Data hints at equipment or pilot fault in Brazil crash

RIO DE JANEIRO, Brazil – Moments before their jetliner skidded off a runway and exploded as it slammed into a building, pilots of a TAM Airlines Flight 3054 screamed “slow down!” and “turn, turn, turn,” flight recorder transcripts revealed Wednesday.

The horrific details read before a congressional commission investigating air safety suggest mechanical failure or pilot error contributed to last month’s accident in Sao Paulo, taking some heat off a government widely blamed for failing to improve the challenging runway, which pilots worldwide liken to landing on an aircraft carrier.

The pilots were unable to activate the spoilers – aerodynamic brakes on the Airbus A320’s wings – as they touched down on the short, rain-slicked runway at Sao Paulo’s Congonhas airport, according to the transcripts.

“Only one reverser. Spoiler nothing,” 53-year-old pilot Henrique Stephanini Di Sacco says in the transcript, giving the first indication that something is wrong.

“Look at that. Slow down, slow down,” says co-pilot Kleyber Lima, 54. Di Sacco replies: “I can’t. I can’t. Oh my God! Oh my God!”

Lima’s last words are: “Go! Go! Turn! Turn! Turn!”

The recording ends with screams and a woman’s voice, followed by an explosion.

The July 17 crash killed all 187 aboard the jetliner and 12 people on the ground in Brazil’s deadliest air disaster.

The Brazilian daily Folha de S. Paulo reported that according to the flight data recorder, one of the plane’s throttles was in the wrong position as it touched down, causing it to speed up instead of slow down.

The congressional commission did not review that data publicly Wednesday. But putting the throttle in the wrong position would have only complicated an already challenging landing for the pilots.

TAM previously acknowledged that one of the jet’s two thrust reversers, used to slow planes during landings, was inoperative. And speculation also has focused on the urban airport’s runway, which is so short that pilots are warned to abort landings if they make any errors while touching down.

“That is the classic aircraft accident,” said J.A. Donoghue, editor in chief of Aerosafety World. “There is not just one thing that causes it, but rather it is a cascading series of events.”

Talk to us

> Give us your news tips.

> Send us a letter to the editor.

> More Herald contact information.

More in Local News

Frank DeMiero founded and directed the Seattle Jazz Singers, a semi-professional vocal group. They are pictured here performing at the DeMiero Jazz Festival. (Photos courtesy the DeMiero family)
‘He dreamed out loud’: Remembering music educator Frank DeMiero

DeMiero founded the music department at Edmonds College and was a trailblazer for jazz choirs nationwide.

Provided photo 
Tug Buse sits in a period-correct small ship’s boat much like what could have been used by the Guatamozin in 1803 for an excursion up the Stillaguamish River.
Local historian tries to track down historic pistol

Tug Buse’s main theory traces back to a Puget Sound expedition that predated Lewis and Clark.

Archbishop Murphy High School on Friday, Feb. 28 in Everett, Washington. (Will Geschke / The Herald)
Former teacher charged with possession of child pornography

Using an online investigation tool, detectives uncovered five clips depicting sexual exploitation of minors.

A person waits in line at a pharmacy next to a sign advertising free flu shots with most insurance on Thursday, Feb. 27, 2025 in Everett, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Have you had the flu yet, Snohomish County? You’re not alone.

The rate of flu-related hospitalizations is the highest it’s been in six years, county data shows, and there are no signs it will slow down soon.

City of Everett Principal Engineer Zach Brown talks about where some of the piping will connect to the Port Gardner Storage Facility, an 8-million-gallon waste water storage facility, on Thursday, Feb. 27, 2025 in Everett, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Port Gardner Storage Facility will allow Everett to meet state outflow requirements

The facility will temporarily store combined sewer and wastewater during storm events, protecting the bay from untreated releases.

Founder of Snohomish County Indivisible Naomi Dietrich speaks to those gather for the senator office rally on Wednesday, Feb. 5, 2025 in Everett, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Membership numbers are booming for Snohomish County’s Indivisible chapter

Snohomish County’s Indivisible chapter, a progressive action group, has seen… Continue reading

Everett
Davin Alsin appointed as new commissioner on Snohomish Regional Fire & Rescue Board

The board filled the vacancy with Alsin, who will serve as commissioner through 2025.

REI packing up Alderwood location for move to bigger store in Lynnwood

The member-owned cooperative will close its doors Sunday before reopening at new location on March 28.

Everett City Council on Wednesday, March 19 in Everett, Washington. (Will Geschke / The Herald)
Everett City Council approves more than $200M in bonds

The bond issuance, routine in municipalities, will help pay for construction work in the city.

Gov. Bob Ferguson speaks at the opening of the Washington State Criminal Justice Training Commission's Northwest Regional Campus on Thursday, March 20 in Arlington, Washington. (Will Geschke / The Herald)
New regional police training campus in Arlington to welcome first class

Gov. Bob Ferguson discussed statewide staffing shortages at the ribbon-cutting ceremony Thursday.

Lynnwood City Council members gather for a meeting on Monday, March 17, 2025 in Lynnwood, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Lynnwood appoints last remaining candidate to council vacancy

Robert Leutwyler, a program manager at Amazon and US Army veteran, is set to be sworn in Monday.

Everett
Police allege Everett man carried out hate crime with a pipe bomb

Suspect held in alleged hate crime bombing that damaged neighbor’s car.

Support local journalism

If you value local news, make a gift now to support the trusted journalism you get in The Daily Herald. Donations processed in this system are not tax deductible.