Supreme Court upholds federal electricity rules

By Gina Holland

Associated Press

WASHINGTON – The Supreme Court today upheld federal rules intended to give people choices for electricity service, but rejected arguments by Enron Corp., for even freer access to the nation’s power grids.

The justices, in a case involving states’ rights and federal authority over electricity markets, also turned back an argument by nine states that the government had overstepped its authority when it directed utilities to open power lines to competitors.

Enron, which before its bankruptcy was one of the nation’s top electricity traders, had maintained that federal regulators had not given power marketers the same access to electricity grids as held by traditional, state-regulated utilities.

The states in presentations before the court Oct. 3, before the severity of Enron’s troubles was publicly known, said the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission had usurped the states’ traditional authority to regulate retail prices when it opened the wholesale power grids to competition in 1996.

But the Justice Department, speaking on behalf of the commission, had argued that the commission pursued a balanced approach that allowed competitors access to power lines, but left retail market issues to states.

The justices agreed and in its ruling today rejected the arguments of both Enron and those of the nine states, led by New York.

The case has been viewed as pivotal in determining the direction of electricity competition at a time when many states – in light of the Enron debacle and recent California power crisis – have been reconsidering electricity deregulation and retail competition.

Some members of Congress also have questioned the extent to which wholesale power markets should be regulated amid allegations of market abuses by Enron.

Enron had maintained that the 1996 FERC order continued to give too much power to state-regulated utilities to “hog” the transmission lines with power they generate and also sell retail.

The ruling said the federal government controls the management of the nation’s power grids – and the future of electricity competition. But it also said that the federal government could limit its assertion of such authority in some cases.

Writing for the majority, Justice John Paul Stevens said that while FERC had the authority to require broader access it also “had discretion to decline to assert such jurisdiction in this proceeding in part because of the complicated nature of the jurisdictional issues” between federal and state interests.

The FERC’s decision in 1996 to require utilities’ power transmission lines to be opened to competing power merchants was key to helping companies like Enron, which sought to market electricity on both the wholesale and retail levels.

Richard Pierce Jr., a George Washington University law professor, said the ruling in its general endorsement of federal authority over power line access, “is terribly important for anybody who’s a consumer and interested in getting a level playing field.”

“The issue is far from dead, even if Enron’s role is no longer what it once was,” he said.

FERC’s 1996 order led numerous states to end monopolies in retail power markets. About half the states have moved toward electricity competition.

But utility regulators in Florida, Idaho, New Jersey, New York, North Carolina, Virginia, Washington, Vermont and Wyoming filed suit arguing that FERC’s directive limited states’ authority to control retail sales.

Enron filed for bankruptcy protection in December. A division of the company, Enron Power Marketing Inc., was involved in this case.

Copyright ©2002 Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

Talk to us

> Give us your news tips.

> Send us a letter to the editor.

> More Herald contact information.

More in Local News

Refugee and Immigrant Services Northwest Senior Associate ESL Instructor James Wilcox, right, works on speaking and writing with Anfal Zaroug, 32, who is accompanied by her daughter Celia Hassen, 6 months, on Friday, Nov. 15, 2024 in Everett, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
What will Trump’s immigration policy mean for Snohomish County?

The president-elect has vowed to ramp up deportations and limit legal immigration.

Water cascades down the Lower Falls near the Woody Trail at Wallace Falls State Park near Gold Bar on Thursday, Sept. 17, 2015. A nearly six mile round-trip to the park's Upper Falls offers hikers an array of vistas on a well maintained trail.
Wallace Falls closed due to bomb cyclone damage

Over 170 trees fell in last month’s storm. The park near Gold Bar is closed until further notice.

Neepaporn “A” Boungjaktha (Snohomish County)
Snohomish County executive director takes new gig with Port of Seattle

Neepaporn “A” Boungjaktha joined the county in 2022. Her last day will be Jan. 2.

People walk into the Everett Library off of Hoyt Avenue on Tuesday, Dec. 3, 2024 in Everett, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
How will new Everett library hours affect its programs?

This month, the two branches scaled back their hours in light of budget cuts stemming from a city deficit.

The Evergreen Branch of the Everett Public Library is open and ready for blast off. Dillon Works, of Mukilteo, designed this eye-catching sculpture that greets people along Evergreen Way.   (Dan Bates / The Herald)
Snohomish County awards money to improve warming, cooling centers

The money for HVAC improvements will allow facilities to better serve as temporary shelters for weather-related events.

Marysville
Marysville to hold post-holiday ‘tree-cycling’ event

You can dispose of your tree and holiday packaging Jan. 4.

A member of the Fire Marshal’s Office circles the remnants of Seattle Laestadian Lutheran Church after it was completely destroyed by a fire Friday, August 25, 2023, near Maltby, Washington. (Ryan Berry / The Herald)
Texas woman accused of arson in Maltby church fire

The August 2023 fire destroyed the Seattle Laestadian Lutheran Church. Natasha Odell faces state and federal charges.

Everett
Police searching for suspect in fatal Everett shooting

A man was found with multiple gunshot wounds Wednesday night in the Silver Lake neighborhood, police said.

The Safeway at 4128 Rucker Ave. on Wednesday. This location was set to be one of the 19 in Snohomish County sold to C&S Wholesale if the merger between Kroger and Albertsons went through. (Will Geschke / The Herald)
Washington unions celebrate Kroger-Albertsons merger’s demise

Nineteen grocery stores in Snohomish County would have been sold if the deal went through.

A view of one of the potential locations of the new Aquasox stadium on Monday, Feb. 26, 2024 in Everett, Washington. The site sits between Hewitt Avenue, Broadway, Pacific Avenue and the railroad. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Everett committee finds downtown AquaSox stadium more viable

But both options — a new downtown stadium or a Funko Field remodel — cost more than the city can raise right now.

Lynnwood
Man, 24, killed in Lynnwood shed fire identified

The cause of the fire that killed Lukas Goodman remained under investigation this week.

Logo for news use featuring the municipality of Snohomish in Snohomish County, Washington. 220118
Snohomish school leader on leave following sex abuse allegations

Last month, police arrested Julian Parker for investigation of child rape. Prosecutors are reviewing the case for charges.

Support local journalism

If you value local news, make a gift now to support the trusted journalism you get in The Daily Herald. Donations processed in this system are not tax deductible.