‘The Monk’ needs more juice from scandalous source material

Beating Mary Shelley’s “Frankenstein” by a couple of decades, the novel “The Monk” was published to scandalized acclaim in 1796.

Its author, Matthew Lewis, stirred up a messy controversy with the apparently sacrilegious book and its stylings have kept it notorious as a key Gothic novel.

None of which quite explains why director Dominik Moll, who hadn’t made a movie since 2005’s eerie “Lemming,” decided to revive this property and give it such a straight-ahead adaptation.

He’s aided in his effort by a strong central performance from international star Vincent Cassel, but the film has an oddly non-igniting quality.

The movie has some of the overheated atmosphere of “Les Miz” without the songs. Foundling babies, illicit sex and evil doings swirl around a Spanish monastery, where a particularly devout monk named Ambrosio (played by Cassel) is prized for his charismatic sermons.

The strangest of the movie’s events is the arrival of a young novitiate, whose face is covered by a mask because of serious burns. The mask suggests that not all is as it seems with this character, but it gets much kinkier than you might think.

A subplot involving a virginal young woman and her earnest suitor is bound to get dragged into the devilish doings.

And don’t think we won’t get a visit from Satan himself; Ambrosio’s spiritual purity is much too prominent not to make itself a target for the devil’s temptations.

If all of this sounds ancient and old-fashioned, that’s the way it plays on screen, too. In his previous films, which along with “Lemming” included the crossover hit “With a Friend Like Harry …,” Moll brought a wry, modern attitude to his Hitchcockian stories.

Not so here; “The Monk” is a straight Gothic cocktail of lightning cracks, trembling innocents and lots of close-ups of stone gargoyles in various stages of horror.

Having said that, the movie should be more devious fun than it is. Vincent Cassel, fresh off effective turns in “Black Swan” and “A Dangerous Method,” gives subtle shading to Ambrosio, and in its own way it’s an admirable performance.

Still, the movie is in dire need of goosing up. When an adaptation of a notorious novel leaves you wondering what all the original scandalous, blasphemous fuss was about, the film has fallen short.

“The Monk” (2 stars)

A notorious Gothic novel from 1796 gets a too-tame adaptation in Dominik Moll’s old-fashioned film. Vincent Cassel (“Black Swan”) gives a subtle performance as a devout priest put in the path of various devilish temptations, but the movie overall needs some goosing, especially given the potentially wild subject matter. In French, with English subtitles.

Rated: R for nudity, subject matter.

Showing: SIFF Uptown.

Talk to us

More in Life

Local artist Gabrielle Abbott with her mural "Grateful Steward" at South Lynnwood Park on Wednesday, April 21, 2021 in Lynnwood, Wash. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Lynnwood mural celebrates the Earth and those who care for it

Artist Gabriella Abbott will discuss “Grateful Steward,” her mural at South Lynnwood Park, in a virtual event April 22.

Peter Rivera and his band will perform April 24 at the Historic Everett Theatre. Rivera was the lead singer for 1970s hitmakers Rare Earth. (www.peterrivera.com)
With Everett gig, Peter Rivera celebrates another day of living

The Rare Earth lead singer and drummer headlines a show Saturday at the Historic Everett Theatre.

Photo by Kira Erickson/South Whidbey Record
Ron Rois, left, and his partner, Stefen Bosworth, are transplants from the Chicago area with roots in the Pacific Northwest. They are the owners of Langley's newest restaurant, Savory.
New Whidbey Island restaurant serves ‘eclectic comfort food’

Owners Stefen Bosworth and Ron Rois offer cozy dining overlooking Saratoga Passage.

The beer is flowing again at Snohomish County breweries as COVID-19 restrictions ease. (Kevin Clark / Herald file)
Drink This: Raise a pint to breweries that survived COVID-19

The Herald’s beer aficionado enjoyed a beer crawl from Everett’s At Large Brewing to 5 Rights in Marysville.

Shrimp scampi -- paired with an islandtini -- is a best seller at The Kitchen at the new Quil Ceda Creek Casino. (Quil Ceda Creek Casino)
Taste of Tulalip: Pair shrimp scampi with an islandtini

The Italian-American seafood dish is a best seller at The Kitchen at the new Quil Ceda Creek Casino.

Fattoush is a chopped Levantine salad made with stale pita. This includes shredded chicken tossed in a citrusy tahini-sumac dressing. (Gretchen McKay/Post-Gazette/TNS)
Eat This: Fattoush with chicken and tahini-sumac dressing

The Mediterranean salad is made with chopped lettuce, cucumbers, radishes and fried or baked pita bread.

When Transient Global Amnesia strikes, the past three months become hard to remember. (Jennifer Bardsley)
The Friday I forgot is one to remember

A sudden — thankfully, temporary — episode of memory loss gave me an opportunity to reflect.

John D. Osterman at 98 years old. (Jeanne-Marie Osterman)
An Everett native pays a poetic tribute to her father

“Shellback” is a collection of narrative poems honoring John D. Osterman, a lifelong Everett resident and WWII veteran.

Horizontal double headlights and an enormous grille are key players in the 2021 Genesis G80 redesign. (Manufacturer photo)
Genesis gains ground with 2021 makeover of G80 luxury sedan

It offers two new engines, top-notch design, zesty performance, blue-ribbon build quality and value.

Most Read