Renee Zellweger plays Judy Garland in “Judy,” which takes place over a couple of weeks in the final year of the troubled icon’s life. (LD Entertainment and Roadside Attractions)

Renee Zellweger plays Judy Garland in “Judy,” which takes place over a couple of weeks in the final year of the troubled icon’s life. (LD Entertainment and Roadside Attractions)

Plodding ‘Judy’ biopic doesn’t do the legendary singer justice

Renee Zellweger does her darndest as Judy Garland, but she and the movie aren’t up to the task.

Playing a genius is never easy. Witness the spectacle of “Judy,” a glimpse at the life of Judy Garland. Renee Zellweger grabs the role, wrassles it, huffs and puffs mightily, and uses her own singing skills to approximate Garland’s voice.

The part still defeats her.

In fairness, “Judy” doesn’t give her much help. A plodding account of a few weeks in the last year of Garland’s life, the film fails to find anything new, or even dramatically appealing, to say about this legendary figure.

The setting is 1969 London, where a cash-strapped Garland puts on a sold-out engagement at the Talk of the Town club. She’s left behind her two youngest kids with ex-husband Sid Luft (a quietly exasperated Rufus Sewell) in Hollywood.

Given Garland’s rocky history with insecurity, tardiness and substance ingestion, the engagement has its problems. The movie sets up Judy with a sympathetic handler (Jessie Buckley), yet fails to build a relationship between them.

Buckley, by the way, is an exciting actress whose own talents (especially playing an unstable singer in “Wild Rose”) are in the tradition of Garland’s own. But she’s wasted here.

We watch Garland fret, befriend a couple of gay super-fans (Andy Nyman and Daniel Cerqueira) and impulsively pounce on a handsome young impresario, Mickey Deans (Finn Wittrock). Not much interrupts the downward spiral.

As though trying to provide psychological explanations, screenwriter Tom Edge includes flashbacks to Garland’s youth. On the set of “The Wizard of Oz,” young Judy (Darci Shaw) endures bullying and chugs down an endless supply of pills to help her perform.

If you’re a fan of Hollywood, you know the yellow brick road did not lead to happiness. “Judy” repeats the idea, without expanding on it.

We’re left with watching Zellweger try to capture the essence of a great star. She gets some of Garland’s sauciness — an aspect of Judy’s personality that sometimes gets left out of her tragic life story — and the loneliness, too.

The problem is, you always see the effort. Zellweger burns up so much energy getting the tics and gestures down, she doesn’t really go beyond impersonation.

And then there’s the voice. Instead of lip-synching to Garland’s songs, Zellweger uses her own singing voice. She can handle a tune, and she makes some vocal nods in the direction of how Garland sang, but … come on. Nobody sounds like Judy Garland.

Without Judy’s full-throttle emotional attack, you find yourself watching the onstage performances of “By Myself” and “The Trolley Song” and (but naturally) “Over the Rainbow” and wondering what all the fuss is about.

There’s a great story in the star’s all-or-nothing approach to showbiz, that desperate need to entertain and be loved at the cost of having an ordinary life. This movie doesn’t have much empathy for that kind of need. But it’s a big reason we remember Judy Garland.

“Judy” (2 stars)

Renee Zellweger plays Judy Garland with a great deal of visible effort, but it’s hard to replicate a showbiz genius — and by sticking to a difficult time in Garland’s life, the movie doesn’t help. Also, Zellweger’s singing voice can’t approximate Judy’s full-throttle emotional attack, and you end up wondering what all the fuss was about. With Finn Wittrock.

Rating: PG-13, for subject matter

Opening Friday: Alderwood Mall, Pacific Place, Seattle 10, Thornton Place

Talk to us

More in Life

The hardy fuchsia “Voltaire” is one the few fuchsias that can take full sun all day. (Nicole Phillips)
Eight perennials to add to the garden for summer-long enjoyment

July is a great time to fill in those blank spots with long-blooming perennials. (Yes, it is OK to plant in the summer.)

Kate Jaeger played Gretl and Kevin Vortmann was Hansel in Village Theatre’s “Hansel Gretl Heidi Günter,” which was canceled due to the COVID-19 pandemic. (Tracy Martin / Village Theatre)
COVID-19 curtain drops on a Village Theatre original musical

The lead actor in the canceled show says his disappointment pales next to that of the 10 young actors who were cast in the production.

PUD program now helps 10% more customers pay their bills

Changes to the PUD’s Income Qualified Assistance Program ensure more people will get the help they need.

Museum invites you to add your colors to vintage Northwest art

The Cascadia Art Museum in Edmonds creates a project where people can color woodblock prints. The results will be displayed in the museum’s windows.

A deservedly affectionate portrait of a civil rights icon

“John Lewis: Good Trouble” traces the life and work of a truly towering figure in American history.

Why more men aren’t wearing masks — and how to change that

The four-pronged M.A.S.K. Approach just might convince mask-averse males to do the right thing.

How to confront the disease epedimic in the COVID-19 pandemic

Good health empowers us to cope better and feel better, in mind and body, during turbulent times.

Working toward Phase 3 of a Safe Start for Snohomish County

Public Health Essentials! A blog by the Snohomish Health District.

Hosta ‘Krossa Regal’ has blue foliage from late spring through early fall. In summer, tall flower spikes bear lavender blooms. (Richie Steffen)
Great Plant Pick: Hosta ‘Krossa Regal’ aka ‘Ginba Giboshi’

This hosta has blue foliage from late spring through early fall. In summer, tall flower spikes bear lavender blooms.

Most Read