Snohomish County Superior Courthouse in Everett. (Kevin Clark / The Herald)

Snohomish County Superior Courthouse in Everett. (Kevin Clark / The Herald)

Bailiff’s comments leads to appeal of child rape conviction

Joseph Hall, of Snohomish, was sentenced to more than 13 years in prison. Now he faces another trial.

EVERETT — An off-hand comment from a bailiff led the state Court of Appeals to reverse a child rape conviction for a Snohomish man accused of repeatedly abusing a 7-year-old girl.

Joseph Hall, 39, was charged in Snohomish County Superior Court in March 2019 with two counts of first-degree child rape and two counts of first-degree child molestation. The girl and her mother, both of Snohomish County, each took the stand and testified in a trial later that year.

The jury deliberated for eight days before returning a guilty verdict on the rape charges. They were deadlocked on the molestation charges. Hall was sentenced in January 2020 to 13⅓ years behind bars.

Over two years later, the state Court of Appeals ordered Hall’s convictions be reversed and the case be remanded, because a bailiff said things to the jury that potentially swayed the verdict.

When the case went to trial in 2019, the bailiff for Superior Court Judge Janice Ellis reportedly made comments to jurors as they deliberated. On the eighth day of deliberations, the jury asked if a juror could be dismissed.

“The juror stated she was not ill and just wanted to leave,” the bailiff told the court, “and they asked me if they could use the alternate. I told them that if they did that, they’d have to start all over and that generally that’s not what the alternate is for, but they told me to ask it anyway.”

The defense attorney and deputy prosecutor were called into court to meet with the judge and discuss the question. When the lawyers arrived, they were told the court had gotten a second question from the jury.

“We have a verdict on 1 and 2,” the jury wrote. “Can we leave 3 and 4 blank or hung?”

Then-defense attorney Cassandra Lopez-Shaw, who was elected judge in 2020 and died in March, filed a motion for a mistrial based on juror misconduct by the bailiff. Judge Ellis denied the motion.

The judge called the jury into the courtroom and directed them to deliver their verdict on the rape charges, and that a mistrial should be declared on the other counts.

Lopez-Shaw filed a motion for a new trial based on misconduct by the bailiff. Judge Ellis denied the motion.

“The bailiff’s post-trial communications with the jurors were demonstrably improper and are the archetype of a statement designed to hasten the jury’s verdict,” Lopez-Shaw wrote in the motion.

Judge Ellis denied the motion.

The judge declined to comment on the ruling this week when reached by a Daily Herald reporter.

The decision means Hall faces another trial. The case is scheduled to go in front of another jury in October.

This week, the girl’s mother told The Herald she had a panic attack when she was told about the appeal and possibility of a new trial. She said she felt disappointed in the criminal justice system. Another trial would mean the woman and her daughter may have to take the witness stand again, when they thought this chapter was over.

“The first time around was so traumatic and so hard,” she said. “Having to relive that would be terrifying. Having to watch my little girl go through that all over again would be terrifying. We’ve moved on with our lives. We’ve healed, we’ve done our counseling.”

Snohomish County Prosecutor Adam Cornell said he has never seen the Court of Appeals reverse a sentence based on a bailiff’s comments in his 20-some years working in the courthouse.

“It’s highly unusual,” he told The Herald, “and it’s obviously devastating for the family and the victim. We anticipate forging ahead and retrying the case if it comes to that.”

The state Court of Appeals released its 12-page opinion in late May.

“After 8 days of deliberations,” the opinion reads, “a mere 20 minutes elapsed between the jury being informed that if juror 4 were excused, they would have to start all over and the jury reaching a verdict. … It is at least possible that the bailiff’s comments resulted in juror 4 being pressured to reach a verdict.”

Court records show Hall had no prior felony convictions. As of this week, he remained incarcerated at the state prison in Shelton, awaiting a second trial.

Ellen Dennis: 425-339-3486; edennis@heraldnet.com; Twitter: @reporterellen.

Talk to us

More in Local News

Providence Regional Medical Center Everett. (Olivia Vanni/The Herald)
Providence nurse’s tearful plea shines light on short-staffed ER

The nurse described an overwhelmed emergency department, as staff have pleaded with the Everett City Council for hazard pay.

FILE - This 2003 electron microscope image made available by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention shows mature, oval-shaped monkeypox virions, left, and spherical immature virions, right, obtained from a sample of human skin associated with the 2003 prairie dog outbreak. A leading doctor who chairs a World Health Organization expert group described the unprecedented outbreak of the rare disease monkeypox in developed countries as "a random event" that might be explained by risky sexual behavior at two recent mass events in Europe. (Cynthia S. Goldsmith, Russell Regner/CDC via AP, File)
Snohomish Health District hiring full-time monkeypox task force

The county is gearing up for more cases. The outbreak will be evaluated weekly to decide if a four-person team is merited.

Logo for news use featuring the municipality of Lake Stevens in Snohomish County, Washington. 220118
Body found in impounded car in Lake Stevens

In June, Bothell police impounded the vehicle. Last week, a Lake Stevens business found a body inside.

Logo for news use featuring the municipality of Lake Stevens in Snohomish County, Washington. 220118
California woman dies after motorcycle crash west of Lake Stevens

Kimberly Moore was the passenger on a motorcycle Friday morning. She died the next night. She was 53.

A view of the proposed alternative station location to Everett Station located east of the current BNSF rail tracks in downtown. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Could light rail station under Pacific Avenue and over railroad work?

A group representing people around Everett Station wants Sound Transit to study the idea.

State Representative Robert Sutherland, left, gives a thumbs-up to passing drivers as he and a few volunteers wave flags and campaign signs along the side of State Route 9 on July 22, in Lake Stevens. Sam Low, right, talks with seniors on July 20 in Lake Stevens. (Sutherland photo by Ryan Berry / The Herald, Low photo by Kevin Clark / The Herald)
In GOP battle of Sutherland vs. Low, Democrats may tip the scale

The state lawmaker and Snohomish County council member are vying for a House seat. Democrats make up roughly 40% of the vote.

Food forum
Chocolate peanut butter Incredibles

These chocolate peanut butter bars are, as the name suggests, incredible.

SnoTown Brewing’s Frank Sandoval in 2019. (Aaron Swaney)
SnoTown Brewery owner charged with child molestation

Frank Sandoval conceded his conduct with a girl at his brewery was inappropriate, but he denied touching her sexually, charges say.

Everett
Head-on crash in Everett leaves man with life-threatening injuries

A two-vehicle collision in the 11600 block of Evergreen Way shut down southbound traffic Monday morning.

Most Read