The brandy cure and other hypothermia myths

  • By Sharon Wootton
  • Friday, December 30, 2011 5:34pm
  • Life

For the first few decades of my life, I only saw pictures of St. Bernards with a little barrel hung around their necks.

The story was that, for a few centuries, monks at a monastery-run hospice sent out St. Bernards with brandy to warm up hypothermic travelers when they were rescued from snowstorms while crossing Great St. Bernard Pass.

The pass sits about 8,000 feet above sea level on a route through the Alps between Switzerland and Italy.

Great story, except that the brandy barrel is a myth.

According to “The Book of General Ignorance” (John Lloyd and John Mitchinson), in 1831 English artist Sir Edwin Landseer painted a portrait called “Alpine Mastiffs Reanimating a Distressed Traveller” that featured two St. Bernards.

To add a touch of interest, Landseer painted a miniature brandy barrel around its neck. He probably didn’t realize that while alcohol temporarily would make a person feel warmer, it dilates the blood vessels and can lead to more heat loss and can impair judgment.

More heat loss can lead to hypothermia or make existing hypothermia worse, affecting coordination and judgment.

Another myth busted.

Here are a few others, brought to you by researchers and wilderness experts using the latest studies.

It Won’t Happen to Me myth: More people die from hypothermia during the summer than winter. Hypothermia can happen any time the body’s core is lowered below 95 degrees. If it can happen in summer, it can happen to you in winter.

Hits Fast myth: Not so fast. Hypothermia takes time to develop. Don’t panic, because moderate to severe hypothermia takes even longer to develop. How long depends on the person and conditions.

Keep Moving myth: Think about it. You’ve been moving, snowshoeing, skiing, whatever, and your companion has signs of hypothermia: any combination of shivering, exhaustion, confusion, slurred speech or fatigue, or loss of motor control. Why would more exercise cure hypothermia?

Severely hypothermic people shouldn’t even sit, stand or walk until they are warm.

Don’t Take Off Wet Clothes myth: The common rationale is that you’ll be exposing the entire body to the cold if you take off wet clothes, even to put on dry ones. But trust me: Dry is better than wet, even with a temporary exposure to cold.

Naked is Good myth: Take off your clothes and your hypothermic companion’s, and huddle up in a zipped sleeping bag.

No, keep your clothes on. Put an insulating layer on the ground. Wrap the endangered one in dry insulating layers, including a windproof or waterproof layer if available. Put him or her in a sleeping bag or wrap with a blanket. Add a hat.

Shivering is good because it generates heat. Exposing your warm body to a naked cold body just puts you in danger.

Get Hot Quick myth: Do not set your companion in front of a roaring fire. Don’t try to warm the arms and legs with heat packs. Go for the core. If you have them, or even hot cloths, place under the arms or on the chest, groin area or neck, but don’t put them directly on the skin.

Massage or Brisk Rub myth: Sorry, but rubbing your companion is not helpful, especially if frostbite is a possibility. A hypothermic victim needs gentle, slow handling. Remember that in hypothermia, the heart becomes weaker.

Beard and Plush Hair myth: The more beard and head hair, the more warmth. Nope. Our hair isn’t fur. It isn’t dense enough to make any difference.

Anti-hypothermia techniques should work sufficiently for mild hypothermia sufferers to be able to reach civilization and go to a hospital.

If it’s moderate or severe, send for help, which brings us back to the St. Bernards. Historians have estimated that the animals rescued about 2,500 people since 1800.

According to “The Book of General Ignorance,” after 50 years or so of no rescues-by-Bernards, the monastery replaced them with a helicopter.

Columnist Sharon Wootton can be reached at 360-468-3964 or www.songandword.com.

Talk to us

More in Life

This family is no match for a German-made knife. (Jennifer Bardsley)
Any way you slice it, that bread knife is dangerous

Their old bread knife was too dull. The new one is too sharp, apparently.

Marc Price
Yes, that’s Skippy: Alex P. Keaton’s pal to do stand-up in Everett

Marc Price, who appeared on 54 episodes of “Family Ties” in the 1980s, to do a set at Tony V’s Garage on Feb. 9.

An exclusive grille design distinguishes the Denali Ultimate trim from other 2023 GMC Sierra 1500 models. (GMC)
2023 GMC Sierra 1500 Denali Ultimate is brawny but civil

Updates for the brand’s full-size pickup this year include new wheels, new colors and a new trim.

Preparing for the natural end of our lives

Most of us don’t want to talk about death. But we need to be prepared for the inevitable.

The European Parliament in Brussels charts the course of Europe.
Rick Steves’ Europe: Politics, good living and peeing in Brussels

The Belgian capital’s rich brew of food and culture pleasantly surprises those who stop.

AeroMexico canceled her flight, but she wants a refund, not a credit

AeroMexico cancels Patrizia Azzellini’s flight and offers her a ticket credit, but she’d prefer a refund. Who’s right?

Everett Home Depot worker Jeffrey Raven Leonard, 52, holds a certificate that names him a Kentucky Colonel, an honor from the governor of Kentucky. He received the award, given to 4,000 to 5,000 people annually, for getting the word out about a hiring program for veterans at Home Depot. (Annie Barker / The Herald)
This Kentucky Colonel works at Home Depot, not a fried chicken stand

Jeffrey Raven Leonard, 52, of Everett, joins thousands of other colonels honored for good deeds by the governor of Kentucky.

Gin Blossoms
Music, theater and more: What’s happening in Snohomish County

Tickets are on sale now for the Gin Blossoms gig in Tulalip. A variety of local music, from rock to classical, can be heard this weekend in Everett.

LoveZone owners Katrina Cooney and husband Kevin Cooney at their store on Wednesday, Jan. 25, 2023 in Everett, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Does your Valentine want candy — or a trip to the Love Zone?

The adult store has 27 years of experience selling products to spice up romance, with stores in Everett and Marysville.

2023 Toyota Highlander (Toyota)
2023 Toyota Highlander

The 2023 Lexus IS 500 F SPORT Premium is as good as it gets for a luxury sports sedan at a mid-grade price.

Tala Davey-Wraight, 3, is thrown in the air by her dad Oscar Davey-Wraight, one of the Summer Meltdown headliners also known as Opiuo, during Cory Wong’s set on Thursday, July 28, 2022 in Snohomish, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
After Monroe debut, no Summer Meltdown music fest in 2023

Organizers announced Wednesday they would “take the year off in order to figure out the best path forward for Summer Meltdown in 2024.”

We don’t know whose eye is depicted in this miniature, but it must have been someone well loved. Wearing a miniature painting of a loved one’s eye was fashionable in the 18th and 19th centuries.
Soapy TV show inspires interest in 19th century accessory

An eye miniature on a pendant, as seen on “Bridgerton,” sells for $704 at auction.