Gore asks for uniform Florida counting standard

By ANNE GEARAN

Associated Press

TALLAHASSEE, Fla. – Democrats asked Florida’s high court Sunday to set a generous standard for deciding what voters really meant when they punched ballots in the disputed presidential election. Republicans argued it was unfair “to keep the state and the nation on hold” any longer.

Lawyers for Democrat Al Gore argued that previous state court rulings have established the rules for discerning the will of the voter in close elections.

“The Secretary of State and Governor Bush nonetheless urge this Court to construe Florida law to prevent county canvassing boards – which are charged under Florida law with primary responsibility for counting ballots – from utilizing the procedures long established in Florida law … to ascertain the electorate’s will in close elections such as this one,” Gore’s filing said.

“This court should reject that approach.”

Democrats want the Florida Supreme Court to establish a standard to approve or reject ballots in the three counties where hand recounts are under way or scheduled.

“For more than 80 years it has been settled Florida law that a ballot must be counted if the voter’s intent is apparent from an examination of the ballot,” Gore’s lawyers wrote.

Earlier Sunday, lawyers for Republican George W. Bush asked the same court to call an end to the presidential election recount and uphold the statutory deadline for counties to report their results.

The paper war lays the legal foundation for a Monday hearing in Florida’s high court.

Gore’s filing cited the law that provides for manual recounts in close elections, noting that if vote-checkers cannot determine the winner on a particular ballot, the local elections board should “determine the voter’s intent.”

The problem comes when those elections boards decide how to do that – with some boards opting for stricter standards than others, Gore’s lawyers said.

The issue only becomes essential if the Florida court allows hand counts to continue at all.

Republican Bush wants the court to end ballot recounts in three large, Democratic-leaning Florida counties, while Gore wants the counts go on for as long as it takes to finish the job.

If original results from those counties stand, Bush wins Florida and with it the presidential election. Gore hopes the recounts will turn up enough votes to erase Bush’s 930-vote lead.

The Republican candidate argued that election officials in the three South Florida counties could have conducted recounts requested by Democrats and still met the seven-day deadline.

“It would be highly inequitable to keep the state and the nation on hold to finish a manual recount when the responsible officials failed expeditiously even to begin the process,” Bush’s lawyers wrote.

Bush noted that a fourth county where Democrats called for a recount – the much smaller Volusia County to the north – did complete its work by the Nov. 14 deadline, seven days after the election.

“While large counties obviously have more votes to count, it is equally obvious that they have more staff, resources, and money to count those votes,” the 64-page GOP filing argued. “There is not a scintilla of evidence that any of the three counties at issue here were unable to meet the Tuesday deadline – as Volusia County did.”

The case arose from lawsuits that Palm Beach and Broward counties filed last week seeking court guidance on whether and how to conduct hand recounts.

The central question for the seven state Supreme Court justices is whether Florida’s secretary of state, the top elections official, acted properly when she invoked the seven-day deadline and then refused to accept the reasoning of county officials who said they need more time.

Hand recounts continued over the weekend in Palm Beach and Broward counties, with Gore picking up modest gains in unofficial results. A manual recount in Miami-Dade is scheduled to begin Monday and continue until Dec. 1.

Until the state high court rules, it is an open question whether results of those recounts will be added to the state tally. The court, composed of six Democrats and one independent, dealt a setback to Bush on Friday when it barred Secretary of State Katherine Harris from declaring Bush the winner on Saturday, as she had planned.

Some Gore supporters accuse Harris, a Republican who campaigned for Bush, of partisan motives. The Bush camp counters that Harris was right to stick to the deadline set out in state law.

“The secretary of state’s conduct was reasoned and reasonable and was perfectly consistent with (indeed mandated by) the laws of Florida,” Bush’s filing said, adding that the court has set a precedent of deferring to the secretary of state in previous election cases.

“Extraordinary times call, however, for courts to adhere steadfastly to the rule of law,” the Bush papers said. “The rule of law is indispensable if the right of the people to pick their leaders, through a full and fair process according to the rules applicable to all, is to be vindicated.”

