Rape kit tests yield suspects but not necessarily convictions

EVERETT — The 20-year-old woman spent Christmas 2010 in a hospital exam room as a forensic nurse carefully collected swabs from her body.

The woman told Everett police someone had raped her hours earlier at a family holiday party while her husband slept nearby. The man she suspected, the only other man sleeping in the living room, denied assaulting her.

Evidence was collected from the woman, but Everett police didn’t submit the sexual assault exam kit to the Washington State Patrol crime lab for analysis.

Detectives closed the investigation “for lack of evidence.”

Everett police Capt. Greg Lineberry recently said that the kit likely wasn’t tested because of the totality of the circumstances. The officers had a named suspect at the time, and he had provided a credible statement that he wasn’t involved, Lineberry said.

“It didn’t appear that it was a case that could be prosecuted so they didn’t have it tested,” he said.

The 2010 rape kit recently was analyzed by the FBI as part of an initiative to reduce the number of untested sexual assault kits across the country.

It’s estimated that nationwide law enforcement agencies are in possession of hundreds of thousands of untested sexual assault evidence kits. Washington lawmakers last year passed legislation to reduce the number of unsubmitted kits and to address the backlog of evidence awaiting testing by the Washington State Patrol crime lab.

Everett police were notified in April that forensic scientists found DNA in the evidence collected in the 2010 case. The genetic profile allegedly matches that of the man who hosted the Christmas party, not the man initially named as a suspect.

Ignacio Fierro Sifuentes had told police back then that he’d been asleep with his wife and three children in the master bedroom at the time of the assault.

An Everett detective late last month contacted the woman who reported the rape. She confirmed that Fierro Sifuentes was in the house when she was assaulted.

Prosecutors earlier this month charged Fierro Sifuentes, 37, with third-degree rape. It’s the first case charged in Snohomish County stemming from recent efforts to reduce the number of untested sexual assault kits.

Scientists were able to identify Fierro Sifuentes because his genetic profile was already in the FBI’s national database, according to court papers. He was required to submit a DNA sample in 2011 after he was convicted of a sexually motivated attack on a woman in an Everett bar.

That felony assault happened about two weeks after the alleged rape.

Everett detectives have since learned that Fierro Sifuentes is being held in a federal detention center in New Mexico. He was deported after serving his jail sentence for the 2011 assault. He was arrested for illegal re-entry in March.

It is expected that Fierro Sifuentes will be brought back to Everett to face the rape charge. A Snohomish County judge recently signed a $150,000 warrant for his arrest.

Snohomish County deputy prosecutor Matt Baldock said Everett detectives didn’t refer the 2010 rape case to his office until recently.

If the case had been forwarded to prosecutors for review at the time, they likely would have asked Everett police to submit the kit to the State Patrol for analysis, he said.

The presence of male DNA likely would have given the detectives grounds to obtain a court order to collect cheek swabs from the men who were in the house at the time. Those genetic profiles could have been compared against the DNA recovered from the sexual assault kit, Baldock said.

The woman told police in 2010 that she and her husband attended a family Christmas Eve party in Everett. Many of the partygoers stayed overnight. The woman and her husband and other adults, along with several children, went to sleep in the living room. The homeowner, Fierro Sifuentes, his wife and their children were in the master bedroom.

The woman reported that she awoke a few hours later to find a man lying on the floor behind her. He began fondling her over her clothing. She pushed his hands away. The woman, still intoxicated, believed it was her husband, Baldock wrote in charging papers. The man pulled down her pants and engaged in sex with her. The next morning she confronted her husband, telling him that it wasn’t appropriate behavior given that there were other people in the room.

“Her husband was surprised and adamantly denied having any kind of physical contact,” with his wife during the night, Baldock wrote. She became upset, realizing that she’d been raped.

The woman assumed that the assailant was the only other adult man who had been sleeping in the living room, according to court papers. Her relatives confronted him about what happened, but he denied raping the woman. He denied the allegation again when interviewed by an Everett police detective. He said he’d slept in a chair in the living room.

The woman went to a local hospital for a sexual assault exam.

“The police investigation was closed for lack of evidence,” Baldock wrote.

