Judge blocks tax-cutting Initiative 722

Herald staff and news reports

A Thurston County judge signed an order Thursday that temporarily blocks tax-cutting Initiative 722 – but only in the nine cities and four counties that sued to stop it.

Neither Snohomish nor Island counties, or any of their cities, are part of the suit yet, but at least one local leader says that may not matter.

And Tim Eyman, the Mukilteo man who authored 1-722, is disappointed with the order but still optimistic it will hold up in court eventually.

The cities and counties in the suit sought and got a temporary injunction on I-722, which rolls back some 1999 taxes and fees and limits property tax growth.

In Thurston County Superior Court on Thursday, plaintiffs’ lawyers argued that implementing I-722 now, before the court determines whether it is constitutional, would cause permanent damage.

Attorney James Johnson, representing the I-722 campaign, said while the initiative might inconvenience tax collectors, it wouldn’t cause irreparable harm.

Thurston County Superior Court Judge Christine Pomeroy said at the end of the three-hour hearing that she believes the plaintiffs have a case, and that I-722 could cause permanent harm if it goes into effect and then is later struck down.

Her ruling applies to the cities of Bainbridge Island, Burien, Carnation, Des Moines, Newcastle, Olympia, Pasco, Richland and Seattle; as well as King, Kitsap, Pierce and Whitman counties. Pomeroy said that, according to state law, she could not make the injunction apply to counties that did not ask for it.

Other cities and counties, unless they join the lawsuit, will have to go ahead and change their tax-collecting systems to comply with I-722 when it takes effect Dec. 7. Snohomish County and cities inside the county have stayed out of the legal fray up to this point.

Despite the judge’s comments, Snohomish County Finance Director Dan Clements said he is being told other counties may be sheltered by the ruling. The state Department of Revenue is expected to issue an administrative ruling saying all counties should follow the same rules governing property tax assessments, he said.

Clements said he also received a memo from the Washington State Association of Counties suggesting the ruling might extend to governments not joining in the suit.

Regardless, he said, Snohomish County wouldn’t see an immediate impact from I-722 because the budget recently approved by the county council holds increases in property tax revenues to the required 2 percent.

“I haven’t seen anything seriously about joining the lawsuit,” Clements said.

Plaintiff’s attorney Sandra Cohen, however, predicted the decision could set off a new round of legal moves.

“I’m not sure what they’re going to do,” she said. “I think we’re going to see a bunch of legal action.”

Johnson argued unsuccessfully that the court should put the rights of taxpayers and voters ahead of complaints from the cities and counties.

“Hundreds of thousands of people are going into Christmas thinking they have tax relief,” he said. “These people have rights.”

I-722 passed last month with 56 percent of the vote. Sponsored by Mukilteo populist Eyman, the initiative requires a refund of taxes and fees imposed since July 2, 1999. It also limits property tax growth to 2 percent a year or the rate of inflation, whichever is lower.

The plaintiffs’ lawyers argued that forcing local governments to return taxes they’ve already collected – and in some cases spent – would be disastrous. Also, since county assessors start calculating taxes for next year this month, they would have to make huge, costly changes to their systems at the last minute.

“Behind these cities are real people,” said Michelle Radosevich, representing the city of Seattle. She said if cities are forced to refund money now, it would require drastic cuts in services such as police, libraries and paramedics.

Radosevich made an example of the city of Newcastle’s golf course. The city last year imposed an admission fee on users of the golf course. Now, the owners of the golf course are demanding the city pay back $120,000 in fees collected.

“That’s a huge blow to a very small city,” Radosevich said. “We need this injunction because very bad things will happen to people in the meantime.”

Plaintiffs’ lawyers compared this initiative to Eyman’s I-695, which passed in 1999. It also sought to limit taxes, but the state Supreme Court recently struck it down as unconstitutional. Both initiatives, the attorneys said, promised a one-shot tax break while at the same time requiring a complicated restructuring of the tax system – thus violating the state constitution’s single-subject rule for laws.

