You’ll fall in love with ‘Letters to Juliet’ schmaltz

  • By Robert Horton Herald Movie Critic
  • Thursday, May 13, 2010 1:58pm
  • LifeGo-See-Do

Well-crafted schmaltz is still schmaltz, so it may seem like splitting hairs to commend a movie for being hokey. But commend “Letters to Juliet” we must, for this film achieves everything it sets out to do.

Its goals are to hit the various buttons of the c-f genre, which you might know as chick flicks. Lost love, regret, European travel, food, charming young foreign actors — everything is checked off the list.

The European stop this time is Verona, Italy, where a place called Juliet’s Wall (inspired by Shakespeare) is used by tourists to leave notes on the subject of love. This massive display of public littering is endorsed, the movie tells us, by a team of Veronese city employees who sit around answering each letter.

This is how American Sophie (Amanda Seyfried) finds herself responding to a 50-year-old letter, whose British writer just happens to be alive and still curious about what happened to the Italian man she left behind all those years before.

Sophie’s in Verona with her fiance (Gael Garcia Bernal, very amusing), who is easily distracted and not interested in accompanying her on her subsequent adventure. The now-elderly author of the love note is Claire (Vanessa Redgrave), who has eagerly come to Italy with her suspiciously available grandson (Christopher Egan) in response to Sophie’s tender reply.

How can Sophie resist inviting herself along on their search for the long-lost Italian lover, especially as she’s casting about for a story idea for the New Yorker?

Hmm, recalling the plot is making me like the movie less. But if you can swallow the concept, “Letters to Juliet” does create a pleasant, sunny mood, which de-emphasizes slapstick in favor of a mellow road trip in gorgeous locations.

Part of this has to do with the peculiar, slightly spooky quality of Amanda Seyfried (late of “Mamma Mia!” and the weepy “Dear John”), a serious presence who frequently seems to be in the middle of her own daydream rather than interacting in scenes with her fellow actors. Her absence of humor makes the movie a different experience from what it would have been with Anne Hathaway or Jennifer Garner, say.

Having cast Vanessa Redgrave as Claire, however, maybe director Gary Winick (returning to form after the poor “Bride Wars”) recognized that a fluffy actress would not be able to hold the screen with Redgrave. Even when she’s being ethereal and romantic, as she is here, Redgrave is so commanding she can blow away lesser performers.

Co-star Franco Nero, by the way, appeared opposite Redgrave in 1967’s “Camelot,” had a child with her then, and, after many years apart, married her in 2006. That story sounds as though it came right out of the movie plot.

“Letters to Juliet” goes on a little long and works out all its issues in a slick, processed way, but I have to admit it’s a well-crafted piece.

The city of Verona can expect a massive uptick in visits from impressionable young women — and probably anybody else who sees this movie.

Talk to us

More in Life

Steve Smith gift ideas for gardeners
Ten gift ideas for gardeners

From puzzles to pruners, how to pick the perfect present for the green thumbs on your list.

Jeff Barnett, owner of Salish Sea-Boathouse during the soft opening in Edmonds on November 24, 2021. (Kevin Clark / The Herald)
Salish Sea sets sail at second location in Edmonds

In honor of the nearby waterfront, The Boathouse has a decidedly nautical feel — and it’s more of a taproom and brewhouse than its sibling brewpub up the street.

Seven gift ideas for weathering the holiday season

Smart thermostats and portable power will be thoughtful presents — especially when energy bills and power outages hit.

Photo Caption: Francois-Xavier Lalanne often used animal motifs in his modern, minimalist sculptures. His porcelain eggcup with a chicken's head, wings and tail sold for $2,080 at Palm Beach Modern Auctions.

(c) 2021 by Cowles Syndicate Inc.
‘Pocillovy’ is the obscure hobby of collecting eggcups

It stems from Victorian times, when nearly every type of food had its own specialized dish and utensils.

Orangebark Stewartia, Stewartia monadelpha,
Great Plant Pick: Orangebark Stewartia

This tree’s stunning bark is shown to perfection when it’s planted with a backdrop of evergreens.

Clockwise from top left: Trinity Yun, Ryan Chung, Carson Chadd and John Meneses.
Orchestra returns with four outstanding young musicians

Pacifica Chamber Orchestra’s first in-person concert since before the pandemic will feature winners of the 2020 Snohomish County Music Teachers Association Competition.

Edmonds’ Gothard Sisters will perform their annual Celtic Christmas Concert at 7:30 tonight at Edmonds Center for the Arts.
Events calendar for Snohomish County

Edmonds’ Gothard Sisters will perform their annual Christmas concert on Dec. 2.

Daphne Patakia, left, and Virginie Efira in "Benedetta." (Courtesy of IFC Films/TNS)
‘Benedetta’ an unruly, sexually frank tale of Renaissance nun

Paul Verhoeven’s film has drawn protests from Catholics, which means he’s definitely doing something right.

George MacKay in "Wolf." MUST CREDIT: Focus Features
‘Wolf,’ a film about identity issues, is an unintentional howler

This misguided movie goes off the rails immediately and stays there throughout its running time.

Most Read