Multiple system failures likely doomed Airbus flight

PARIS — The first sign of trouble was a glitch that appeared in the air speed sensors.

Inside the sleek cockpit of Air France 447, according to French aviation experts, the crew would within minutes be confronted with a cascade of mysterious system failures.

The atmosphere of a routine international flight would vanish. Warning lights would be flashing and alarms would sound as one high technology system after another of the highly automated jetliner began going off line.

At the same time, the Airbus A-330 was flying through turbulence caused by a tropical storm rising from the equator 35,000 feet below that was capable of jostling the pilots so strongly they may have had difficulty reading the cockpit instruments.

Were the wings level? What speed were they traveling? Why were the computers downgrading their ability to move the plane’s control surfaces? As the pilots frantically worked to understand what was happening during the chaotic final minutes before the plane crashed into the Atlantic Ocean on May 31, the sky was illuminated by sporadic flashes of lightening.

“It would tax a really experienced pilot,” said Robert Ditchey, a pilot, aeronautical engineer and former U.S. airline executive. “All hell is breaking loose.”

French authorities investigating the accident that killed 216 passengers and 12 crew members are still at the early stages of determining the cause. But preliminary evidence has already made clear that the flight crew was battling a multitude of problems during the final four minutes.

The Airbus A-330 jetliner sent out 24 automated messages about abnormalities to Air France’s maintenance department in the minutes before the crash. The airline has not released that data, but some information has been leaked to outside aviation experts and ultimately to the media.

The initial event, based on what is known so far, was the simultaneous failure of three sensors that determine airspeed. The sensors are called pitot tubes, a decades-old technology.

Pilots depend on several instruments for speed information. A system of laser gyroscopes and a separate GPS system can tell pilots their ground speed. But the pitot system provides data about the speed of air flowing over the wings, critical to maintaining lift.

If all that information disappears, as apparently happened, Air France provided pilots with an emergency procedure check list.

“It’s a very long checklist,” said Guillaume Pollard, an Air France pilot and member of one of the three unions representing pilots. “You have to take the book out, look for the right page, be available to read what is written and understand what is written. So you have to have practically nothing else to do but to read this list.”

Airbus officials warned against reading too much into the failure of the air speed sensors.

“We know there has been an indication of unreliable air speed, but we don’t know how it is linked to other events,” said Airbus spokesman Stefan Schaffrath. “What we know for sure is that data transmitted, including the unreliable air speed, do not explain the accident of AF447.”

Louis Jobard, the president of one the Air France pilots unions, said the loss of the air speed data “doesn’t justify an accident.” Nonetheless, the union obtained a pledge from Air France that it would immediately replace at least two of the three pitot tubes on all of the jets.

When the pitot tubes failed, the plane’s autopilot disengaged, forcing the crew to fly the plane “by hand,” a difficult task if airspeed is uncertain and turbulence is buffeting the plane.

“One of the toughest things for a pilot to do if you have multiple emergencies is trying to determine which is the most critical one. That is the one you deal with first,” said Amos Kardos, a veteran U.S. commercial pilot.

Kardos and others say hand flying a plane should not be difficult in normal circumstances, but Air France 447 was apparently in a tough fix.

After the auto pilot disengaged, at least two other systems went off line.

A system of laser gyroscopes that provide critical information about the pitch and roll of the plane failed, meaning that the pilots may have lost their primary electronic image of the horizon.

“Not only did they lose their speed readings, but they may have lost their artificial horizon,” said Pollard. “And I can tell you that you might as well give up. In the day, it’s fine, when you have the horizon in front of you.”

The Airbus A-330, like most modern jets, has a backup system that would have provided the information. Whether it was available or also compromised is unknown.

After the laser gyroscope system failed, at least two addition problems materialized.

The stabilization system for the rear control surfaces went off line. As that system failed, the plane’s computers automatically reduced the pilot’s ability to move the plane’s control surfaces — technically known as going to “alternate flight law.”

Ditchey said alternate flight law is meant to protect the plane by reducing the ability of pilots to make a mistake, but ultimately it also may limit the ability of pilots to save the plane.

The flight laws Airbus programs into its computer embrace a fundamentally different approach to flying than those used by Boeing, which gives humans far greater authority to fly the plane, according to a wide range of pilots interviewed by the Los Angeles Times.

One critical piece of the accident puzzle involves whether the flight control system also had some role in causing the plane to break apart before it actually hit the water. The vertical stabilizer was recovered in tact, similar to the tail recovered from an American Airlines A-330 that crashed in New York in 2001.

The concern is that the flight control system may have applied excessive aerodynamic forces on the tail assembly, ripping it off the plane. That is essentially what occurred over New York.

“It doesn’t surprise me that the plane might have broken up before hitting the water, said Vincent Fave, a former investigator with the French agency that studies air disasters. “I thought that before seeing the photos because if we were in a scenario of having control difficulties in very high altitude, there’s little chance of arriving to the water whole.”

Talk to us

More in Local News

William Talbott II pleads his innocence before a judge sentences him to life with out parole at the Snohomish County Courthouse on Wednesday, July 24, 2019 in Everett, Wash. A Snohomish County judge sentenced William Talbott II to life in prison without parole, for murdering a young Canadian couple in 1987. (Andy Bronson / The Herald)
Cold-case murder conviction reversed due to juror’s bias

William Talbott, the world’s first convicted forensic genealogy defendant, was accused of killing a young Canadian couple in 1987.

Dr Chris Spitters (center), Interim Health Officer, makes makes his address Monday evening during a Special Meeting of the Snohomish Health District Board of Health at the Administration Builiding in Everett on March 2, 2020.  (Kevin Clark / The Herald)
Chris Spitters, Snohomish County’s chief health officer, to step down

The physician who has been the official voice of the pandemic here says his departure is not work-related.

Man identified after fatal fall from Arlington cell tower

Michael Vasquez, 24, of Las Vegas, fell about 140 feet while working Saturday afternoon.

Carpenters from America and Switzerland build the first "modular home" made from cross-laminated timber, inside a warehouse on Marine View Drive on Tuesday, Nov. 30, 2021 in Everett, Washington.  (Andy Bronson / The Herald)
Affordable housing’s future? Innovative home built in Everett

Swiss and American carpenters built the nation’s first “modular home” made of cross-laminated timber.

Houses at the end of the 2100 block of 93rd Drive SE in Lake Stevens used to front a forest. Now the property has been clearcut to make way for a new Costco store near the intersection of Highway 9 and 20th Street SE. (Chuck Taylor / The Herald)
Lake Stevens councilmember says he profited off Costco deal

Until now, Marcus Tageant would not confirm his role in the multimillion-dollar sale of acreage that is soon to be a Costco.

Police: Student, 13, falsely accused classmate of making threat

The student alleged the classmate called to say there would be a shooting at Hidden River Middle School.

John Lovick
State Rep. Lovick gets nod for state Senate

After Legislative District 44 Democrats nominated him, his House seat opened for party jockeying.

Brian Loomis and Michelle Moch browse for a live Christmas tree from Adopt A Stream on Tuesday, Dec. 7, 2021 in Everett, Wa. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
These holiday trees can liven a salmon’s home as well as your own

Adopt A Stream Foundation is selling native trees. Return them after the holidays, and they’ll become critical fish habitat.

Lake Stevens resident Rick Trout shows a Feb. 2020 photo of the rising lake level in front of his home after a storm. (Isabella Breda / The Herald)
Some Lake Stevens homeowners now must buy flood insurance

Updated FEMA maps show some lakeside homes now sit in a designated flood hazard area, due to a warming climate.

Most Read