Stillaguamish Tribe sues state, disputes Oso mudslide liability

OSO — The Stillaguamish Tribe of Indians has sued the state in federal court, asking that it not be held liable for damages related to the deadly Oso mudslide.

The suit came in response to letters the state Attorney General’s Office sent the tribe, stating that a wooden crib wall the tribe built in 2006 along the bank of the North Fork Stillaguamish River possibly contributed to the damage caused by the slide.

The tribe is seeking a ruling that it is not liable for any of the damages. Calls to the state Attorney General’s office and the Stillaguamish Tribe were not immediately returned.

The March 22, 2014, slide killed 43 people, injured dozens of others and destroyed 40 homes.

Later that year, victims, the estates of the deceased and property owners in the slide zone sued Snohomish County, the state and Grandy Lake Forest Associates, a timber company that years earlier logged the top of the hill where the slide took place.

Among other claims, the plaintiffs contend the crib wall gave the people in the neighborhood a false sense of security. The case is scheduled to go to trial in the fall.

For decades before the 2014 slide, the hillside above the Steelhead Haven neighborhood outside Oso had been a source of sediment in the river, which degraded salmon spawning grounds.

In April 2005, Pat Stevenson, the environmental manager for the tribe, signed an agreement with the state Salmon Recovery Funding Board that provided $497,000 to improve fish habitat.

In 2006, after a large slide damaged some fishing cabins along the river, the tribe built the crib wall and retention ponds to reduce the sediment and further erosion at the toe of the slide.

In the letter sent to the tribe this year, the Attorney General’s office claimed the tribe shares in the state’s potential liability for the work done on the riverbank. The tribe might be responsible for a share of the $12 million the state estimated might be due to the plaintiffs, the state said.

“The claims asserted by the plaintiffs related to the crib wall and sediment retention ponds constructed by the Stillaguamish Tribe as part of its project trigger the Tribes’ duty to defend, identify, and hold harmless the State from these claims as provided by the funding agreement,” the Attorney General’s letter states.

The tribe disputed the claim, saying the agreement between the tribe and state is invalid because there is no evidence the tribe’s board of directors approved the agreement, and Stevenson was never authorized to sign it.

The Supreme Court ruled in 1992 that tribes are immune from state tort claims.

“Without a Board resolution approving the Agreement or authorizing anyone to sign it on the Tribe’s behalf, the Tribe did not agree to be bound by the Agreement or any of the provisions therein, and the Tribe could not have waived its inherent sovereign immunity for claims arising out of this agreement,” the suit states.

Even if the agreement were valid, the tribe stated, the waiver of immunity only applied to actions the state could take to enforce the agreement, which excludes third-party actions — such as the lawsuit brought by those harmed in the Oso mudslide.

Chris Winters: 425-374-4165; cwinters@heraldnet.com. Twitter: @Chris_At_Herald.

More in Local News

Nation’s first coronavirus patient said to be fully recovered

The Snohomish Health District has released the man from home isolation.

Gun-ammunition bill is suffocated by GOP amendments

It’s Day 40 of 60 of the 2020 session of the Washington Legislature in Olympia.

Chris Walsh and his wife, Carol, talk outside the Delta Rehabilitation Center about their plans to close the care facility long known as the Snohomish Chalet. Chris is the owner and administrator of the nursing home that cares for people with severe brain injuries. Carol has worked as a nurse there for many years. (Dan Bates / The Herald)
Delta Rehabilitation, home to brain injury victims, to close

“There’s no replacement,” head of care facility agency says of place once known as Snohomish Chalet.

A Hamas heir, a nose job, $1.5 million — and global intrigue

An urgent plastic surgery request in Lynnwood may have exposed huge fraud by a Palestinian refugee.

Edmonds School District leaders plan for another school bond

It won’t be in April, but the district could float another bond proposal in August or November.

Boeing asks that its big state tax break be suspended

The company hopes the move will resolve a trade dispute involving European rival Airbus.

Everett defense investigator stripped of license

Witness tampering charges against Michael Powers were dropped, in a deal that ends his career.

Body scanner could replace strip searches in Monroe prison

A new bill suggests using a scanner, like those in airports, to check for contraband on or in people.

High school wrestler steps in after twin faces fight of his life

SULTAN — Tyler Deason was the one his family thought would be competing at the state high school wrestling tournament.

Most Read