2 Democratic legislators have opposing views on class-size initiative

Democratic 1st Legislative District State Sen. Rosemary McAuliffe and Democratic 21st District State Rep. Mary Helen Roberts have opposing views on Initiative 1351,which would require the Legislature to pay to reduce class sizes throughout the public-school system.

McAuliffe, who is in the middle of a four-year Senate term, says that she supports the measure because a positive vote would show the legislature that reducing class size is important to voters. The ranking Democrat on the Senate committee on education, she represents most of Mountlake Terrace, all of Brier and Bothell and the rest of the 1st Legislative District.

Roberts, who is retiring after five two-year terms in the House, says that she opposes the measure because it has no way to pay for the required extra teachers and class space and because of a lack of evidence that class-size reduction helps learning. Roberts, a longtime member of the House committee on early learning and human services, represents most of Edmonds, all of Mukilteo and the rest of the 21st Legislative District.

Here’s what McAuliffe said in support of I-1351:

“I believe legislators need to hear from the people regarding class size. The voice of the people will be very important when decisions are made regarding the investment of dollars into basic education. While some people may say that reduction in class size is not laid out in the McCleary decision (requiring he Legislature to provide full state support for basic public education) and will not satisfy the court, the initiative reflects the class-size reduction recommended by the Office of the Superintendent of Public Instruction and the Quality Educational Council. There is nothing more basic then a class size where students can receive the personalized instructional time they need to learn.”

Here’s what Roberts said in opposition to the initiative:

“While I think small class size is important for the lower grades, there is little evidence that the breadth of the requirement in the initiative is proven or necessary.

“The key question is how can we afford it? If we implement the education reform act and comply with the McCleary decision, we will accomplish a great deal. However, from my perspective, even doing that will require new revenue unless we shred the social services safety net. Revenue growth through a healthier economy is insufficient to meet our obligation to adequately fund basic education and provide much needed services for children, the disabled and the elderly.

“The Children’s Alliance, which strongly advocates for children, has voted to also oppose I-1351.”

Evan Smith can be reached at schsmith@frontier.com.

Talk to us

More in Local News

Mike Evans, Blue Heron Canoe Family patriarch, asks permission to navigate the Coast Salish waters as paddlers prepare to depart on their two week journey to Lummi Island. (Isabella Breda / The Herald)
Pandemic disrupted tradition, but not their love of the sea

The Blue Heron Canoe family has embarked on a two-week journey, launching from the Edmonds waterfront.

Laura Smith, with husband Tom, makes Danielle Lam laugh after being presented with a check for $10,000 from The Prize Patrol from Publishers Clearing House on Wednesday, July 28, 2021 in Mukilteo, Washington. (Andy Bronson / The Herald)
‘Holy roses!’ A day in the life of the legendary Prize Patrol

Publishers Clearing House surprised a Mukilteo couple with a sweepstakes prize, flowers and balloons.

Michael Fong
Somers taps Seattle deputy mayor to lead COVID recovery

Mike Fong will oversee how Snohomish County uses its $160 million in federal relief dollars.

Man, 20, hit and killed in Lynnwood, another badly injured

They were part of a group riding bicycles, scooters and skateboards. They were hit by a pickup truck.

Former EvCC standout athlete killed in Spokane shooting

Jakobe Ford, 22, was named to the Northwest Athletic Conferences All-Decade teams for 2010-19.

Lane closure set for section of Highway 527 near Canyon Park

The Washington State Department of Transportation is cleaning stormwater retention vaults.

Daniel Scott (center, in green jacket) and Eddie Block (bottom right) are shown in a video before the Proud Boys and other rioters stormed the U.S. Capitol building on Jan. 6 in Washington, D.C.
Arlington Proud Boy ‘Milkshake’ indicted in Capitol siege

Daniel Lyons Scott faces 10 federal charges, including assaulting federal officers.

Familiar faces making their mark in City Council contests

In Lynnwood, a 21-year-old is winning, while in Edmonds only 81 votes separate three hopefuls.

Incumbent Everett, Snohomish mayors seem headed for November

After early counting, Cassie Franklin and John Kartak appeared to be headed for the general election.

Most Read