What happens when MyPlate sets the menu? A starch overload

What happens when MyPlate sets the menu? A starch overload

The USDA Food Plan considers potatoes, corn and frozen juice concentrate as produce.

This month, my family is doing the MyPlate on My Budget challenge. Can my family of four follow the USDA’s MyPlate guidelines and also stick to their thrifty budget as defined by the USDA Food Plan: Cost of Food Report?

For my family of two adults and two children, this means spending $158.30 on food. To help simplify things, I’m using a two-week sample menu plan available on ChooseMyPlate.gov.

Last week, I shared the story of my epic shopping trip at the grocery store, purchasing the 109 items needed to make the first week of food. The final total was $182.45, which amounted to $24.15 over budget. When my family saw the wide assortment of groceries I brought home, they had questions. Would we really be able to drink four gallons of milk in one week? Just how many peanut butter and jelly sandwiches would we have to eat?

As the primary chef in the house, my concern was the amount of labor involved in preparing 21 meals from scratch, without conveniences like baby carrots or skinless chicken thighs to help me out. I was also worried about nutrition. Would we eat enough fruits and vegetables? Theoretically MyPlate is based on the concept that every meal should be made up of half fruits and vegetables. But the USDA considers potatoes, corn and frozen juice concentrate as produce. Luckily none of us are diabetic.

The first night of cooking, the meal plan had me bake four pounds of chicken that would be used for three different meals. Along with a portion of the honey-lemon chicken, I served frozen peas and corn, and brown rice pilaf for dinner, plus a homemade chocolate chip cookie and a glass of milk for dessert. Everything was surprisingly tasty, and our challenge was off to a great start.

My fears about the plan requiring too much time in the kitchen were unfounded because the recipes were easy and we sometimes ate leftovers for lunch. Frozen vegetables are in their own way a convenience food, and I learned a delicious new way to cook them. Lay out the vegetables on a foil-lined sheet plan, sprinkle with olive oil, salt and pepper, and roast in a 500-degree oven for 26 minutes.

But not everything about the meal plan made sense. The fish dinner, for example, called for couscous with peas and onions plus a white dinner roll. Two starches in one meal? It felt like a time warp to the 1950s. A few days later, when it was time to serve lentil stew, we hit a mountain of starch. The menu called for lentils, brown rice and a slice of whole wheat bread.

My teenage son loved the plan because almost every meal included a glass of milk. The rest of us hit milk overload pretty fast. By day seven, we’d only drunk two of the four gallons of milk. We also had a dozen eggs left, a package of tofu and two bags of frozen vegetables, but had run out of fresh produce.

At the end of week one, my family agreed that so far, our challenge was a success — except the part about being $24.15 over budget. By that measure, we’d already failed.

Learn more

Read Jennifer Bardsley’s original MyPlate on My Budget articles from 2013:





Explore resources available from the USDA:




Talk to us

More in Life

Veteran Keith F. Reyes, 64, gets his monthly pedicure at Nail Flare on Tuesday, Dec. 21, 2021 in Stanwood, Wa. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
No more gnarly feet: This ‘Wounded Warrior’ gets pedicures

Keith Reyes, 64, visits a Stanwood nail salon for “foot treatments” that help soothe blast injuries.

Eggs Florentine
Baked Eggs Florentine: A brunch favorite inspired by a queen

The kitchen manager at Quil Ceda Creek Casino shares a dish that pays homage to a spinach-crazy 16th century monarch.

Jennifer Bardsley, author of her newest book Good Catch, at her home on Tuesday, Sept. 28, 2021 in Edmonds, Wa. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Edmonds author transitions from young adult novels to romance

Jennifer Bardsley’s “Good Catch” is set in an Edmonds-like town. Spoiler alert: There’s a happy ending.

Caption: They might be too old for lunch box notes, but teenagers benefit from TLC too.
Fun ways to show the teens in your life that you care

The teen years can be challenging but they don’t last long. A little bit of extra attention can go a long way.

This easy-to-make spinach and mushroom quiche is perfect for a light dinner or fancy brunch. (Gretchen McKay/Pittsburgh Post-Gazette/TNS)
Gretchen’s table: A spinach-mushroom quiche with cheesy goodness

The savory egg custard baked in a pie crust is easy to make — especially if you use a refrigerated crust.

Nissan’s signature V-motion grille dominates the 2022 Pathfinder’s front. Look closely and you’ll see three slots at the top, a tribute to the original 1986 Pathfinder. (Manufacturer photo)
Nissan Pathfinder comes full circle with all-new 2022 version

The three-row mid-size SUV gains modern amenities but returns to the rugged impression of the original.

Jack Rice, left, gives his grandmother Carolyn Rice, a tutorial on her new tablet Saturday afternoon in Edmonds on November 20, 2021.  (Kevin Clark / The Herald)
Need to Ring or Zoom? Edmonds teen comes to the rescue

Jack Rice, 17, started a free service to help seniors connect with tech. “He’s a hero around here.”

Herr Jung leads a group through Bacharach, Germany.
Rick Steves’ Europe: Lessons from a schoolmaster on the Rhine

Herr Jung dedicated his life to sharing Germany’s hard history so others can learn from it.

How to transform past shame into something positive and healthy

Tips on coping with the shame that we carry around in our hearts and on our sleeves.

Header, garden shovel or spade puts into soil, green meadow in the back, low angle shot
Regenerative gardening helps save the planet one garden at a time

Regenerative gardening is founded on the principle that if we take care of our soils then everything else will work out for the best.

She canceled her Iceland trip in time. Where’s her refund?

When Kim Josund cancels her trip to Iceland, she believes she’s entitled to a full refund. Why are her hotel and dive operator refusing?

Great Plant Pick: Acer tegmentosum “Joe Witt”

This Manchurian snakebark maple boasts beautiful highly striped white bark that brightens the shade garden.