Scuttlebutt’s new Barrel-aged Scotch Ale worth the wait

It’s a beer that takes plenty of patience.

Scuttlebutt Brewing’s new Barrel-aged Scotch Ale not only needs to sit and warm up after pouring, but it’s a beer that took a long time to find the right level. And when a barrel-aged beer finds that perfect spot, it can be a beautiful thing.

Scuttlebutt will be pouring the beer Oct. 17 at The Collective on Tap on Camano Island’s Oktoberfest celebration. Bottles of the beer will be available in 22-ounce bottles at Scuttlebutt’s restaurant and brewery starting Oct. 19. They will also be sending a keg to the Elliott Bay Brewing Barrel-Aged Invitational on Nov. 7 at the Lake City Cascade Hall.

Scuttlebutt head brewer Matt Stromberg recently chatted about the long path it took to get the well-balanced Barrel-aged Scotch Ale. Stromberg came up with the original recipe in 2003 and it was based on a recipe he brewed at McMenamins in the late 1990s.

The process started more than two years ago when the Everett brewery received six second-run whiskey barrels from an out-of-state distillery and two first-run barrels from Woodinville Whiskey Company. (The difference between first- and second-run barrels is that second-run barrels have already been used to house beer.)

Stromberg said the brewery decanted two barrels approximately every six months, and that it’s been interesting to observe the changes in the beer over time.

The first two barrels were decanted after about eight months and had a pleasant oak flavor in the beer. After about a year, the second two barrels were decanted and had a much deeper and well-rounded flavor, according to Stromberg.

One of the most interesting beers was the beer aged in the Woodinville Whiskey barrels, which came out shortly after a year. At first, the spirit was overpowering the beer, giving it a distinct sourness, Stromberg said. So, they decided to set the kegs aside and let them age a little longer.

Four months later, Stromberg said, the beer was coming into balance and the sourness was going away. Another two months of waiting and the beer was just right.

“Its deep, round, harmonious flavors resonated,” Stromberg said of the Scotch Ale that came out of the Woodinville Whiskey barrels. “It’s crazy how dramatically things changed.”

Scuttlebutt poured that beer at the Washington Brewers Festival this past June.

As for the Scotch Ale that is bottled now, they came from the final two barrels that were tested at 14 months and was good, but Stromberg said they held off. At 18 months, they noticed some spirit flavors migrating into the beer. They waited another two months, giving the beer a little more spirit flavor.

The finished product is quite the reward. It pours a caramelly dark brown and has a bit of a tight mouth-feel at first. But wait. Stromberg told me to pour it out and wait up to a half hour. So, after an initial taste, I did just that.

The end result is amazing. The beer warms up and brings out a deep, well-rounded spirit flavor to marry with a nice malty backbone. I can’t recommend this beer highly enough.

Well done, Matt and the rest of the brewers at Scuttlebutt.

Aaron Swaney: 425-339-3430; Twitter: @swaney_aaron79. Follow the Hops and Sips blog at

Talk to us

More in Life

Here’s how you can attract birds, including sparrows, to your yard. (Mike Benbow)
The gardener’s playbook for attracting birds to your yard

If you want birds to visit, you’ll need to provide four basic elements: safety, nesting spots, food and water.

Oliver Elf Army
New independent music label launches with a party in Everett

Palmer House specializes in cassette tapes. Oliver Elf Army, I Will Keep Your Ghost and FUNERALHOMES will play at the event.

John Morrison dressed up as Michael Myers wanders through a Halloween scene on Saturday, Oct. 16, 2021 in Arlington, Wa. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Facebook map sets path to Halloween fun around the county

Brandi Smith’s map lists nearly 500 — and counting — addresses for trick-or-treating and spooky decorations.

The green Japanese maple has one of the most brilliant reds of all Japanese maples come fall. (Great Plant Picks)
Great Plant Pick: Acer palmatum ‘Osakazuki’ aka green Japanese maple

Though it’s an understated green, this tree has one of the most brilliant reds of all Japanese maples come fall.

The Snohomish Conservation District is hosting a “Lawns to Lettuce” webinar Nov. 4 via Zoom. (Mark Mulligan / Herald file)
Home and garden events and resources around Snohomish County

Home and garden events and resources around Snohomish County

When your jack-o’-lantern has lost its luster, toss it in the food and yard waste cart. Not the recycling bin. (Waste Management)
The 5 things scare recyclers — keep them out of the blue bin

Check to see if any of these common items have made it into your recycling cart. They make your recycling team scream!

Woodcarver Johannes Scholl went by John after emigrating from Germany to the United States. One of his elaborate folk art whimsies sold at Conestoga Auctions for $4,130. (Cowles Syndicate Inc.)
This folk art whimsy by John Scholl auctioned for over $4,000

A woodworker, Scholl’s carved decorations are thought to be among the most important works of the 20th century.

From left, Zendaya and Timothee Chalamet in the film "Dune." (Warner Bros. Entertainment/TNS)
The new ‘Dune’ is hypnotically beautiful, but is that enough?

This take on Frank Herbert’s epic looks great and isn’t bonkers like the 1984 David Lynch version. But star Timothee Chalamet is bland.

Robbie Dee portrays the King of Rock 'n' Roll in the Elvis tribute Kentucky Rain Band, performing Oct. 29 at the Historic Everett Theatre. (Kentucky Rain Band)
All about music: Schedule of concerts around Snohomish County

The listings include Sir Mix-a-Lot, ZZ Top and Bands, Brews and Bowling at Evergreen Lanes in Everett.

Most Read