Petition would list single captive orca as endangered

EVERETT — A proposal to list a captive killer whale as protected under the Endangered Species Act is entering an uncertain legal environment.

The orca, known as Lolita, was captured from Penn Cove off Whidbey Island in 1970 and since has been performing for audiences at privately owned Miami Seaquarium wildlife park.

Putting Lolita on the endangered list would have ramifications much wider than just where a single animal will be allowed to live. The status of other endangered animals in captivity across the country could be called into question.

Lolita is the subject of a multiyear dispute between animal rights activists and the Seaquarium. Activists have petitioned the government to list her under the Endangered Species Act.

An ESA listing could spell the end of Lolita’s performing career.

The permit required for Lolita to perform is renewable, and the Endangered Species Act, while it may allow Seaquarium to retain ownership of Lolita, does not allow entertainment permits for captive endangered animals, said Kathy Hessler, director of the Animal Law Clinic at Portland’s Lewis and Clark College Law School.

“We’re only allowed to own wild animals with permits and not allowed to own endangered wild animals except under very special circumstances,” Hessler said. Performing is not one of those circumstances, she said.

Activists, including Freeland-based Orca Network, PETA and the Animal Legal Defense Fund, have long wanted to bring Lolita back to the Northwest. They now see an ESA listing as the best vehicle to do so.

According to the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, Lolita has been determined genetically to have been born a member of the L pod of Southern Resident Killer Whales, which were listed as endangered in 2005.

It is believed her mother is Ocean Sun, an 88-year-old still swimming with L pod, said Howard Garrett, board president of Orca Network.

At the time of the ESA listing, NOAA’s Fisheries service took the unprecedented step of including language that created an exception for wild-born captive orcas.

The petition seeks to remove that language, and in January, NOAA opened the petition for public comment, as required before a ruling.

NOAA Fisheries marine biologist Lynne Barre said that the government does have a precedent to follow, in that captive members of species such as smalltooth sawfish and Atlantic sturgeon have been covered by ESA listings. The theory behind the rule change may also apply to captive chimpanzees, she said.

NOAA will accept comments through March 28, and a decision will be made within one year of that date, Barre said.

Many of the facts surrounding Lolita’s captivity are not subject to debate: she lives in an oval tank 80 feet long (and she is 20 feet long). She occasionally lives and performs with other animals, such as dolphins or sea lions, but has had no contact with others of her species for more than 40 years. She’s also in relatively good health.

Listing Lolita under the ESA wouldn’t guarantee she’d be freed, however. The government’s own study indicates that releasing Lolita into the wild might itself be a violation of the ESA.

The experience of Keiko, the orca of “Free Willy” fame, is sobering: Keiko died five years after his release.

One significant difference is that Keiko had no pod to return to, Garrett said, while Lolita’s pod still swims the waters of Puget Sound. The plan would be to gradually reintroduce Lolita to the L pod in a sea pen that would be built off San Juan Island.

In response to an earlier press release from PETA, the Miami Seaquarium issued a statement through its public relations firm that read, in part, “Even if Lolita is officially deemed part of an endangered species group, Miami Seaquarium would already be in full compliance with any additional requirements and protections that the new designation might impose.”

The Seaquarium declined to answer any questions. But its assertion that it is already in full compliance with additional requirements is not certain.

Hessler sees two possible scenarios if Lolita is added to the endangered list.

First, if NOAA’s ruling also affirms Seaquarium’s ownership rights, then some kind of deal would likely be worked out for Lolita’s release, because the Seaquarium would otherwise be paying to maintain and care for a protected animal that it couldn’t use to generate revenue.

Alternatively, NOAA could challenge Seaquarium’s right to even own Lolita, in which case laws concerning the taking of private property would apply, she said.

“That’s the ultimate goal of the ESA, to limit how we interact with animals that are endangered,” Hessler said.

But even that would not likely be the end of the story. Activists are pursuing change through the administrative rule making process. Seaquarium or the activists might pursue further appeals or petitions, or even file a lawsuit if the ultimate ruling is not to one or the other party’s liking.

A court ruling could bring more clarity to a murky part of the law but also open the doors to establishing a precedent that will change how humans interact with endangered animals across the country.

If Orca Network and the other activists ultimately prevail, then their plan to bring Lolita back to the Northwest can be put into action.

But it is likely that the fight over Lolita’s future will not be over soon.

Chris Winters: 425-374-4165; cwinters@heraldnet.com.

Talk to us

> Give us your news tips.

> Send us a letter to the editor.

> More Herald contact information.

More in Local News

Employees and patrons of the Everett Mall signed a timeline mural that traces the history of the 51-year-old indoor mall that was once considered the premier place to go shopping in the city. Thursday, March 20, 2025 (Aaron Kennedy / The Herald)
Mall mural offers nostalgic trip into the past

Past and present Everett Mall employees joined customers Thursday to view an artistic timeline of the once popular shopping mecca.

Edmonds Mayor Mike Rosen gives his State of the City address on Thursday, March 20 in Edmonds, Washington. (Will Geschke / The Herald)
Edmonds mayor talks budget at 2025 State of the City

Mayor Mike Rosen discussed the city’s deficit and highlights from his first year in office.

Jeannie Nicholos points out some of the multi-colored marks on her office wall left by lighting that struck the outside of her home and traveled inside on Thursday, March 27, 2025 in Everett, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Everett home hit by lightning, catches fire

Family escapes as roof burns; two other homes hit on Camano Island.

Snohomish County sheriff Susanna Johnson swears in colleagues during the ceremonial oath of office at the PUD auditorium in Everett, Washington on Tuesday, Jan. 2, 2024. (Annie Barker / The Herald)
Sheriff, council member elected to lead Snohomish justice council

Dunn and Johnson to co-chair as the council encourages community members to join.

Judge sets $2M bail in 1989 Everett murder case

Joseph Andrew Jacquez pleads not guilty in first court appearance after extradition from Nevada.

‘An uphill battle’: South County firefighter facing his toughest fight

Nick Jessen, 38, has stage four lung cancer, a disease disproportionately affecting his profession.

Four scams that officials say residents should watch out for

Toll scams, jury duty fraud and fake arrest warrants are among the new tactics.

Amtrak suspends most train service on Cascades route

Amtrak discovered problems with its Horizon railcars, which forced the suspension. The agency will use buses in the meantime to keep service running.

Lester Almanza, programs manager at the Edmonds Food Bank, puts together a custom shoppers order on Wednesday, March 26, 2025 in Edmonds, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
‘It’s going to lead to more hungry people’: Cuts hit SnoCo food banks

Federal and state funding to local food banks is expected to drop — even as the need has increased in recent years.

Logo for news use featuring Snohomish County, Washington. 220118
County council approves changes to ADU laws

The ordinance allows accessory dwelling units to be built in more urban areas and reduces some restrictions previously in place.

Update: Everett not included in severe thunderstorm watch from NWS

Everett could still see some thunderstorms but the severity of the threat has lessened since earlier Wednesday.

Dr. Katie Gilligan walks down a hallway with forest wallpaper and cloud light shades in the Mukilteo Evaluation and Treatment Center with Amanda Gian, right, and Alison Haddock, left, on Monday, March 24, 2025 in Mukilteo, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Partnership works to train Snohomish County mental health doctors

Compass Health works with medical students from Washington State University to provide psychiatry training. Both groups hope to fill gaps in much-needed services.

Support local journalism

If you value local news, make a gift now to support the trusted journalism you get in The Daily Herald. Donations processed in this system are not tax deductible.