Harris and the Bush camp have had a delicate relationship as litigation heated up, both of them reluctant to seem too closely allied.

Harris tried to distance herself from Bush in her own filing Sunday, arguing that while both Bush and Gore are trying to turn state law to their advantage, her duty is to be neutral.

“It is clear, that for the Democrats and the Republicans, the object is to win, and that is understandable. The stakes are very high.”

She also asked the court to let her argue her case separately from Bush on Monday.

A federal appeals court is also considering Bush’s separate constitutional challenge to manual recounts. The 11th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals in Atlanta also dealt Bush a setback on Friday when it declined to put an immediate stop to the counting.

Bush raised some of the same constitutional issues in Sunday’s filing in the Florida court.

Copyright ©2000 Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

Talk to us

> Give us your news tips.

> Send us a letter to the editor.

> More Herald contact information.

More in Local News

George Beard walks into the Stanwood Library with coffee in hand on Thursday, May 23, 2024, in Stanwood, Washington. (Ryan Berry / The Herald)
As winter approaches, Stanwood man remains homeless

George Beard is living in his car because he’s too sick to work. So far, connections to resources haven’t been enough.

Logo for news use featuring the municipality of Monroe in Snohomish County, Washington. 220118
‘Right-hand man’ in Snohomish County drug ring sentenced to 10 years

Humberto Garcia was convicted of drug trafficking in April. He’s the last member of the group to be sentenced.

Snow is visible along the top of Mount Pilchuck from bank of the Snohomish River near Rotary Park on Wednesday, May 10, 2023 in Everett, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Everett initiative asks: Should the Snohomish River have legal rights?

Initiative 24-03 proposes legal standing to prevent environmental damage. Opponents say it’ll lead to unnecessary lawsuits.

The Grand Avenue Park Bridge is seen as the sun sets in 2022 in Everett. (Ryan Berry / The Herald)
Elevator at Grand Ave. bridge in Everett closed due to vandalism

The city hopes to reopen the elevator by December. Repairs could cost tens of thousands of dollars.

Riaz Khan finally wins office on his fifth try. (Kevin Clark / The Herald)
Mukilteo police seek info on alleged attack on House candidate

Riaz Khan, a former City Council member, said he was fixing campaign signs Tuesday morning when two men attacked him.

Brandon Borg, 21, fills his gas tank in Everett on Oct. 24. Borg must drive long distances for work, and is worried about how the rise in gas prices will affect his ability to save money for his future. (Caroline Walker Evans for Cascade PBS)
Young WA voters say cost of living is their top concern

Everett and Seattle residents cited gas prices and rising rents as motivating factors for their votes this year.

Arlington
9K remain without power in Snohomish, Island counties

At one point Monday afternoon, over 20,000 had lost power. Winds were expected to subside.

Boeing workers file into Angel of the Winds Arena to vote on the latest contract proposal from the company on Monday, Nov. 4, 2024 in Everett, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Boeing Machinists approve contract, ending 52-day strike

After voting no twice, 59% of union members approved the latest contract.

Snohomish County Elections employees check signatures on ballots on Tuesday, Oct. 29, 2024 in Everett , Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
5 things to watch in Washington heading into Election Day

Keep your eyes on statewide initiatives, the race for public lands commissioner and two contentious congressional races.

Snohomish County Elections employees Frank Monkman, left, and Tina Ruybal, right, place sorted ballots in a green container on Tuesday, Oct. 29, 2024 in Everett , Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Snohomish County’s guide to the 2024 election

Here is everything you need to know before Election Day.

The Victorian home sits on Whidbey Island. (Alyse Young for The Washington Post)
Whidbey couple thought they found their dream home — then came the bats

The couple had no recourse after unknowingly buying a home infested with thousands of bats.

Everett
Everett men arrested in huge bust of Seattle drug ring

On Wednesday, investigators searched 31 locations, but suspects from Lynnwood and Edmonds remained at large, officials said.

Support local journalism

If you value local news, make a gift now to support the trusted journalism you get in The Daily Herald. Donations processed in this system are not tax deductible.