Sitcom pacing detracts from sincerity of Braff’s ‘Wish’

  • By Robert Horton Herald Movie Critic
  • Wednesday, July 16, 2014 5:45pm
  • LifeGo-See-Do

In the long-lived sitcom “Scrubs,” Zach Braff proved his comic timing and a willingness to be silly. And like so many actors who succeed with comedy, it seems Braff cannot stop wanting to be serious.

He wrote and directed the 2004 indie hit “Garden State,” which captured a moment for millennial viewers. In that one, the funny stuff was funny, and the serious stuff played like someone wanting to be taken seriously.

Braff’s return to directing is “Wish I Was Here,” and again, comedy is not enough. In this one he stars as Aidan Bloom, an L.A. actor (that is, he auditions for parts he doesn’t get) whose life is frittering away.

He’s embarrassed that his wife Sarah (a nicely understated Kate Hudson) has to work a boring job to keep the family going, and he can’t keep his two kids (Joey King and Pierce Gagnon) in religious school because his orthodox father (Mandy Patinkin) is faced with a cancer challenge and can’t pay their tuition anymore.

Aidan also has a brother (Josh Gad), a nerd-genius type who lives in a trailer and refuses to talk to the father. He’s given a promising but underdeveloped subplot about a neighbor (Ashley Greene) with a hobby of dressing up as furry characters at comic-book conventions.

Around this mid-life stall, the film mostly provides scenes that you’d expect, with lessons learned and small victories gained. Braff’s personality as a filmmaker is unwaveringly earnest, and he presents the most conventional scenes — trying to get his kids to appreciate an epiphany during a camping trip to the desert — as though he really, really means them.

Luckily for the movie, there are funny moments, and Braff actually does have an eye for the stray, telling detail. He’s good at inserting those at key moments, like the waiting-room rack-holder labeled “This Pamphlet Could Save Your Life,” which contains no pamphlets.

The jokes tend to be staged with the rhythm of a sitcom, which is an issue when the movie goes on for a while. Stuff that works in the pell-mell world of something like “Scrubs” just seems weird when placed in a more realistic context like this.

It’s similar enough to “Garden State” that the audience that turned that into a surprise hit might come out again. Some of them actually contributed to its making; “Wish I Was Here” was partly financed through crowd-sourcing fundraising on social media.

However, the “Garden State” audience is now raising kids and dealing with weightier life issues, just like Braff’s characters. That means they don’t go to movies as much anymore. Let’s see if they’re still game for his blend of whimsy and sincerity.

“Wish I Was Here” (two stars)

Director-star Zach Braff follows up his 2004 indie hit “Garden State” with this mid-life crisis movie, which also blends whimsy with sincerity. Kids, jobs and a parent’s illness are the issues on the table, played at a sitcom rhythm that isn’t quite right for a feature length film. Kate Hudson co-stars.

Rating: R, for language, subject matter

Opening: Friday at Guild 45th and Pacific Place

Talk to us

More in Life

Workers prepare to offload Dungeness crab from a boat on Pier 45 in the Fisherman's Wharf district in San Francisco, California, on Jan. 13, 2021. MUST CREDIT: Bloomberg photo by David Paul Morris.
No crabs, no scallops: Seafood is vanishing from menus in U.S.

Seafood prices have risen about 11% over the past year, thanks to congested ports, not enough fishermen and soaring demand.

Laura Smith, with husband Tom, makes Danielle Lam laugh after being presented with a check for $10,000 from The Prize Patrol from Publishers Clearing House on Wednesday, July 28, 2021 in Mukilteo, Washington. (Andy Bronson / The Herald)
‘Holy roses!’ A day in the life of the legendary Prize Patrol

Publishers Clearing House surprised a Mukilteo couple with a sweepstakes prize, flowers and balloons.

Nathan Welton/ Dreamtime Images
Photographer David Welton’s work has appeared in the South Whidbey Record and The Daily Herald.
The camera is Whidbey Island man’s second calling

After retiring from a career in medicine, David Welton of Langley focuses on his first love: photography

Mussels steamed in white wine. (Kristen Mendiola for The Daily Meal; Shannon Kinsella/food styling/TNS)
Here’s how to cook delicious mussels in 5 easy steps

It all begins with the right way to select, store and clean the blue-and-black shellfish.

A zucchini noodle salad with an East Asian-inspired tahini-ginger dressing is an easy, low-carb summer dish. (Gretchen McKay/Pittsburgh Post-Gazette/TNS)
Tahini-ginger noodle salad is the answer to zucchini overload

When you can’t bear the thought of more zucchini bread, give this Asian-inspired dish a try.

Can an air fryer replicate rotisserie chicken? Seventy minutes at 375 degrees comes pretty darn close. (Jennifer Bardsley)
Be careful with those carrots — she’s on an air-frying rampage

After mastering a variety of vegetables, this mom was ready to pop a 4-pound bird into her new air fryer.

How to cope with pandemic letdown in face of delta variant

It’s not over until it’s over. The whole world is still dealing with a COVID-19. It is OK to be disappointed and sad.

The 2021 Jeep Wrangler 4xe plug-in hybrid is available in Sahara, Rubicon, and High Altitude trim levels of the Unlimited (four-door) model. (Manufacturer photo)
Emissions-free off-roading courtesy of 2021 Jeep Wrangler 4xe

The new PHEV version of the perennial all-terrain favorite can go up to 25 miles in full electric mode.

Coffeeshops in Amsterdam sell marijuana.
Rick Steves’ Europe: Dutch Tolerance: Red lights and pot shops

Amsterdam is a laboratory of progressive living, bottled inside Europe’s finest 17th-century… Continue reading

Most Read