Hung jury means life for Finch


Herald Writer

A convicted double murderer was spared a death sentence Monday after a Snohomish County jury was unable to reach agreement on his punishment.

What the outcome means for Charles Ben Finch, 51, was not immediately clear.

The lack of a verdict means an automatic sentence of life in prison without possibility of release. But questions remain whether Finch will survive. On Monday, he remained unconscious at an Everett hospital with head and spinal injuries suffered during an Oct. 25 suicide attempt at the Snohomish County Jail.

Jurors divided on what punishment Finch should receive for the August 1994 aggravated murders near Cathcart of sheriff’s Sgt. Jim Kinard, 34, and Ronald Modlin, 38, a blind man.

They declined to speak with reporters after announcing their verdict and were escorted from the courthouse by security officers.

Before leaving, jurors privately told lawyers that most supported death sentences for both killings, deputy prosecutor Michael Downes said. The split was 10-2 for death in connection with Modlin’s murder and 9-3 in favor of death for Kinard’s killing, Downes said.

The jury had to be unanimous for a death sentence. But unlike most criminal cases, a nonunanimous verdict did not signal a mistrial.

Downes said he was relieved the case was over.

"I’m sure the jury gave it a lot of thoughtful consideration," he said.

One of Finch’s attorneys, public defender Bill Jaquette, swiftly left the courthouse without commenting.

Finch has been paralyzed and in critical condition since leaping headfirst from a second-floor balcony at the jail and landing on his neck.

The courtroom was packed for the verdict with most of the seats occupied by deputies who had served with Kinard. They greeted the news with stoic silence.

So did the slain lawman’s family, but they later made their disappointment known.

Phyllis Kinard said she had a difficult time understanding how some jurors had arrived at the conclusion that Finch deserved mercy.

During the trial, she testified about her son, telling jurors how as a little boy he had loved to dress up as a cowboy and ride his tricycle. Jim Kinard was the father of a young boy, too, when a bullet fired by Finch cut him down.

There will be no closure for Kinard’s family until "Mr. Finch dies, and I hope it will be soon," Phyllis Kinard said.

"I couldn’t even begin to tell you what Jim would say," she added. "It would be unprintable."

Finch attempted to kill himself only hours after he had personally addressed jurors, asking for mercy. He also apologized for killing Modlin and Kinard, calling their deaths a "terrible thing."

Finch was convicted of murdering Kinard and Modlin and sentenced to die in 1995. But the state Supreme Court tossed out the sentence in 1999 because jurors had seen him in handcuffs and a nylon hobble. The underlying convictions were not affected.

The sole question in Finch’s new trial was whether he should receive a death sentence or life in prison without possibility of release.

The suicide attempt — Finch’s second at the jail since the murders — came the night before closing arguments and jury deliberations had been scheduled. The defendant’s grave injuries brought the trial to a halt for more than a week as lawyers and Judge Ronald Castleberry wrestled with what to do next.

Doctors said that Finch injured his spine, most likely causing permanent paralysis to his legs and limiting the use of his arms. He also suffered bleeding to his brain.

Jaquette had moved for a new trial, arguing that Finch’s medical condition rendered him legally incompetent and unable to assist in his defense.

Prosecutors countered that Finch had voluntarily absented himself from the trial, and that it should move forward.

Castleberry never ruled on the mistrial motion. Instead, on Friday he told attorneys to make their closing arguments and instructed jurors to begin deliberations.

Before beginning deliberations, jurors were informed, in detail, about Finch’s suicide attempt and his injuries. They also were instructed that they could consider that information, but were prohibited from allowing sympathy to color their verdict.

Talk to us

More in Local News

Members of South County Fire practice onboarding and offboarding a hovering Huey helicopter during an interagency disaster response training exercise at Arlington Municipal Airport on Tuesday, June 6, 2023, in Arlington, Washington. The crews learned about and practiced safe entry and exit protocols with crew from Snohomish County Volunteer Search and Rescue before begin given a chance to do a live training. (Ryan Berry / The Herald)
Snohomish, King counties train together for region’s next disaster

Dozens of agencies worked with aviators Tuesday to coordinate a response to a simulated earthquake or tsunami.

Police stand along Linden Street next to orange cones marking pullet casings in a crime scene of a police involved shooting on Friday, May 19, 2023 in Everett, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Lake Stevens man identified in Everett manhunt, deadly police shooting

Travis Hammons, 34, was killed by officers following a search for an armed wanted man in a north Everett neighborhood.

Ciscoe Morris, a longtime horticulturist and gardening expert, will speak at Sorticulture. (Photo provided by Sorticulture)
Get your Sorticulture on: Garden festival returns to downtown Everett

It’s a chance to shop, dance, get gardening tips, throw an axe and look through a big kaleidoscope. Admission is free.

Funko mascots Freddy Funko roll past on a conveyor belt in the Pop! Factory of the company's new flagship store on Aug. 18, 2017.  (Dan Bates / The Herald)
Lawsuit: Funko misled investors about Arizona move

A shareholder claims Funko’s decision to relocate its distribution center from Everett to Arizona was “disastrous.”

1 stabbed at apartment in Lynnwood

The man, 26, was taken to an Everett hospital with “serious injuries.”

A firefighting helicopter carries a bucket of water from a nearby river to the Bolt Creek Fire on Saturday, Sep. 10, 2022, on U.S. Highway 2 near Index, Washington. (Ryan Berry / The Herald)
Red flag fire warning issued west of Cascades

There are “critical fire weather” conditions due to humidity and wind in the Cascades, according to the National Weather Service.

A house fire damaged two homes around 1:30 a.m. Tuesday, June 6, 2023 in Marysville, Washington. (Photo provided by Marysville Fire District)
Fire burns 2 homes in Marysville, killing 2 dogs

Firefighters responded to a report of a fire north of Lakewood Crossing early Tuesday, finding two houses engulfed in flames.

Dolly Hunnicutt holds onto a metal raccoon cutout while looking through metal wildflowers at the Freeborn Metal Art booth during the first day of Sorticulture on Friday, June 9, 2023 in Everett, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Sorticulture brings gardening galore, fun by the bushel at 130 booths

“Every year there’s something different to see,” one attendee said at the opening of the three-day festival in downtown Everett.

Alex Dold lived with his mother and grandmother, Ruby Virtue, near Echo Lake. His sisters, Vanessa and Jen Dold, often would visit to play board games and watch soccer on television.
Troubled deputies at center of $1.5M settlement in Maltby man’s death

In 2017, Bryson McGee and Cody McCoy killed Alex Dold with their Tasers. Neither of them work for the sheriff’s office anymore.

Most Read