A Lynnwood traffic-enforcement camera. (Dan Bates / Herald file)

A Lynnwood traffic-enforcement camera. (Dan Bates / Herald file)

Lynnwood prevails in red-light camera court case

A judge found no proof that automated camera tickets violated the plaintiffs’ civil rights.

LYNNWOOD — A federal judge has dismissed a man’s lawsuit that claimed Lynnwood’s traffic-enforcement cameras violated his civil rights.

Ian Jordan, of Lake Forest Park, did not have legal standing in the case, U.S. District Court Judge Richard Jones wrote in his decision. Jordan did not prove that he had suffered harm nor was he in danger of being harmed, the judge found.

Jordan had asked the court to refund thousands of traffic-enforcement tickets issued by Lynnwood in certain years. Federal court was not the appropriate venue for some of Jordan’s arguments, because those citations had been resolved in Lynnwood Municipal Court, the judge said. He also was not convinced that the city’s ticketing system violated anyone’s rights.

Jones’ nine-page decision was issued Jan. 22. In recent weeks, Jordan’s attorney and city officials did not respond to requests for comment for this story.

In court papers, the city sought the dismissal, calling Jordan’s claims “illogical” and “meritless.”

The lawsuit was prompted by Jordan getting a camera ticket in 2016. He was accused of running a red light at 196th Street SW and 36th Avenue W. He later paid a mitigated $85 fine.

In the lawsuit, he raised questions about whether the city was following a state law that required it to post the citation and crash data for intersections with enforcement cameras. The city since has started doing that, acknowledging Jordan’s reminder. The available reports now include 2017 as well.

The city told the judge that Jordan failed to link the previously missing reports, which it described as “an alleged technical violation,” with a constitutional issue.

Lynnwood has held a contract with the maker of the cameras since 2006. The contract is based on an agreement between the same company and the city of Seattle.

At recent meetings, the Lynnwood City Council has been discussing what to do pending the future of Seattle’s contract. Seattle has adopted a number of short-term extensions, the most recent of which goes through 2018, documents show. The same is true for Lynnwood.

The red-light camera contract last was listed on the Lynnwood City Council agenda for a Feb. 21 work session. The school-zone cameras are under a separate contract.

Both kinds of the devices are profitable.

From 2007 through 2015, the city collected $19.2 million in gross camera revenue. It pays about $648,000 annually to lease the devices, according to documents recently provided to the council.

Rikki King: 425-339-3449; rking@heraldnet.com; Twitter: @rikkiking.

Talk to us

More in Local News

Vehicles start to back ups at I-5's exit 192 as rush hour begins. (Lizz Giordano / The Herald)
Survey: Snohomish is state’s sixth-healthiest county

While the county has low birth rates among teens, drivers here have some of the longest commute times.

Everett's Christopher Sembroski during centrifuge training at the NASTAR Center in Pennsylvania. (John Kraus/Inspiration4 photo)
Everett’s own spaceman thrilled to join all-civilian mission

Christopher Sembroski is in training to be part of a three-day SpaceX Dragon flight funded by a billionaire.

Police seek suspect in Mountlake Terrace shooting

Two men who were shot were in critical condition and transported to Harborview Medical Center in Seattle.

Snohomish County kicks off new rental assistance program

It starts with nearly $25 million from the U.S. Treasury Department. More funding is expected soon.

A dog died and several people were displaced in a fire at an apartment complex in Mukilteo on Monday. (Mukilteo Fire Department)
Dog dies in Mukilteo apartment fire early Monday

Several people were displaced, and the damage was estimated at $850,000.

Firefighters kept a wildfire in the Grandview area northeast of Arlington from growing beyond the 1.5 acres it torched Sunday afternoon. (North County Fire/EMS)
Brush fire near Arlington scorches grass and shrubs

The fire reached about 1.5 acres Sunday afternoon.

Kelsey Dunlap and Brian Matson. (Contributed photos)
2 Edmonds College students make state all-academic team

Edmonds College students make state all-academic team Edmonds College students Kelsey Dunlap… Continue reading

With desks stacked away to provide social distance spacing, tenth grader Zendon Bugge attends a World History class during the first day of school for Everett High students on Monday, April 19, 2021 in Everett, Washington.  (Andy Bronson / The Herald)
Students statewide returned to school buildings on Monday

Districts are now required to provide in-person class two days a week for kids through grade 12.

Firefighters work to put out a blaze at a house in the Meadowdale area of Edmonds early Saturday morning.  (South County Fire)
Man, woman seriously injured in Meadowdale house fire

They were taken to Harborview Medical Center. Three other adults and a dog escaped with no injuries.

Most Read