TACOMA — The widow of a Federal Way police officer who died from a heart attack at a shooting scene in March is fighting the state’s denial of survivor’s benefits for her and her three children.
Vanessa Walsh of Puyallup has asked the state Department of Labor &Industries to reconsider its decision that she does not qualify for pension benefits because her husband, 34-year-old Brian M. Walsh, died while performing “the normal and expected duties of a police officer.”
“I was pretty shocked when I found out we weren’t covered because of the way it happened,” Vanessa Walsh said Monday. “I think I’m still dumbfounded that we’re not covered. Part of me is angry.”
The state is allowed to pay benefits to a surviving spouse or children if a person’s death is “related to an industrial injury or an occupational disease,” said Elaine Fischer, a spokeswoman for Labor &Industries.
In the case of a heart attack, state law requires “it must show a direct link between the heart attack and some unusual physical or emotional exertion that’s not normally expected in that person’s job,” Fischer said.
Vanessa Walsh, 33, has three children — a 12-year-old daughter, a 4-year-old son, and a 6-week-old daughter. Her husband had been a police officer for eight years, the last four in Federal Way.
Her lawyer, Mark Wagner of Tacoma, said she is entitled to survivor’s benefits because her husband suffered a heart attack in a situation of “unusual exertion,” meeting the standard required by law. Wagner said the exertion was stress-related, not physical.
“I think unusual exertion is the emotional stress situation he was put in,” he said.
The benefits, if approved, would have been significant:
$128.34 a month for each of the Walshes’ three children (2 percent of Walsh’s monthly salary) until they turn 18.
A one-time payment of $4,000 immediately after the death and about $7,000 for the officer’s burial.
The Federal Way Police Officers Guild previously set up a memorial fund for Walsh and her children at Key Bank branches. Cmdr. Chris Norman declined to say exactly how much has been raised but said the total is less than two months of Brian Walsh’s salary.
Brian Walsh suffered a heart attack and died March 21 while maintaining a perimeter around a shooting scene, the King County Medical Examiner’s Office ruled.
He was found unresponsive in his patrol car around 6:45 a.m. He had responded to the 33300 block of 26th Avenue Southwest to help other officers investigating an officer-involved shooting in the area.
The shooting happened when officers were investigating a stolen SUV. The driver took off, ramming three patrol cars. Two officers shot at the fleeing SUV, wounding the 17-year-old driver in the arm.
The Federal Way boy, now 18, was arrested and pleaded guilty last month and was sentenced to about 2½ years in custody at a juvenile facility.
Wagner said Walsh was in excellent health and had not complained of any medical conditions or symptoms prior to his death. He said the fatal shootings of four Lakewood police officers late last year contributed to the stress Walsh was under.
“In the months following the Lakewood shootings, officers in uniform appeared to be targets and in danger simply for their line of duty,” Wagner wrote Labor &Industries.
Wagner provided The News Tribune a copy of the denial letter Labor &Industries’ sent to Vanessa Walsh.
It says: “For a claim for a heart related event to be allowed, it must be established that the event precipitating the condition entailed unusual physical and/or emotional exertion not normally expected as part of the job.”
“Upon review,” the letter continued, “the activities your husband was performing at the time of his death appear to be among the normal and expected duties of a police officer.”
Fischer said her agency reviewed the case closely.
“It was given an exceptionally thorough review because of the sensitivity of it being a police officer that had died,” Fischer said.
Because of the request for reconsideration, Fischer said Labor &Industries is now reviewing the case file — including any new information — with “the highest level of attention.” She said she doesn’t know how soon that review will be complete.
Vanessa Walsh said she must decide soon whether she’ll return to teaching sixth grade at Rocky Ridge Elementary in Graham.
“I’m having the hardest time making any decisions,” she said. “I feel like I can’t plan anything right now.”
Talk to us
> Give us your news tips.
> Send us a letter to the editor.
> More Herald contact information.
