Whidbey sailor hurt in shooting files $20 million complaint

He had gone to try to help a friend who was armed and suicidal during a standoff with police.

By Jessie Stensland / Whidbey News-Times

A Navy man injured during an unusual 2017 police standoff that ended in the fatal shooting of another sailor filed a $20-million tort claim against Island County but hasn’t followed up with a lawsuit.

On May 4, the attorney for Heath Garcia and his wife filed the claim for damages, which is a step that has to be taken at least 60 days before a lawsuit can be filed in superior court against a governmental entity.

The claim was forwarded to the county’s risk pool, which handles torts and lawsuits against the member counties.

Garcia was shot above the ankle during the Sept. 17, 2017 incident and badly injured, ending his Navy career just short of retirement, the claim states.

In the Sept. 17, 2017 incident, Navy member Nicholas Perkins was armed and suicidal at his North Whidbey house, which led to a standoff with deputies with the Island County Sheriff’s Office, according to an analysis of the shooting by Island County Prosecutor Greg Banks. He declined to charge anyone.

After finding out about the incident involving his friend, Garcia left his post at Naval Air Station Whidbey Island without permission and went to the scene, Banks’ report states.

Garcia, however, later claimed he had permission to go.

At the scene, Garcia allegedly entered the home without permission from law enforcement in an attempt to talk his friend down. Garcia later claimed he did have permission from law enforcement.

Whether he had permission or not, Garcia exited the house and law enforcement officers on the scene, led by Lt. Mike Hawley, allowed him to go back into the house again in an attempt to prevent Perkins from hurting himself or anyone else.

Other members of the Navy also arrived at the scene and were able to talk Perkins into coming out, but he did so armed with a shotgun and yelling obscenities, the prosecutor’s report states; Garcia suddenly put Perkins in a bear hug and a deputy tackled the two men to the ground.

During a struggle on the ground, Perkins managed to switch off the safety on the deputy’s rifle and pulled the trigger 10 times, Banks wrote. One of the bullets struck Garcia in the lower leg.

Another deputy joined the tussle and shot Perkins three times, killing him.

The tort argues that law enforcement should never have allowed a civilian “to become involved in, and actively participate in, an extraordinarily dangerous incident involving an armed, military-trained service member suffering from mental illness, who was barricaded in his own home.”

“The Island County Sheriff’s Department and incident commander failed to ensure that proper procedures and responses were followed,” the complaint states.

The claim also states that the sheriff’s office failed to have a SWAT or a trained negotiator on scene.

Garcia suffered “terrible injuries” that required his ankle to be surgically reconstructed, the claim states.

Garcia was “medically retired” from the Navy in March of this year, which was 18 years and 10 months into his career, the complaint states.

This story originally appeared in the Whidbey News-Times, a sister publication to The Herald.

Talk to us

More in Local News

Sid Logan (left) and Rob Toyer
PUD candidates focus on rates, broadband and renewables

Incumbent Sidney Logan faces former Marysville City Council member Rob Toyer for the District 1 seat.

Motorcycle rider dies after collision with car near Stanwood

The investigation of the fatal crash on Pioneer Highway closed stretches of it to drivers.

Deputies search for suspect after shooting south of Everett

One man was transported to a hospital with non-life threatening injuries. A shooter reportedly fled.

Bill Bruch (left ) and Dave Paul
First-term Dem faces a GOP challenger for House seat in 10th

Rep. Dave Paul and Bill Bruch differ widely on the response to COVID-19.

Ballot drop box in Mill Creek hit by truck

The box was damaged Friday. Ballots inside will be counted. Officials gave other dropoff options.

FILE - In this July 31, 2015 file photo, an orca leaps out of the water near a whale watching boat in the Salish Sea in the San Juan Islands, Wash. Habitat protections for an endangered population of orcas would be greatly expanded under a proposal to be advanced by NOAA Wednesday, Sept. 18, 2019. (AP Photo/Elaine Thompson, File)
Millions have been spent on orca recovery: Is it working?

Restoring destroyed salmon habitat is the key to regaining Southern Resident killer whale numbers.

This firetruck serves the South County Fire District. (City of Lynnwood)
Two fire districts want to change how they make money

South County Fire wants to do a benefit charge, while Sky Valley Fire looks for a levy lid lift.

Sawyer West was last seen Oct. 16 at Highway 99 and 220th Street Southwest in Lynnwood. (Courtesy Carol Crane)
Search continues for missing man last seen in Lynnwood

Family, friends and police ask that people keep an eye out for Sawyer West, who has schizophrenia.

Most Read