Two weeks later Fierro Sifuentes was arrested at an Everett bar after attacking a 45-year-old woman in the restroom. He forced his way into the woman’s stall, grabbed her by the neck and pushed her to the ground. Fierro Sifuentes threatened to rape and kill her.

She kicked him and freed herself, and Fierro Sifuentes was detained by a security guard.

Fierro Sifuentes pleaded guilty to second-degree assault in early 2011 and was sentenced to eight months in jail. As part of his sentence Fierro Sifuentes was required to provide a DNA sample for the FBI’s national database.

There are multiple reasons sexual assault kits have not been submitted for testing over the years, Baldock said. In some instances, a victim reports the sexual assault to a medical provider but doesn’t consent to having the kit tested. Law enforcement may never learn of the allegations, Baldock said.

Police also may not believe there is probable cause to show that an assault happened, the deputy prosecutor said.

Everett detectives have prioritized testing for cases in which the suspect is unknown to the victim, Lineberry said.

“But a lot of sexual assault reports we receive involve a suspect who is known to the victim, so we already have a suspect name,” Lineberry said.

In some of those cases, the suspect claims that the sexual contact was consensual. A forensic exam is still conducted, but the DNA testing isn’t necessary for prosecution, Lineberry said.

“Those kits would typically not be sent in for testing, and over the years the number of those kits we are holding gets larger and larger,” he said.

Before new legislation was passed last year the department decided to submit all of its untested rape kits, Lineberry said. The department has about 370 kits in its property room.

A few years ago the department conducted an audit of its untested kits to determine if any that should have been tested slipped through the cracks, Lineberry said. He also wanted to take a second look at some cases to see if improvements in forensic testing might yield results. The review identified a number of kits that need testing.

Last year the department had the chance to participate in a new program with the FBI to submit older kits that had not previously been tested. Everett was allowed to submit 18 kits. The 2010 rape was in that batch. The department will be allowed to send up to 22 more once the first set is completed, Lineberry said. Everett also will be allowed to submit up to 175 untested kits to the State Patrol’s Crime Lab as part of the grant fund created by lawmakers to address the number of untested kits around the state.

The new law requires that all kits collected after July 2015 be submitted to the State Patrol’s forensic labs within 30 days. The legislation also established a task force to study how to tackle the thousands of untested kits collected before July 2015. It’s estimated that statewide there are 6,000 tests that haven’t been submitted for analysis.

Additionally, this year Gov. Jay Inslee signed a law requiring the state to track all rape kits from hospital room to police station to the crime lab.

In Everett, about 83 kits have been through the department’s review process, Lineberry said.

About 20 of those already had been tested, and there was no basis for additional examination, he said. About 63 reports have been submitted to the State Patrol, and the department is waiting for the lab to notify officers when to send in the kits. The department is reviewing the remaining 250 cases, one report at a time, to determine what 100 or so kits will be shipped to the State Patrol, Lineberry said.

Of the 83 cases that were reviewed as a part of the crime lab project, about 47 had named suspects. Eleven were cases in which the victim declined to cooperate with police. The kits were collected between 1998 and 2008.

The Snohomish County Sheriff’s Office doesn’t know how many of its 922 rape kits have been tested, spokeswoman Shari Ireton said. No searchable field was set up to track that information when the office switched over to the beleaguered New World software record tracking and dispatching system.

A deputy has been assigned to audit the kits and determine which should be submitted for testing.

Law enforcement routinely has been judicious about what kits to send to the State Patrol.

“We haven’t wanted to flood them with kits that aren’t needed for prosecution,” Lineberry said.

Police want to be able to get quick results for sexual assaults committed by unidentified suspects, he said.

Everett police are hopeful that they will be able to test all of the unsubmitted kits. There’s no guarantee the tests will help prosecute a suspect. That’s because a large number of the untested kits are from cases in which a suspect already was identified but there are other problems.

“In the vast majority, a DNA match probably won’t result in prosecution,” Lineberry said. “It will, however, add to the DNA database and may help solve other crimes where the suspect was not known or help solve crimes in the future.”

Diana Hefley: 425-339-3463; hefley@heraldnet.com. Twitter: @dianahefley

Talk to us

> Give us your news tips.

> Send us a letter to the editor.

> More Herald contact information.