State budget analysts say the I-722 revenue loss to state and local programs – and the savings to property owners – will be $376 million during the two-year budget cycle that begins next summer.

The state Department of Revenue is a defendant in the lawsuit, which adds another wrinkle to the injunction. The injunction means the Revenue Department cannot give local governments any advice on implementing I-722. Usually, the state assesses the value of property that crosses county lines – things like public utilities and railroads. Because of the injunction, the Revenue Department won’t be able to assess those properties according to the rules of I-722. Counties that don’t join the lawsuit and are trying to implement I-722 on their own will thus have a tough time doing it without help from the Revenue Department.

Gary McLean, the Des Moines city attorney, called the judge’s ruling a “victory for the constitution of the state.”

Eyman was disappointed but still optimistic that the courts will uphold I-722 in February, when both sides are scheduled to argue the merits of the case before Judge Pomeroy.

“Elected officials that choose to use taxpayer money to sue the taxpayers are going to be able to stick it to the taxpayers,” Eyman said after the judge’s decision. “Voters have this kooky idea that when they vote for something it becomes law.”

Talk to us

More in Local News

Funko mascots Freddy Funko roll past on a conveyor belt in the Pop! Factory of the company's new flagship store on Aug. 18, 2017.  (Dan Bates / The Herald)
Lawsuit: Funko misled investors about Arizona move

A shareholder claims Funko’s decision to relocate its distribution center from Everett to Arizona was “disastrous.”

1 stabbed at apartment in Lynnwood

The man, 26, was taken to an Everett hospital with “serious injuries.”

A firefighting helicopter carries a bucket of water from a nearby river to the Bolt Creek Fire on Saturday, Sep. 10, 2022, on U.S. Highway 2 near Index, Washington. (Ryan Berry / The Herald)
Red flag fire warning issued west of Cascades

There are “critical fire weather” conditions due to humidity and wind in the Cascades, according to the National Weather Service.

A house fire damaged two homes around 1:30 a.m. Tuesday, June 6, 2023 in Marysville, Washington. (Photo provided by Marysville Fire District)
Fire burns 2 homes in Marysville, killing 2 dogs

Firefighters responded to a report of a fire north of Lakewood Crossing early Tuesday, finding two houses engulfed in flames.

Logo for news use featuring the municipality of Mountlake Terrace in Snohomish County, Washington. 220118
Mountlake Terrace eyes one-time projects for $2.4M in federal funds

Staff recommended $750,000 for a new roof and HVAC at the library, $250,000 toward a nonprofit facility in Lynnwood and more.

The Snohomish River turns along the edge of the Bob Heirman Wildlife Preserve at Thomas’ Eddy on Wednesday, May 3, 2023 in Snohomish, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
To build a healthier Snohomish River, more log jams

About $2.8M in grants will help engineer log jams, tear down levees and promote salmon restoration at Bob Heirman Wildlife Preserve.

Dave "Bronco" Erickson stands next to the pink-and-purple 1991 Subaru Justy hatchback “Pork Chop Express” car that he is seeking to re-home for $500. The car has been on Whidbey Island for years, mainly as yard art. (Andrea Brown / The Herald)
For sale: Whidbey’s fabled ‘Pork Chop Express’ gets great smileage

Asking price is $500 for the 1991 Subaru Justy, a three-cylinder econobox with 65K miles and a transmission as rare as hen’s teeth.

People begin parading down First Street with a giant balloon “PRIDE” during Snohomish’s inaugural Pride celebration on Saturday, June 3, 2023, in downtown Snohomish, Washington. (Ryan Berry / The Herald)
Your guide to Pride in Snohomish County

Mark your calendars; Pride Month is upon us.

Twin sisters Lyndsay Lamb (left) and Leslie Davis (right), co-hosts of HGTV's Unsellable Houses. (Photo provided)
Meet and greet HGTV’s ‘Unsellable Houses’ twin sister stars in Snohomish on Friday

Lyndsay Lamb and Leslie Davis have made Lamb & Co. a #twinwin home-selling, home-goods brand.

Most Read