State: Mudslide-case email deletions were honest mistake

OSO — Attorneys defending Washington against claims that the state should be held partly responsible for the misery caused by the Oso mudslide admitted Friday it was wrong for their hired experts to systematically delete emails discussing the case.

But the state’s lawyers insisted that was an honest mistake, not “part of some nefarious plot” to hide evidence about why the hill fell in 2014.

“No attorney for the state ever directed the experts to delete emails, to reach a particular conclusion or to change their opinions,” Rene Tomisser, senior counsel at the state Attorney General’s Office, said in court papers. “To the contrary, the state’s experts’ conclusions are based solely on data, the scientific method, and their search for truth.”

The 30-page pleading was filed at close of business Friday in King County Superior Court. It was brought in response to accusations leveled by attorneys representing people harmed in the disaster, which killed 43 and caused millions of dollars in property damage.

Plaintiffs’ lawyers on Aug. 23 urged Judge Roger Rogoff to sanction the state based on evidence they allege points to “the biggest discovery fraud in the history of the state.”

It’s true that experts hired by the state in early 2015 agreed between themselves to regularly delete emails discussing their theories about why the hill fell, Tomisser wrote.

It’s also true that one member of the state’s legal team was aware of the experts’ agreement and failed to instruct them that they should preserve all emails about the case for later review, he wrote.

The lawyer who apparently knew about the email-destruction agreement is special assistant attorney general Mark Jobson. In a declaration filed along with Friday’s pleading, he said he was present when the experts discussed their plans and he mistakenly believed they would be in compliance with discovery rules because the experts’ conclusions and data ultimately would be supplied over time.

In court papers, plaintiffs’ attorneys suggested others in the state’s legal team were aware. They focused on Bob Christie, a Seattle lawyer who just months before joining the mudslide litigation was sanctioned in an unrelated case where a judge determined rampant document destruction had occurred.

Notes provided by the state’s experts show an “Attorney Bob” was present at a meeting when the decision to destroy emails was reached.

On Friday, Christie filed a declaration insisting he had no knowledge of the agreement.

“I recall no discussion about information management amongst the expert team and the attorneys,” he wrote. “I recall no discussion about emails of any kind. If others had such a discussion, I was not a party to it.”

In the pleading filed Friday, Tomisser apologized to the judge, the other parties in the case and the state’s experts for not correctly advising the scientists about how to avoid the discovery questions now at issue.

State lawyers, all the way up to state Attorney General Bob Ferguson, are engaged in trying to make the situation right, he wrote.

The attorney general’s office has hired a computer forensic expert to attempt recovery of the experts’ deleted emails. The state also has scoured its servers and secured hundreds of messages that may be responsive to discovery demands. And in pleadings Friday, the state offered to pay attorneys fees and other costs that the plaintiffs may incur questioning the experts under oath about any new information contained in the previously withheld or deleted emails.

Attorneys for those harmed by the slide have asked Rogoff to consider a number of sanctions. The harshest would be deciding the case in favor of the plaintiffs without a trial. In the alternative, they’ve suggested the state be precluded from offering testimony from its experts. If that happened, the results of roughly $3 million worth of scientific studies would not be presented to jurors, including information from the first-ever investigative drilling on the hill.

Tomisser said that would not serve justice.

The state’s experts have shared their data with the plaintiffs all along, he wrote.

They’ve filed reports challenging widely held theories, particularly the allegation that logging over the years made the hillside dangerously prone to collapse. The experts also have opined that the hillside was so geologically complex as to preclude “any reasonable predictability of the timing of a long-runout landslide within the perspective of a human lifetime,” court papers show.

Studies conducted since 2014 have found signs that giant slides have occurred repeatedly in that stretch of the North Fork Stillaguamish River Valley since the Ice Age.

“The state and its experts made no effort to hide the truth in this case,” Tomisser wrote. “Rather, it is plaintiffs’ counsel who, by their motion, ask this court to prevent a jury from inquiring into the truth of what caused the Oso landslide because of discovery errors.”

A hearing on the sanctions motion is scheduled before judge Rogoff early this month. Trial in the case, believed to be the state’s largest-ever wrongful death lawsuit, is scheduled to get underway in October.

Scott North: 425-339-3431; Twitter: @snorthnews.

This story has been modified to correctly reflect the gender of Rene Tomisser, senior counsel at the state Attorney General’s Office.