More in Local News

Snohomish residents Barbara Bailey, right, and Beth Jarvis sit on a gate atop a levee on Bailey’s property on Monday, May 13, 2024, at Bailey Farm in Snohomish, Washington. Bailey is concerned the expansion of nearby Harvey Field Airport will lead to levee failures during future flood events due to a reduction of space for floodwater to safely go. (Ryan Berry / The Herald)
Harvey Field seeks to reroute runway in floodplain, faces new pushback

Snohomish farmers and neighbors worry the project will be disruptive and worsen flooding. Ownership advised people to “read the science.”

Grayson Huff, left, a 4th grader at Pinewood Elementary, peeks around his sign during the Marysville School District budget presentation on Tuesday, Nov. 28, 2023 in Marysville, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
State OKs Marysville plan with schools, jobs on chopping block

The revised plan would mean the loss of dozens of jobs and two schools — still to be identified — in a school district staring down a budget crunch.

IAM District 751 machinists join the picket line to support Boeing firefighters during their lockout from the company on Thursday, May 16, 2024, in Everett, Washington. (Ryan Berry / The Herald)
Amid lockout, Boeing, union firefighters return to bargaining table

The firefighters and the planemaker held limited negotiations this week: They plan to meet again Monday, but a lockout continues.

The Trestle’s junction with I-5 is under evaluation (Kevin Clark / The Herald)
Here’s your chance to give feedback on the US 2 trestle and its future

Often feel overwhelmed, vulnerable and on shaky ground? So is the trestle. A new $17 million study seeks solutions for the route east of Everett.

George Beard poses for a photo outside of the the Stanwood Library in Stanwood, Washington on Wednesday, May 8, 2024.  (Annie Barker / The Herald)
From sick to the streets: How an illness left a Stanwood man homeless

Medical bills wiped out George Beard’s savings. Left to heal in his car, he got sicker. Now, he’s desperate for housing. It could take years.

Logo for news use featuring Snohomish County, Washington. 220118
Lawsuit says Snohomish County deputies not justified in Sultan shooting

Two deputies repeatedly shot an unarmed Sultan man last year, body camera video shows. An internal investigation is pending.

An airplane is parked at Gate M9 on Tuesday, May 21, 2024 at O’Hare International Airport in Chicago, Illinois. (Jordan Hansen/The Herald)
Good luck to Memorial Day travelers: If you’re like me, you’ll need it

I spent a night in the Chicago airport. I wouldn’t recommend it — but with flight delays near an all-time high, you might want to pack a pillow.

Editorial cartoons for Friday, May 24

A sketchy look at the news of the day.… Continue reading

Cascade’s Mia Walker, right, cries and hugs teammate Allison Gehrig after beating Gig Harbor on Thursday, May 23, 2024 in Lacey, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Seniors Wilson, Tripp power Cascade softball past Gig Harbor

The pair combined for three homers as the Bruins won the Class 3A state softball opening-round game.

The original Mountlake Terrace City Council, Patricia Neibel bottom right, with city attorney, sign incorporation ordinance in 1954. (Photo provided by the City of Mountlake Terrace)
Patricia Neibel, last inaugural MLT council member, dies at 97

The first woman on the council lived by the motto, “Why not me?” — on the council, at a sheriff’s office in Florida, or at a leper colony in Thailand.

To the amazement of onlookers, flames shoot out the exhaust pipes on Les Sanders’ black 1950 Mercury Coupe as he drives up and down Colby Avenue with many others in classic and custom automobiles during one of the many popular Cruzin’ to Colby events held each summer in Everett. (Dan Bates / The Herald)
Cruzin’ to Colby has ‘100 years of cars’ showing off in downtown Everett

Last year, over 40,000 people came to the free event, a Memorial Day weekend tradition for nearly 25 years.

N3054V accident site. (Alaska State Trooper Photo)
Lake Stevens pilot, who lived ‘Alaska dream,’ died in Fairbanks crash

Former Snohomish County lawyer Harry “Ray” Secoy III, 63, worked as a DC-4 pilot in Alaska in the last years of his life.

Support local journalism

If you value local news, make a gift now to support the trusted journalism you get in The Daily Herald. Donations processed in this system are not tax deductible.