‘Prodigal Sons’: Stranger than fiction, but queasy-making

  • By Robert Horton Herald Movie Critic
  • Thursday, March 4, 2010 2:24pm
  • LifeGo-See-Do

The title “Prodigal Sons” is tricky and loaded. In this documentary, the sons have complicated stories: One is adopted, and one is a woman.

Filmmaker Kimberly Reed was born Paul McKerrow, and has lived for many years away from her Montana hometown while she has been navigating the trip from male to female.

That story might have served as enough of a topic for a first-person documentary. But “Prodigal Sons” has more on its plate. Lots more.

Reed has a slightly older, adopted brother named Marc. While in his early 20s, Marc suffered a serious brain injury in a car accident, and his mood swings and capacity for violence are only partly controlled by medication.

Marc has been more or less estranged from Kimberly for a while — and that, again, might have been enough for a documentary.

As the movie begins, and Reed returns for her high school reunion (when she was Paul, she was the football team’s star quarterback), where she tries to re-connect with Marc.

But there’s more. In a story that brought national headlines at the time, Marc’s inquiry into the identity of his birth parents led him to a Tacoma woman named Rebecca Welles.

And Rebecca Welles, his birth mother, was the daughter of Orson Welles and Rita Hayworth.

For Marc, whose mental challenges frequently take the form of elaborate resentment about his lot in life, the news that he was the grandson of a cinematic genius and a Hollywood goddess comes as a strange chance at a new kind of identity.

In a visit to Croatia to visit Oja Kodar (the woman who shared Orson Welles’ life for many years), Marc seems to blossom.

It’s fascinating to watch Kodar’s reaction to this unknown connection to her former love — she touches Marc’s face, which strongly resembles his grandfather’s, as though summoning up Orson Welles himself.

As the movie shows, things don’t work into a neat happy ending; More trauma is to come.

All of this is quite arresting to watch, and film buffs with an interest in Welles and Hayworth will be especially intrigued.

Nevertheless, I have lingering unease about the movie. Laying oneself bare is one thing, but “Prodigal Sons” takes on an uncomfortably voyeuristic edge; the camera is running, even in the middle of physically violent confrontations. As fascinating as this family’s tensions are, I couldn’t quite shake the creepiness of that.

Talk to us

More in Life

Head brewer Hollis Wood at Skookum Brewery is leaving Arlington for a job at Ever Grain Brewing in Camp Hill, Pennsylvania. (Andy Bronson / Herald file)
Drink This: Skookum’s head brewer is heading to the East Coast

After 10 years with the Arlington brewery, Hollis Wood will work for Ever Grain Brewing in Pennsylvania.

Seattle Photographer
Celebrate National Pasta Month with fast and easy cacio e pepe

The dish, which translates to “cheese and pepper,” is an upscale Italian version of macaroni and cheese.

Travis Harhai's deep-dish apple crumble pie. (Gretchen McKay/Pittsburgh Post-Gazette/TNS)
This award-winning apple crumb pie wowed ‘em at the county fair

The crumb top is what makes it special, says the novice baker who won the blue ribbon at the fair.

Penn Cover Brewery owners, Mitch and Mark Aparicio, at their new Freeland location on Thursday, July 22, 2021. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Brewery in the barn: Here’s Whidbey’s newest craft-beer hotspot

Penn Cove Brewing Co. has expanded its operations to a scenic spot on Whidbey Island with views of Holmes Harbor and the Olympic Mountains.

The 2022 Honda CR-V Hybrid has five-passenger seating and comes standard with all-wheel drive. (Manufacturer photo)
2022 Honda CR-V Hybrid is the lineup’s fuel economy leader

The hybrid has the same superior qualities as the gasoline version, but is miles ahead in eco status.

Old dogs like Merlin provide great company, even while snoring. (Jennifer Bardsley)
This old dog of mine: A tribute to my fluffy couch potato

Sleeping has become this poodle’s full-time job. He’ll take five naps a day, in between turns around the yard.

Marriage basics: How to resolve your relationship conflicts

The top five sources of conflict in relationships? Sex, money, children, in-laws and household chores.

Romantic lakeside dining in Varenna.
Rick Steves’ Europe: Lago di Como: Where Italians honeymoon

It’s one of several beautiful lakes in Italy’s northern Alpine region, a tourism mecca for centuries.

Wintergreen adds a pop of red to the garden all winter long. (Getty Images)
Though they’re cold, fall and winter can be colorful seasons too

You have no shortage of choices when it comes to planting for fall and winter interest in the garden.

Most Read