Talk to us

> Give us your news tips.

> Send us a letter to the editor.

> More Herald contact information.

More in Local News

Lead Mammography Technologist Starla DeLap talks about the different ways the Hologic 3D Mammography Exam can be situated around a patient on Wednesday, July 10, 2024 in Everett, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Providence Everett launches early breast cancer detection program

Prevention4Me, the hospital’s new breast cancer risk assessment tool, will help doctors and patients expedite diagnoses and treatment.

A boat drives out of the Port of Everett Marina in front of Boxcar Park on Wednesday, Nov. 25, 2020 in Everett, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Expand the Port of Everett’s boundaries? Voters must decide

The port calls it a workforce measure to boost the economy and add jobs. Opponents say it burdens property owners with another tax.

A closing sign hangs above the entrance of the Big Lots at Evergreen and Madison on Monday, July 22, 2024, in Everett, Washington. (Ryan Berry / The Herald)
Big Lots announces it will shutter Everett and Lynnwood stores

The Marysville store will remain open for now. The retailer reported declining sales in the first quarter of the year.

Lily Gladstone poses at the premiere of the Hulu miniseries "Under the Bridge" at the DGA Theatre, Monday, April 15, 2024, in Los Angeles. (AP Photo/Chris Pizzello)
Mountlake Terrace’s Lily Gladstone nominated for Emmy for ‘Under the Bridge’

The nomination comes after Screen Actors Guild and Golden Globe wins for her performance in “Killers of the Flower Moon.”

A Mukilteo firefighter waves out of a fire truck. (Photo provided by Mukilteo Fire Department)
Mukilteo levy lid lift will hike average tax bill about $180 more a year

The lift will fund six more workers, ambulances, equipment and medical supplies. Opponents call it unnecessary.

Doug Ewing looks out over a small section of the Snohomish River that he has been keeping clean for the last ten years on Thursday, May 19, 2022, at the Oscar Hoover Water Access Site in Snohomish, Washington. Ewing scours the shorelines and dives into the depths of the river in search of trash left by visitors, and has removed 59 truckloads of litter from the quarter-mile stretch over the past decade. (Ryan Berry / The Herald)
If Snohomish River campaign passes, polluters could be held accountable

This summer, a committee spearheaded efforts to grant legal rights to the river. Leaders gathered 1,300 signatures.

Miners Complex tops 500 acres in Mount Baker-Snoqualmie National Forest

Nine lightning-caused fires force trail closures and warnings 21 miles east of Darrington. No homes are threatened.

Targets and an assortment of trash and debris are mounded into a backstop at an unofficial shooting range along Green Mountain Road on Wednesday, July 17, 2024, near Granite Falls, Washington. Shell casings and trash are scattered along the road as well as throughout the clearcut area. (Ryan Berry / The Herald)
‘It’s like the wild west’ on popular road for shooting near Granite Falls

Officials are pleading with recreational shooters to play by the rules, as Green Mountain Road has become a dangerous trash dump.

The Snohomish County Jail is pictured on Thursday, Oct. 26, 2023, in Everett, Washington. (Ryan Berry / The Herald)
Woman, 43, dies inside Snohomish County Jail, sixth death since September

Corrections staff found the inmate unresponsive in her single-occupancy cell Wednesday. It was unclear how she died.

Port officials and future tenants shovel some earth while participating in a groundbreaking ceremony for Restaurant Row at the Port of Everett on Tuesday, July 23, 2024, in Everett, Washington. (Ryan Berry / The Herald)
Here’s the scoop on sweet additions to Everett waterfront

Two new buildings at Port of Everett will house new froyo shop, breakfast cafe, fish market, taproom and wine bar.

Logo for news use featuring the municipality of Gold Bar in Snohomish County, Washington. 220118
US 2 reopened near Gold Bar after crash

The crash Wednesday afternoon at Reiter Road east of Gold Bar caused minor injuries. Traffic was backed up a half-mile.

A transit rider steps onto a Community Transit bus on Tuesday, Jan. 3, 2023 in Everett, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
What route should new Smokey Point bus route take through Marysville?

By 2029, the Gold Line will connect Everett Station to Smokey Point. Community Transit wants your input on the exact path.

Support local journalism

If you value local news, make a gift now to support the trusted journalism you get in The Daily Herald. Donations processed in this system are not tax deductible.