‘The Oath’: Gitmo prisoner profile compelling

  • By Robert Horton Herald Movie Critic
  • Wednesday, June 16, 2010 7:08pm
  • LifeGo-See-Do

Just when you thought you’d seen every angle on the “war on terror,” along comes a documentary film, “The Oath,” that finds a new way in.

Filmmaker Laura Poitras apparently set out to look at Guantanamo prisoner Salim Hamdan, the former chauffeur of Osama bin Laden, whose landmark lawsuit saw the U.S. Supreme Court siding with his arguments in a 2006 decision.

Because Hamdan chose not to be interviewed for the movie, he remains a somewhat ghostly figure. His letters are read aloud, in compensation.

We do see quite a bit of his military defense attorney, Lt. Cmdr. Charles Smith, a spit-and-polish career Navy man whose frustration with the Guantanamo system is apparent in every statement he makes. (Actually, Smith is not a career Navy man; the Navy declined to promote him after he won the Supreme Court rulings, and he was forced to retire according to policy.)

But taking center stage — in fact, rather hogging it — is Hamdan’s brother-in-law, a man who calls himself Abu Jandal, a name he took when he devoted himself to jihad, al-Qaida-style. For a while he was bin Laden’s bodyguard.

Now Abu Jandal lives in Yemen and drives a taxi, where he dickers with passengers over the fare and recruits young people to, apparently, the cause of jihad — if not al-Qaida-related, at least a general sort of anti-American attitude and focus.

This contradictory and bizarre character becomes the true subject of the movie. On the one hand, he says he fears for his life because he speaks openly about the inner workings of al-Qaida (thus violating an oath to bin Laden, which was apparently something along the lines of the “Fight Club” rule of silence), but on the other hand, he continues babbling “death to the West” rhetoric.

A slippery fellow, to be sure, and the fact that you can never be quite sure how to believe his statements keeps us alert around him. He even rationalizes eating Western-made cookies, which makes you wonder what else he justifies.

It’s enough to make “The Oath” an absorbing character study, if a very depressing film. Underlying all the information here is that the recruiting of jihadists and anti-U.S. sentiment are running higher today than they were before Sept. 11, 2001, something the film reminds us of with regularity.

Talk to us

More in Life

Brian Geppert holds a birdhouse made of skis at his home in Lynnwood, Washington on Saturday, March 11, 2023. Geppert started a recycling program for the greater Seattle area, which has saved hundreds of skis from their demise. He turns the skis into functional art for the home, such as coat racks, bottle openers, bookends, shelves, candle sconces, toilet plungers, beer flights, and more. (Annie Barker / The Herald)
Boeing engineer turns old ski gear into household essentials

If Lynnwood’s Brian Geppert isn’t on the slopes, then he’s turning skis into coat racks and bottle openers.

Give your home some extra love with a deep clean this spring. (Jennifer Bardsley)
Roll up your sleeves and tackle these 15 spring cleaning steps

A lot of work? Sure. But it beats paying $800 for a cleaning service to do all this stuff.

What to do when a co-worker makes you miserable

It’s counterintuitive, but you need to get to know that person better. You don’t need to be friends — just understand them better.

Lyft charged her $150 for mud stains in a car. But she didn’t do it!

Debbie Kim is shocked to find a $150 charge from Lyft on her credit card. What did she do — and is there a way to undo it?

In this side-by-side image, the Totem Diner and Pacific Stone Company signs put on a flirty display for all to see Wednesday, March 22, 2023, in Everett, Washington. (Ryan Berry / The Herald)
Signs of love on Rucker Ave: blushing rocks, scrambled eggs, a coffee date

Messages on display on Totem Family Diner and Pacific Stone Co. signs reveal “secret crushes.” More updates expected.

Comedian Jeff Dye is scheduled to do a show March 25 in Everett. (Associated Press)
Music, theater and more: What’s happening in Snohomish County

Comedian Jeff Dye does a set in Everett on Saturday. And country star Tracy Byrd performs locally Friday.

Some of the brightest spots in my garden right now are my clumps of mixed crocuses. (Getty Images)
Lessons spring from what does and does not winter over

Taking stock of how your garden fared through the cold, wet months will help you plant for the future.

Antique mocha ware, made in England to export to the United States and Canada in the 18th and 19th centuries, caught collectors’ attention in the mid-20th century. Like many mocha pieces, this colorful mug is decorated with several patterns.
The name for decorated pottery like this can be deceiving

Mocha pottery is made from clay and features colorful patterns painted over a white glaze.

The 2023 Infiniti QX60 is powered by a V6 engine paired with a nine-speed automatic transmission. (Infiniti)
2023 Infiniti QX60 offers luxury at an attractive price

All four trim levels of this mid-size SUV come generously equipped with premium features as standard.

Most Read