High court begins term with case on police actions

WASHINGTON — The Supreme Court opened its new term Monday pondering whether a police officer’s misunderstanding of the law can justify a traffic stop that led to the seizure of illegal drugs.

Several of the justices questioned whether it was reasonable for the North Carolina officer to pull over a car because one of its two brake lights was burned out, even though a quirky state law requires only one light to be functional.

The stop led to a search and the discovery of cocaine in the trunk, but the high court’s ultimate decision could lead to that evidence being excluded.

Arguments in the case took place shortly after the court announced its surprising decision to turn away appeals from five states seeking to prohibit same-sex marriages, paving the way for an immediate expansion of gay marriage.

This group of justices began its fifth year together, and Chief Justice John Roberts is at the start of his 10th year at the head of the high court. On tap for the term is an array of cases involving:

— Religious, employment and housing discrimination;

— The drawing of political districts in Alabama and Arizona;

— A dispute between Congress and the president over passports that is heavy with Middle East politics;

— The use of a law to prevent document shredding against a fisherman accused of throwing undersized red grouper overboard; and

— The prosecution of a self-styled rapper whose Facebook postings threatened his estranged wife, an FBI agent and area schools.

Monday’s argument on the police action involves an appeal by Nicholas Heien, whose Ford Escort was pulled over when an officer saw that the right rear brake light wasn’t working. The officer found cocaine during an ensuing search, and Heien was later convicted of drug trafficking.

The case tests whether the officer’s mistaken understanding of the law makes the traffic stop unreasonable and the search a violation of Heien’s constitutional rights. A divided state Supreme Court said the mistake was reasonable enough to justify the routine traffic stop and refused to toss out the drug evidence.

Heien’s lawyer, Stanford Law School Professor Jeffrey Fisher, told the justices that “in a country dedicated to the rule of law, governmental officers should be presumed to know the law at least as well as the citizens.”

Roberts asked him why not take reasonableness into account since the Fourth Amendment only protects against “unreasonable” searches and seizures.

Fisher responded that criminal law “is presumed to be definite and knowable.”

Robert Montgomery, North Carolina’s senior deputy attorney general, argued that the Fourth Amendment does not require police officers to be perfect.

“All that is required is that a police officer have a reasonable view of the facts and apply those facts to a reasonable understanding of the law.” Montgomery said.

Justice Elena Kagan suggested officers should enforce the law as written and not push every law “to the furthest, furthest, furthest it could go.”

Justice Sonia Sotomayor wondered how many people “have been stopped for one brake light that were asked to have their car searched and is that something as a society that we should be encouraging.”

Montgomery said innocent people are stopped all the time when officers make reasonable mistakes of fact and then are let go when police realize there is no criminal offense. He said police should be given the same leeway when they make mistakes of law.

The Obama administration is siding with North Carolina in the case. Justice Department attorney Rachel Kovner argued that police officers can make stops if they reasonably believe a person committed a crime, even if it later turns out the officer was mistaken as to the law or the facts.

A decision in the case of Heien v. North Carolina, 14-604, should come by late spring.

Talk to us

> Give us your news tips.

> Send us a letter to the editor.

> More Herald contact information.

More in Local News

Olivia Vanni / The Herald 
The Mukilteo Lighthouse. Built in 1906, it’s one of the most iconic landmarks in Snohomish County.
The Mukilteo Lighthouse. Built in 1906, it’s one of the most iconic landmarks in Snohomish County. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Mukilteo mayor vetoes council-approved sales tax

The tax would have helped pay for transportation infrastructure, but was also set to give Mukilteo the highest sales tax rate in the state.

Marysville Mayor Jon Nehring gives the state of the city address at the Marysville Civic Center on Wednesday, Jan. 31, 2024, in Marysville, Washington. (Ryan Berry / The Herald)
Marysville council approves interim middle housing law

The council passed the regulations to prevent a state model code from taking effect by default. It expects to approve final rules by October.

x
State audit takes issue with Edmonds COVID grant monitoring

The audit report covered 2023 and is the third since 2020 that found similar issues with COVID-19 recovery grant documentation.

Bothell
Bothell man pleads guilty to sexual abuse of Marysville middle schoolers

The man allegedly sexually assaulted three students in exchange for vapes and edibles in 2022. His sentencing is set for Aug. 29.

Larsen talks proposed Medicaid cuts during Compass Health stop in Everett

Compass Health plans to open its new behavioral health center in August. Nearly all of the nonprofit’s patients rely on Medicaid.

Snohomish County Dahlia Society members Doug Symonds and Alysia Obina on Monday, March 3, 2025 in Lake Stevens, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
How to grow for show

10 Snohomish County Dahlia Society tips for award-winning blooms

State Attorney General Nick Brown's office posted a release announcing $720 million in nationwide settlements with eight drugmakers that manufactured opioid pills and worsened the nationwide opioid crisis. The state could receive more than $16 million, the release said. (Ryan Berry/Washington State Standard)
Snohomish County to receive portion of latest $16M opioid settlement

While the amount of money is still unknown, funding plans are already in place to help with drug abuse prevention, treatment and education.

Community members gather for the dedication of the Oso Landslide Memorial following the ten-year remembrance of the slide on Friday, March 22, 2024, at the Oso Landslide Memorial in Oso, Washington. (Ryan Berry / The Herald)
The Daily Herald garners 6 awards from regional journalism competition

The awards recognize the best in journalism from media outlets across Alaska, Idaho, Montana, Oregon and Washington.

District 2 candidates differ in public safety approach

Incumbent Paula Rhyne is facing challenger Ryan Crowther. The third candidate, Jonathan Shapiro, is no longer seeking the seat.

From left to right, Edmonds City Council Position 3 candidates Joseph Ademofe, Alex Newman and Erika Barnett.
Amid budget crisis, Edmonds City Council candidates talk revenue, affordability

Three newcomers are facing off for Position 3 on the council, currently held by council President Neil Tibbott.

Everett
Everett approves new fines for non-emergency lifts

The fire department will only issue fines for non-emergency lift assists at licensed care facilities, not for individuals at home calling 911.

Guns for sale at Caso’s Gun-A-Rama in Jersey City, New Jersey, which has been open since 1967. (Photo by Aristide Economopoulos/New Jersey Monitor)
After suing, WA gets carveout from Trump administration plan to return gun conversion devices

The Trump administration has agreed to not distribute devices that turn semi-automatic… Continue reading

Support local journalism

If you value local news, make a gift now to support the trusted journalism you get in The Daily Herald. Donations processed in this system are not tax deductible.