once again the center of the film’s, and the murderer’s, attention. Together, she and Ryan must solve a new problem, which entails identifying one of several timelines as the “right” one. In these parallel universes, it isn’t just Tree who is threatened, but her friends.

In the first film, repetition worked against the kind of tension that builds suspense. But by taking over screenwriting duty from Scott Lobdell, who wrote the original, returning director Christopher Landon finds inventive and unexpected ways to tweak the formula. For example, he leans even harder into a tone of satire that was only hinted at in the first film: Bayfield’s sports mascot — the Bayfield Baby, an adult in a baby mask — infantilizes the students who adopt the costume, reducing them to caricatures of infants, sucking at giant novelty baby bottles whenever the basketball team sinks one in the big game.

This time, “Death Day” has ambitions, posing questions that other slasher films wouldn’t touch. Is the self-absorbed Tree caught in a cycle of repetition so that she can become a better person? Or is she just collateral damage in some careless classmates’ ultimately meaningless science experiment?

The first time around, Tree’s character development seemed rushed. But now that she’s had two whole movies to learn about what matters in life, the opportunity seems to have only given her the chance to make new mistakes. It’s a “Fantasy Island”-esque dilemma: If we had the chance to pick and choose things to change in our lives, would that be a dream come true, or a nightmare? As one of her time-warping classmates says, “We’re messing with things we shouldn’t be touching.”

Ultimately, “Happy Death Day 2U” doesn’t live up to its aspirations. Landon’s script may be better than his direction, but he leaves a potentially resonant subplot — one that involves existential questions — flat and lifeless, as if our most important choices were of no more consequence than a joystick maneuver.

By the time the climax arrives, “Happy Death Day 2U” has lost its thread, in an increasingly busy “Scooby Doo”-style adventure that, sadly, only points to the possibility of a “Happy Death Day 3-peat.”

“Happy Death Day 2U” (1½ stars)

This sequel to the 2017 horror-comedy outing finds that film’s heroine back in the time loop facing another killer — who this time is after her friends. Everything culminates with a setup to another sequel — in other words, there’s no happy ending.

Rating: PG-13, for violence and language

Showing: Alderwood, Alderwood Mall, Cinebarre Mountlake Terrace, Everett Stadium, Galaxy Monroe, Marysville, Meridian, Oak Tree, Pacific Place, Thornton Place, Woodinville, Cascade Mall

Talk to us

More in Life

Snohomish artist Cathy Tanasse works on facial proportions on one of her "Memory Project" portraits on Friday, March 19, 2021 in Snohomish, Wa. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Cruise lines can soon begin trial voyages in U.S. waters with volunteer passengers helping test whether the ships can sail safely during a pandemic.The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention gave ship operators final technical guidelines Wednesday for the trial runs. The CDC action is a step toward resuming cruises in U.S. waters, possibly by July, for the first time since March 2020.A spokeswoman for the cruise industry’s tour group said the group was reviewing the CDC instructions.Each practice cruise — they’ll run two to seven days — must have enough passengers to meet at least 10% of the ship’s capacity. Volunteers must be 18 or older and either fully vaccinated or free of medical conditions that would put them at high risk for severe COVID-19.The ship operator must tell passengers that they are simulating untested safety measures “and that sailing during a pandemic is an inherently risky activity,” the CDC guidelines state.Passengers must be examined for COVID-19 symptoms before and after the trip, and at least 75% must be tested at the end.Restrictions on board will include face masks and social distancing. The CDC will allow guided shore excursions — no wandering about on their own — if tour operators follow certain standards.Ships must make at least one practice run before resuming regular cruises in U.S. waters, although operators will be able to avoid the requirement if they vouch that 98% of crew and 95% of passengers are vaccinated.

Cathy Tanasse, a retired Glacier Peak High School art teacher, draws portraits of strangers as gifts.

Billy Crystal (left) and Tiffany Haddish in "Here Today." (Sony Pictures/Stage 6/TNS)
‘Here Today’ showcases Billy Crystal … but not much else

The star wrote himself a role that showcases his signature charm, but he neglected to give his supporting cast anything to work with.

Make a batch of chocolate chip sable cookies for Mother's Day. (Tulalip Resort Casino)
Celebrate Mom’s special day with special chocolate chip cookies

These chocolate chip sable cookies are great for afternoon tea, and store well in the freezer for future in indulgences.

Chefs Renee Erickson and Bobby Palmquist collect Dungeness crabs. Illustrates FOOD-CHEF (category d), by Shauna James Ahern, special to The Washington Post. Moved Monday, Jan. 5, 2015. (MUST CREDIT: Jim Henkens)
Seattle chef’s cookbook has fresh ideas for Cinco de Mayo

Renee Erickson recipe for shrimp cocktail will transport you to a beach in western Mexico.

Olivia Vanni / The herald 
Keger paints the final touches on his work in Everett.
Everett’s a canvas for nation’s most talented graffiti artists

Graffiti on downtown buildings, painted with the owners’ permission, showcases the street art.

Here are practical tips for easing the mental load that parents — and especially mothers — carry. (Jennifer Bardsley)
How to call your mind back home after it has wandered away

Here are some tips for easing the mental load that parents — and especially mothers — carry.

Deal with pandemic fatigue by leaning into your experience

Don’t push your malaise away or distract yourself. Pay attention to how you feel, and see what happens.

CAPTION: Escargot — a hit with the French.
Rick Steves’ Europe: Escargot and the beauty of Terroir

But these days, the top-quality, free-range snails most likely last slithered in Poland.

Can she get a refund for her nonrefundable hotel?

After the COVID-19 outbreak, Noemi Freeman has to cancel her trip to Greece. Does this mean she loses the $592 she paid for her hotel?

Most Read