Local companies work to protect birds, power lines

  • By Sharon Wootton
  • Friday, November 29, 2013 11:21am
  • Life

Snow geese by the thousands and trumpeter swans by the dozens have returned to Snohomish and Skagit counties for the winter.

Coyotes, vehicles and hunters will be responsible for most of their deaths, but there is another danger: Power lines, and death by electrocution or collision.

The first reported eagle death by powerline was recorded in 1922 in the Midwest. In the 1970s, concerns about increasing deaths reached a tipping point and environmental regulations began to address the problem.

Motivated by the U.S. Department of Fish &Wildlife, the Migratory Bird Treaty Act, and pressure from environmental groups, power companies developed avian protection plans and made changes to modify their infrastructure in some areas to lower bird mortality.

It’s difficult to, with absolute certainty, compare numbers of deaths from year to year locally or nationally. The Avian Bird Conservancy says that millions of birds are thought to die each year from interacting with power lines.

Snohomish County PUD and Puget Sound Energy provide energy to much of Western Washington.

Efforts to reduce avian deaths include wood pole-top caps, insulator covers, bird-flight diverters, insulated wires, perch deterrents and more distance between wires.

The Stanwood is an area of concern, said PUD environmental affairs manager Christoph Enderlein, because farm fields and crops tilled under attract feeding trumpeter swans. They may take off or land in low-light conditions and collide with power lines.

“We’ve installed bird flight diverters on each of the wires to make them more visible for birds (and) constantly make modifications.”

Sometimes geography makes a difference.

In eagle country in the Rockport area, there have been no reports of electrocuted eagles, according to PSE, because eagles use trees, not power poles.

An osprey nest on top of a pole can lead to bird deaths and sparks that could cause a fire. Rather than remove a Gold Bar nest, the PUD put up a second set of crossarms below the nest and transferred the electrical wire.

“You can make a case for significant modification such as changing or replacing crossarms because a death could lead to taking a line out of service, grounding, replacing and reenergizing. That’s a cost to the district plus it impacts customers,” Enderlein said.

This year the PUD has had 18 incidents of deaths, including three by collision.

In 1999, a Colorado power company was ordered to pay $100,000 in fines and restitution, and ordered to retrofit their lines with bird-safety devices after being found guilty of violating the MBTA and the Bald and Golden Eagle Act.

This raised the profile of the issue and sent a strong (and financial) message to utilities around the country.

In 2000, PSE began to track and record bird-caused outages.

Mel Waters, wildlife biologist for Puget Sound Energy, said the company has systematically been installing protective devices as well as using different pole designs.

“Laws protect birds, and that’s the right thing to do. But we can’t do everything at once. People would complain about electric rates,” Walters said.

“But taking (killing intentionally or by accident) is a violation of the Migratory Bird Treaty Act. But environmental laws don’t always have teeth to them. PSE is happy to say we’re trying to do the right thing,” Walters said.

“Our progressive model is a model program for the state. Our advantage is that we’re big enough and can have a full-time person working on those issues,” he said.

PSE responds to 200 to 250 incidents a year. So how cost-effective is prevention? A service response to a bird-caused outage costs PSE $1,000 to 3,000, not to mention losing a $60,000 transformer.

After a cost-effective analysis, Canadian power companies are protecting all substations.

“In America, people don’t always do what makes sense in long run. We need to look at the long run. PSE has bought into that approach,” Walters said.

Columnist Sharon Wootton can be reached at 360-468-3964 or www.songandword.com.

Talk to us

More in Life

Some pilots land just to eat at Arlington airport restaurant

No measuring spoons: Executive chef LeeWay Morris brings his southern-style cooking to Ellie’s.

Drink This: Distillery switches from gin to hand sanitizer

Lynnwood’s Temple Distilling is now making the alcohol-based cleaner — but you can still order spirits.

We’d like to post your stories of random acts of kindness

Here is your chance to praise someone, thank someone or call attention to something good that’s happened.

Westport Winery transforms storied grapes into hand sanitizer

The Aberdeen winery used riesling to produce the cleaner for law enforcement and first responders.

Spice up dinner with this pizza-flavored chicken burger

Two of America’s favorite foods, pizza and burgers, combine in this pizza chicken burger.

You’ve never seen anything like this woman’s crafting room

Everett resident and retired teacher Melissa Halferty loves all things red, vintage and Frida Kahlo.

With a bidet, TP shortages no longer scare the crap out of us

This family ordered their new toilet just in time. Now bidets are either sold out or on back-order.

While stuck at home, Rick Steves reminiscences about Europe

Edmonds’ travel guru reflects on his favorite memories of experiencing Europe’s living traditions.

These are stressful times

Public Health Essentials! A blog by the Snohomish Health District.

Most Read