WASHINGTON — Only months ago, Democrats were targeting the controversial USA Patriot Act as an ideal issue to use in their campaign against President Bush, assailing the law as an intrusion on civil rights. But in a turnabout, the act has suddenly emerged as a cornerstone of Bush’s re-election campaign, while Democratic rival Sen. John Kerry and others have toned down their criticism.
The Patriot Act is proving to be more popular in opinion polls than once expected, given its diverse range of critics. Also, both Democratic and Republican strategists now believe that public debate over the Patriot Act and other aspects of the nation’s response to terrorism only enhance the national security credentials of President Bush, while threatening to paint Kerry as soft on terrorism.
The result is that the Democrats have lost what once seemed like a useful tool for rallying opposition to the president.
"There’s a dangerous trap here for Democrats," said Jim Mulhall, a Democratic strategist working with independent groups targeting Bush. "It’s a terribly unfair characterization, but … if Democrats are not careful, they will sound more like they’re worried about technical concerns than they are about locking up terrorists."
Kerry, the presumptive Democratic presidential nominee, has recently been couching his positions on the law as "fixes," whereas in December the Massachusetts senator called for "replacing the Patriot Act with a new law that protects our people and our liberties at the same time." Kerry has even argued that his ideas would make the law, bashed repeatedly last year by nearly all the Democratic presidential contenders, tougher than it is currently.
Bush showcased his aggressive support for the Patriot Act last week, appearing in Buffalo, N.Y., with the federal prosecutor who uncovered a suspected terrorist cell dubbed the Lackawanna Six after the 2001 terrorist attacks in New York and on the Pentagon.
Bush argued that the law "defends our liberty" against terrorists and should be strengthened. He said terrorists had been caught in part because of the new law, drawing applause from a crowd of invited guests.
"The true threat to the 21st century is the fact somebody is trying to come back into our country and hurt us," Bush said. "And we ought to be able to at least send a signal through law that says we’re going to treat you equally as tough as we do mobsters and drug lords."
Passed with overwhelming support from lawmakers and signed by Bush within two months of the Sept. 11, 2001, attacks, the USA Patriot Act gives officials more powers in conducting searches and seizures and in sharing information.
It allows the government to cite terrorism and computer fraud as the basis for requesting wiretaps; allows roving wiretaps to follow suspects, no matter what telephones they use; and allows secret searches in which the authorities delay notifying a suspect.
Among other provisions, it allows the attorney general to detain any noncitizen believed to be a national security risk, in some cases for long periods of time.
The Patriot Act has been an awkward issue at times for Bush, drawing heat from some in his own conservative base. Critics have included not only the Democratic presidential candidates and the American Civil Liberties Union, but also libertarians, advocates for smaller government and members of the National Rifle Association.
Many critics denounced the act as an intrusion on privacy rights and civil liberties.
While polls have shown that certain aspects of the Patriot Act are unpopular when they are explained to voters, responses to broader questions suggest general support for the law.
More than six in 10 respondents to a February Gallup/CNN/USA Today survey said the law is just about right or does not go far enough, while only about one-fourth said it goes too far.
Talk to us
> Give us your news tips.
> Send us a letter to the editor.
> More Herald contact information.