Tone and timing of ‘One Day’ are off

  • By Robert Horton Herald Movie Critic
  • Friday, August 19, 2011 12:01am
  • Life

The gimmick of “One Day,” which covers two decades, is that everything we witness takes place on July 15, St. Swithin’s Day, each year.

It’s the day acquaintances Emma (Anne Hathaway) and Dexter (Jim Sturgess) get to know each other just as they are leaving college in Edinburgh. And, via the structure of novelist-screenwriter David Nicholls, we keep checking in with these two lovebirds as they spend years denying the fact that they obviously want to be together.

Obnoxious, substance- abusing Dexter (no wonder Emma loves him, right?) becomes mildly famous as a variety-show presenter on British television. But surely he will one day realize that his life of cocaine and supermodels is empty and shallow.

Emma goes through a mousy phase but eventually finds her writing voice. Much quicker with a wisecrack and kinder of heart than Dexter, she makes you wonder why she’d still be thinking about this heel after all these years.

I can see how a novel could skip from year to year and have time to give these characters some richness and heft. The movie, unfortunately, needs to squeeze 20 years’ worth of scenes into 108 minutes, which means we skip along all too quickly in most of the segments.

“One Day” is the first dud from the Danish director Lone Scherfig, who did “An Education” and the wonderful “Wilbur Wants to Kill Himself.” The quick-stepping structure makes it hard for Scherfig to establish a sense of place, which is one of her strengths, although Edinburgh looks very lovely in the opening and closing sequences.

Worse, Scherfig’s touch with the two lead performers is off. I don’t have a beef with the casting of an American star as a Brit (hey, Renee Zellweger did just fine as the ultra-English Bridget Jones), but Anne Hathaway floats through this one with a strangely weightless quality; she seems halting and hesitant, as though worried about mispronouncing words.

Jim Sturgess has been likable in movies as different as “Across the Universe” and “The Way Back,” but in order to ring true, Dexter needs more authentic wildness. Sturgess comes across as a decent bloke pretending to have movie problems.

Perhaps you will find yourself with the intended sense of urgency about these two getting together. I didn’t feel urgency, just impatience.

A late-story plot development comes along just when you expect it to, and its shock effect feels especially manipulative. Skillfully done, but manipulative, and at that point I began to resent the movie even more than I already did.

“One Day”

Every July 15th, we check in on the friendship of two Brits (Anne Hathaway, Jim Sturgess), who can’t recognize that they are actually in love with each other, although the audience can. This contrivance becomes a test of patience, and director Lone Scherfig can’t wring much appeal out of the two lead actors.

Rated: PG-13 for language, subject matter.

Showing: Everett Stadium, Galaxy Monroe, Marysville, Pacific Place, Seven Gables, Thornton Place, Cascade Mall.

Talk to us

More in Life

Washington’s most beloved state park turns 100

Deception Pass State Park, which draws as many visitors as the best-known national parks in the U.S., celebrates a century of recreation and conservation

Hydrangea and rose
July checklist for Snohomish County gardeners

After a slow start to summer, things should take off this month. So keep planting and nurturing.

Caption: The 12 week Edmonds Community Police Academy was a free opportunity for private citizens to learn about law enforcement.
An inside look at how law enforcement works

A pregnant mother. A man who rescues abused horses and donkeys. A… Continue reading

Kid 'n Play members Christopher "Kid" Reid, left, and Christopher "Play" Martin perform on NBC's "Today" show during the "I Love The 90's" morning concert at Rockefeller Plaza on Friday, April 29, 2016, in New York. (Photo by Charles Sykes/Invision/AP)
Music, theater and more: What’s happening in Snohomish County

Relive the music of the 1990s with Kid N Play and other stars of the era at the Tulalip Casino Amphitheater.

So-called relaxing summer vacations can wear you out

To truly enjoy a family getaway, tone down your expectations. Everything won’t be picture-perfect.

Gimmelwald, built in an avalanche zone, yet specializing in alpine tranquility.
Roaming the Alps brings cultural insights along with the views

The Swiss have great respect for Alpine traditions and culture — and contempt for tourists who disrespect both.

Will TripMate cover costs for trip canceled for medical reasons?

After Stanley Wales cancels his diving trip to Bonaire, he files a travel insurance claim with TripMate. What’s taking them so long to respond?

Contestant chef Brian Madayag (left) of Edmonds and West Coast team captain Brooke Williamson on “Beachside Brawl.” (Food Network) 20220616
Edmonds chef reps Pacific Northwest on new Food Network show

Barkada owner Brian Madayaga will compete on a new Food Network series that premiers Sunday.

Chamaecyparis obtusa ‘Kosteri’ (Richie Steffen)
Great Plant Pick: Chamaecyparis obtusa ‘Kosteri’

This Hinoki cypress is graceful and beautiful, and is very drought-tolerant once established.

Most Read