Historian intrigued by 100-year-old love story

Today, Annette Fitch-Brewer’s saga would be one for the milk cartons. Or she’d be in court, charged with a crime.

Nearly a century ago, she wrote it all down. She called her self-published book “The Story of a Mother-Love.”

In truth, it’s a story of custodial interference and abduction. Telling only her side of it, the author comes off as a fearless heroine. She portrays her wilderness adventure as a noble act of love for her little boy.

I was hooked from the start. Near the beginning of Fitch-Brewer’s tale, published in 1913, she wrote: “My child was six years old, and when he asked me to take him where he ‘could stay with mamma,’ I let a mother’s heart overrule a woman’s head.”

David Dilgard, a history specialist at the Everett Public Library, is more economical with his words. “She just swiped the kid and ran. She swiped him right after Christmas in 1905,” he said.

Dilgard will present a program at 7 p.m. Thursday in the Lake Stevens High School library called “Annette Fitch-Brewer: Hiding Out at Lake Stevens, 1906-1910.”

The free event is organized by the Lake Stevens Historical Society, which has one copy of the book. The Everett library’s Northwest Room has another copy, and Dilgard has located a few copies at BookFinder.com and other online sources.

Fitch-Brewer didn’t write about what led to her 1904 divorce from Isaac Curtis Brewer, a wealthy man in Sandusky, Ohio.

On Dec. 24, 1905, she was allowed to visit with Isaac Curtis Jr. – the boy was called Curtis – at a Cleveland hotel. When she didn’t return him, Brewer hired detectives and began a hunt that wouldn’t end until 1910.

His ex-wife had money and friends. She and the child traveled by train to Ottawa, Canada. Later, a letter she wrote to her Ottawa friends from the stately Davenport Hotel in Spokane tipped off detectives who were on her trail.

A wanted poster distributed by her husband includes the line “Left Spokane October 1, 1906.”

She was tracked to Seattle, but finally found refuge at Lake Stevens on property owned by William Illman, an early settler. She lived near the Rucker Mill. The book is filled with descriptions of the “great peaks that looked down on us” and the forest “with its strong, healthy fragrance.”

She settled in, made friends in Everett and Seattle, and ordered “luxuries” from the Bon Marche. She went by the name Mrs. McIntyre and renamed her son Boyd McIntyre.

She bought some small boats and canoes, and rented them out to fishermen – 25 cents an hour for a canoe, $1 a day for a boat.

Dilgard said the book has been in the Northwest Room for years. He is only now digging deeper into the story.

“There are lots of accounts of America, but this is Lake Stevens,” Dilgard said. “When she writes about her little boy watching cars go by, those were the first cars in Snohomish County. The added intrigue is, she’s in hiding.”

The intrigue ended April 14, 1910. An Everett Herald article tells of “the climax of an exciting search extending over a period of five years.”

“Eastern lawyer” H.L. Peake, employed by Brewer, was accompanied by a deputy sheriff as he took a picture of Curtis into a Lake Stevens schoolhouse. The boy matched the picture and was taken from the school.

Young Curtis was returned to his father, and no mention is made of any legal consequences for Fitch-Brewer.

If it happened today, “it could either be a felony or a misdemeanor, depending on the circumstances,” said Kathy Webber, a Snohomish County deputy prosecutor who has handled numerous custody cases. She said it’s common to get complaints around Christmastime.

“They aren’t necessarily prosecutable, but what happens around the holidays is people want to change their parenting plan,” Webber said.

Long before parenting plans, Fitch-Brewer took matters into her own hands. She wrote of her belief that God was on her side: “That Just Judge above sees intents and reads thoughts and hearts, and in His hands I leave my case.”

Dilgard discovered through his research that after Curtis grew up, he returned to live with his mother.

“She ended up living in Everett, on Grand Avenue,” Dilgard said. “By World War I, her son was living with her. He enlisted and was a veteran of the first World War.”

Dilgard also found evidence that Isaac Curtis Brewer Jr. later lived in Everett by himself.

As for Fitch-Brewer, “Whether she lived the rest of her life here and is buried here, I’m still trying to find that piece,” Dilgard said.

Always looking for an eyewitness to the past, he wonders if there’s anyone left who knew Annette Fitch-Brewer.

Is there?

If you know, give me a call.

Columnist Julie Muhlstein: 425-339-3460 or muhlsteinjulie@heraldnet.com.

Hiding out at Lake Stevens

Historian David Dilgard will present “Annette Fitch-Brewer: Hiding Out at Lake Stevens, 1906-1910” at 7 p.m. Thursday in the Lake Stevens High School library, 2908 113th Ave. NE.

Dilgard will explore the story of a mother who abducted her son and ran off to Lake Stevens. For more information, call Anne Whitsell of the Lake Stevens Historical Society at 425-334-3873.

Talk to us

More in Local News

Clyde Shavers, left, and Greg Gilday.
Shavers wins by narrow margin as Dems flip seat in 10th District

Democrat Clyde Shavers won by 211 votes against incumbent state Rep. Greg Gilday. It’s close enough for a recount.

Edmonds man hospitalized after shooting in Arlington

The man, 30, was found Monday night in the 500 block of N. Macleod Avenue after reports of an assault.

Snow lingered outside the office building of Receivables Performance Management on Thursday, Dec. 1, 2022, in Lynnwood, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Lynnwood data breach exposed sensitive info for 3.7 million across US

Lawsuits allege lax security at a debt collection agency led to the attack. It wasn’t announced for over a year.

The Washington State Patrol was investigating a fatal crash involving multiple vehicles Thursday on Highway 530 near Oso. (Washington State Patrol)
1 killed, 1 injured in crash east of Arlington

There was no detour for several hours Thursday afternoon as detectives investigated the four-vehicle collision.

Teen killed in Everett crash, shooting identified

No arrests have been made in the Friday night killing of 17-year-old Gabriel Kartak, of Seattle.

The crab doughnut at Market in Edmonds is a strange delight, with a sweet and dense glazed doughnut topped with bright and briny dungeness crab salad, nutty browned butter and a shower of smoky bacon bits. (Taylor Goebel / The Herald)
This idyllic dining destination is right in Snohomish County

Edmonds boasts fresh seafood, Caribbean-inspired sandwiches, artisan breads, cocktails and more.

Marysville Jail (City of Marysville)
Man with hepatitis C accused of spitting on Marysville jail staff

Hepatitis C is usually spread through blood. The suspect, 28, faces allegations of exposing the officers to a contagious disease.

NO CAPTION. Logo to accompany news of Washington state.
Medicare open enrollment ends Dec. 7

Find information and resources to help make the best choice for you.

Sunlight illuminates a framed photograph of Mila and Wilfrido Sarmiento while their daughter Rowella Sarmiento cries reading her statement to the court during Caleb Wride’s sentencing on Monday, Nov. 28, 2022 in Everett, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
At sentencing, family mourns parents killed in fatal DUI crash

Caleb Wride, 23, of Everett, was sentenced Monday for the head-on crash that killed Mila and Wilfrido Sarmiento.

Most Read