Weird tone is the biggest mystery in ‘Gone Girl’

  • By Robert Horton Herald Movie Critic
  • Wednesday, October 1, 2014 3:37pm
  • LifeGo-See-Do

You’ve got to admire the confidence of “Gone Girl”: this truly odd movie coughs up a bizarre story line mixed with comic social commentary, but it never loses its swagger. Being the eagerly awaited adaptation of a best-selling page-turner will encourage that kind of attitude, I guess.

Gillian Flynn’s 2012 novel has a few twists up its bloodied sleeve, but we’ll be discreet here. The story begins with the disappearance of Amy (Rosamund Pike) from her unloved Missouri home, and escalates into a media circus as suspicion is cast on her husband Nick (Ben Affleck).

Nick has the help of his sister (Carrie Coon) and a celebrity lawyer (Tyler Perry, excellent), but his status in the public eye is dismal. Meanwhile, we see excerpts from Amy’s diary, which fill in the picture of a marriage gone sour.

The TV-style cops on the case are quirkily played by Kim Dickens and Patrick Fugit. In fact, part of the kick of “Gone Girl” is the unexpected cast. This includes “Madea” man Tyler Perry playing it straight, Neil Patrick Harris and Scoot McNairy as eccentric exes from Amy’s past, and model Emily Ratajkowski as a young woman of intrigue.

Affleck brings his doofus side out, looking beefy and just a bit slow on the uptake. Pike, who’s gone good duty in “Jack Reacher” and “The World’s End,” is ideal for the smart but super-controlling Amy.

This story might have been a clean, dark suspense tale. But Flynn (who adapted the screenplay herself) and “Zodiac” director David Fincher have gone in an unexpected direction — it’s the biggest twist of all. “Gone Girl” is not a thriller but a satire, one that reaches for things to say about modern society, and all that.

The peculiar tone takes some getting used to. Yes, there’s a woman missing and evidence of violence, but these cops sure are funny.

Fincher is a gifted filmmaker, although the role of social satirist (as in “Fight Club,” or “The Social Network”) is not his best mode. Most of the targets here, from media goons to suburban small-mindedness, are past their freshness date.

Some of this is redeemed by the film’s eerie momentum, even when the chronology flips back and forth. Scenes quickly fade to black and then just as quickly come up on some new revelation.

Weird film. “Gone Girl” is an outlandish subject with an A-list treatment, and its cynicism is striking. An interesting spectacle to watch, for sure, but for me the movie rings hollow at its core.

“Gone Girl” (2 1/2 stars)

A missing wife (Rosamund Pike) and a husband (Ben Affleck) under suspicion are the ingredients of this truly odd adaptation of Gillian Flynn’s bestseller. Director David Fincher goes for social satire — the movie isn’t really much of a thriller — which gives the whole thing a hollow ring. Great cast, including Tyler Perry and Neil Patrick Harris.

Rating: R, for nudity, violence, language

Showing: Alderwood Mall, Cinebarre Mountlake Terrace, Everett Stadium, Galaxy Monroe, Marysville, Stanwood Cinemas, Meridian, Sundance Cinemas Seattle, Thornton Place Stadium 14, Woodinville, Cascade Mall.

Talk to us

> Give us your news tips.

> Send us a letter to the editor.

> More Herald contact information.

More in Life

Animal Chaplain Shel Graves has her dog Lily pose for a photo in her home office on Tuesday, July 9, 2024 in Everett, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Is your dog or cat grieving? There’s an animal chaplain for that

Chaplains offer spiritual care for beings of all species: “Absolutely, animals do feel grief and loss.”

Performers joust during the Washington Midsummer Renaissance Faire at Sky Meadows Park in Snohomish, Washington, on Sunday, Aug. 06, 2023. (Annie Barker / The Herald)
Royalty and revelry: The spirit of the Renaissance comes to Monroe

The annual Renaissance fair will open its doors every weekend from July 20 to Aug. 18

Trees and foliage grow at the Rockport State Park on Wednesday, April 3, 2024 in Rockport, Washington. (Annie Barker / The Herald)
When you get lost in WA, what’s the cost to get rescued? Surprisingly little

Washington’s volunteer search and rescue teams save lives without costly bills.

A booking error leads to a nonrefundable hotel room, or does it?

Glen Hartness books the wrong night at La Quinta through the Priceline app. Why won’t Priceline refund the booking?

Mona Newbauer, 62, pours caramel into a machine inside her store Sweet Mona's Chocolates on March 21, 2024 in Langley, Washington. (Annie Barker / The Herald)
Sweet Mona’s Chocolates in Langley stirs up treats for all tastes

Chocolate slugs, whales, truffles and caramels are among sweets in the shop Mona Newbauer founded in 2006.

Music, theater and more: What’s happening in Snohomish County

What do Patti Labelle, John Legend, Mudhoney, Dwight Yoakam have in common? They’re all performing locally this weekend.

Crape Myrtle
Hardiness, hotter summers helping colorful crape myrtles find homes here

Many are hardy enough, but we were never hot enough. In recent summers, however, I’ve seen them blooming in local gardens.

I scream, you scream, we all scream for … glace? Well, in France, yes.

This ice cream vendor toy, which sold for $1,800 at auction, reminds us of France’s role in popularizing the summer treat.

Lily of the Scheherazade variety with red-white flowers from the Oriental-Tubular (OT) hybrids group. Decorative plant in the garden
Great Plant Pick: Scheherazade Orienpet Lily

What: Once mature, this giant lily makes a stunning presence in the… Continue reading

The 2024 Ford F-150 full-size pickup. The Platinum trim is shown here. (Photo provided by Ford)
2024 Ford F-150 is a cornucopia of varieties

2024 Ford F-150 is a cornucopia of varieties

2024 Mercedes E 350 4MATIC sedan (Photo provided by Mercedes)
2024 Mercedes E 350 4MATIC sedan

In this time of rapid change in the automotive industry, it’s nice… Continue reading

The 2025 Lexus UX 300h is the luxury brand’s smallest and most affordable SUV. (Photo provided by Lexus)
2025 Lexus UX 300h gets more horsepower, keeps great MPG

The luxury brand’s smallest SUV is available only as a hybrid.

Support local journalism

If you value local news, make a gift now to support the trusted journalism you get in The Daily Herald. Donations processed in this system are not tax deductible.