Judge again rebukes lawyers who want him to step down from Byron Scherf’s trial

EVERETT — For the second time in as many weeks, lawyers for an inmate accused of killing a Monroe corrections officer faced a judge’s admonition for their handling of the case.

Snohomish County Superior Court Judge Thomas Wynne on Friday concluded that defense attorneys Jon Scott and Karen Halverson violated professional ethics rules by leveling untrue allegations against him as part of their second attempt to get Wynne to step down from the case.

The lawyers represent Byron Scherf, an inmate serving a life sentence for sex offenses. Scherf, 53, is accused of strangling corrections officer Jayme Biendl in the prison chapel last year. Prosecutors are seeking the death penalty.

The defense attorneys filed a motion last week asking the judge to withdraw. They alleged that Wynne has operated under a flawed understanding of the law and had ceded his authority in the past to prosecuting attorney Mark Roe.

They accused the longtime judge of entering into a “wink-and-nod” agreement with Roe in the 2006 retrial of convicted child killer Richard Clark. They questioned the judge’s ability to give Scherf a fair trial.

Wynne called the defense’s allegations a “bald-faced fabrication.” He went on to say that if they were attempting to intimidate him, it wasn’t working.

“I’m not intimidated,” Wynne said.

He concluded that the defense’s statements alleging that the failed to follow the law in the Clark case were made recklessly. He followed the law then and he stands by his decision now, Wynne said.

The defense alleged that Wynne ignored the law when he allowed prosecutors to withdraw their intent to seek the death penalty after Clark agreed to admit his involvement in Roxanne Doll’s death and waived further appeals. That resolution was supported by the girl’s family. Clark is serving a life sentence in prison without parole.

Wynne on Friday noted that he considered the case law that the defense noted in their motion. However, he concluded that case didn’t apply as the state Supreme Court handed down a specific decision on Clark.

“(W)e reverse his death sentence and remand to the trial court where, if the state desires, a new special sentencing proceeding may take place,” the justices wrote in their 2001 opinion.

The assertions that he ignored the law in the Clark case are “frivolous and totally without merit,” he said.

Wynne declined to step down from Scherf’s case, adding he wouldn’t allow the defense’s ethical lapse to affect his rulings. He hasn’t found Scherf’s lawyers to have engaged in unethical conduct before, the judge said.

Meanwhile, the judge went on to grant the defense’s motion for more time to prepare for key hearings that were scheduled to begin Monday. They now are set for April.

The hearings will determine if jurors will hear statements Scherf allegedly made to detectives after Biendl’s death, including a confession that he killed Biendl after he became upset over something she allegedly said earlier in the night.

In October, the lawyers blocked out three days to hear testimony from detectives and corrections officers. Halverson said the defense has been working diligently to prepare for those hearings, but still has more than a dozen interviews to conduct before they’ll be ready.

Two weeks ago, Wynne scolded Scott for failing to alert the court earlier that there may be a problem providing briefing to the court.

The defense had missed a court-ordered deadline for filing any legal arguments they planned to raise at the Feb. 13 hearing.

Halverson on Friday also told Wynne that the defense likely won’t be ready for trial in September.

“The important thing here is to get things done correctly, rather than quickly,” Halverson said.

Wynne acknowledged that preparing for the pending hearing is complicated. He also said that he has the duty to make sure the case is progressing without unnecessary delays and costs.

He told the defense he expects them to notify him if they need more time, rather than ignore the court’s order.

Diana Hefley: 425-339-3463; hefley@heraldnet.com.

Talk to us

More in Local News

Traffic will be rerouted from a closed section of 220th Street SW just west of I-5 for overnight road repairs Wednesday and Thursday. (Sound Transit)
Overnight work to close 220th Street SW and southbound I-5

Contractor crews plan to repair 220th and need to close the freeway for light rail work.

With credit scores out, will insurers cut or hike your rate?

Lack of affordable housing squeezed buyers and drove up home prices across Snohomish County.

This condo on Norton Ave. in Everett was sold Friday, June 18. (Sue Misao / The Herald)
Snohomish County home values soar in latest assessment

Lack of affordable housing put the squeeze on buyers and drove up home prices across Snohomish County.

Cars make their way across US 2 between Lake Stevens and Everett as wildfire smoke makes downtown Everett barely visible on Friday, Sept. 11, 2020. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Wildfire smoke: A burning health issue is getting worse

As the hazardous haze increases during fire seasons, it’s time to get serious and prepare, experts say.

Everett's Patrick Hall was among people who put up signs in March to save the Longfellow School building.  He is now part of an advisory task force looking at options for the building, which the Everett School District had planned to tear down.  (Dan Bates / The Herald)
National register listing could be next for old Longfellow

But the designation wouldn’t stop the Everett School District from tearing down the former school.

Harry Lee Jones Jr.
Man gets 31½ years for shooting Everett motel guest 12 times

Harry Lee Jones Jr., 27, beat and then shot a Farwest Motel guest in 2018 while two accomplices looted his room.

Pallet communities are groups of tiny homes for unhoused people. Here, a worker installs weatherstripping on a pallet shelter at Pallet in Everett in January 2020. (Kevin Clark / Herald file)
Tiny home community is proposed at a Marysville church

The Pallet shelter community would provide transitional housing to eight people. Neighbors have questions.

Photo courtesy Laura Thompson 

Madison Thompson and her dog Stella.
Whidbey teen, golden retriever make top 8 in NY kennel show

Madison Thompson was one of the youngest competitors in her division of 80 kids.

A Marysville Pilchuck football player sports a spear on his helmet as the Tomahawks took on Snohomish in the Wesco 3A Championship Friday evening at Quil Ceda Stadium on November 1, 2019. School district leaders will soon need to drop Marysville Pilchuck High School’s mascot, the Tomahawks. (Kevin Clark / The Herald)
Native American mascots to be discontinued in Marysville

A new state law, which bans the use of Native American mascots by schools, takes effect July 25.

Most Read