WASHINGTON — As Congress adjourns for a summer recess, Democrats are in the uncomfortable position of trying to defend a plan for vast change in the nation’s health care system that has not yet been written. Critics have ramped up their protests, and disruptions of lawmakers’ town hall meetings have dominated news coverage.
And yet, the Democrats also find themselves in a surprising place: When they return after Labor Day, they will be well-positioned to pass a bill that will touch the lives of almost everyone in America.
Many questions remain, including how to pay for insuring the 46 million people in the U.S. who now do not have coverage, and how to corral health cost inflation. Legislation from three committees in the House will have to be blended; the House bill will have to be reconciled with still-evolving legislation in the Senate. An effort in the important Senate Finance Committee to craft a bill with the support of several moderate Republicans probably will continue until Sept. 15, a deadline imposed by Democratic leaders.
Emerging consensus
Still, just seven months into the Obama administration, there is an emerging consensus among the majority Democrats about what is wrong with the health care system and what can be fixed.
Sen. Evan Bayh, D-Ind., a centrist, said after a recent party caucus that broad agreement had developed to shore up Medicare subsidies for prescription drugs and to make it harder for insurance companies to limit coverage based on pre-existing conditions.
“The prospects for incremental improvement are still reasonably good,” said Geoff Garin, a Democratic pollster close to the congressional leadership. “But there’s a lot more realism about how hard this is.”
One focus now is the Senate Finance Committee, the panel charged with deciding not just how to reshape health policy but how to pay for it. All previous committee votes on health care this year have been along party lines. The finance committee, where talks will continue in the coming month, is the last forum in which Democrats hope to forge a sturdy bipartisan compromise.
The political price: Any bipartisan agreement probably will abandon a proposal from liberals to create a government-sponsored insurance option as an alternative to private health insurance.
The August congressional recess is a crucial period. Democrats hope to use the time to build support for the health care bill by telling voters what’s in it for them. Conservative critics are packing town hall meetings with people charging that Obama’s plans amount to a government takeover of health care.
Democrats have claimed those crowds have been organized by Republicans and their allies and that they do not reflect genuine grass-roots opposition. But national polls indicate that Democrats have a real political problem: The more people learn about the health care legislation, the less they seem to like it.
Confusion reigns
And confusion about what the legislation ultimately will say is a major complication.
House Democratic leaders have yet to resolve the differences among bills passed by three House committees. For example, the House Energy and Commerce Committee wants to limit the proposed subsidies that would help needy people buy insurance, an effort designed to win support from fiscal conservatives.
The Ways and Means Committee, meanwhile, has proposed paying for expanded access to insurance coverage with a tax on the very wealthy — an idea that has been opposed by many Democrats.
The biggest differences, however, probably will not be among House committees but between Democrats in the House and Senate. As a group, House Democrats tend to be far more liberal than the Senate Democratic Caucus, while Senate rules make it much harder to pass legislation without some bipartisan support.
Throughout congressional debate so far, Obama has kept his hands off the details of the legislation. He has laid out general principals of what he wants but has given Democrats wide latitude to craft the legislation — including the politically dicey measures for how to pay for it, which could entail tax increases for some Americans.
The Obama administration is expected to get more involved later in the process, when House and Senate negotiators sit down in a conference committee to write the final bill.
In the end, Democratic strategists say, it would be a huge political problem for the party if Congress comes up empty-handed.
“We have passed the point of no return,” said a senior Senate Democratic aide, who would not be quoted by name while discussing strategy. “We are too heavily invested in this. We will do something on health care.”
Talk to us
> Give us your news tips.
> Send us a letter to the editor.
> More Herald contact information.
