Auburn cop’s story conflicts with witness account of killing

Police officer Jeffrey Nelson has been charged with murder in the killing of Jesse Sarey.

Auburn police officer Jeffrey Nelson. (Auburn Reporter, file)

Auburn police officer Jeffrey Nelson. (Auburn Reporter, file)

Auburn police officer Jeffrey Nelson’s written statement regarding the killing of Jesse Sarey conflicts with the eyewitness’s account on key details.

A month after Nelson shot and killed Jesse Sarey, he sat down at an Auburn police substation with his lawyer and two Port of Seattle police officers to read a prepared statement on the killing. Audio of this statement was obtained by the Auburn Reporter through public records requests.

In his statement, Nelson claims that during the fight, Sarey pulled a pocket knife out of a chest pocket on Nelson’s jumpsuit and used it as a weapon.

“The subject then changed hands and secured my jumpsuit with his left hand and removed my utility knife with his right hand,” Nelson said. “I observed the silver blade become visible and it occurred to me in that instant the subject had not only removed my knife but had apparently chosen to open it.”

Nelson continues to describe closing his eyes, anticipating that Sarey would fatally stab him in the face or the neck. When no stab occurred, Nelson said he pulled his gun out, pointed it at Sarey and shot him in the torso.

“At the moment I fired I believed that at this point in the struggle I had no other reasonable alternative regarding the use of force, and that the use of deadly force was appropriate to avoid being killed or seriously injured,” Nelson said.

After Nelson shot Sarey in the torso, he said Sarey fell backwards and then onto his knees. At that point, Nelson claims he didn’t know whether or not he shot Sarey and that his gun had jammed.

Nelson describes unjamming his gun by clearing the spent round and cycling another round before looking around.

“It was my impression that the subject had not been stopped and remained a threat, the male subject was positioned in a squatting fashion with his hands before his knees,” Nelson said. “I could not discern whether my first round hit him.”

Nelson claims Sarey still had the knife, so Nelson then shot Sarey in the head, point blank.

Nelson’s account differs from the statement of an eyewitness — who was standing directly behind the two men — given merely hours after the shooting. Audio recordings of the eyewitness’s interview with Federal Way police officers was also obtained through public records requests.

Unlike in Nelson’s story, the witness said while the men were fighting, a knife fell near his feet.

“A knife flew at my foot … it’s a black and silver foldable knife, I’m not sure whose it was but it came over by my feet and I picked it up and threw it on my car,” the witness said.

The witness said after he picked up the knife and put it on his car, Nelson got Sarey in a headlock and punched him several times in the face, then Sarey fell down, the witness said.

“Right after that the dude [Sarey] fell down and officer Nelson pulled out his gun and shot him, it looked like in the stomach or chest to me, and then officer Nelson, after he shot him, he looked up at me and then he shot him in the head,” the witness said.

It is possible that there were two similar looking folding knives on the scene. However, neither the witness nor Nelson acknowledge the presence of a second knife.

Another discrepancy is in the way Nelson and the witness describe how Sarey was acting after the first shot. Nelson said he still believed Sarey was a threat. The witness on the other hand said Sarey gave up and wasn’t doing anything.

“He [Sarey] was on the ground, shot, he wasn’t moving, he wasn’t trying to resist, he wasn’t trying to fight, he wasn’t trying to do none of that,” the witness said.

Nelson said he felt the second shot was necessary to protect himself and the public from Sarey, but the witness said the second shot was unnecessary.

The witness said at no time after the second shot did Nelson or any of the police who showed up check on Sarey.

Security camera footage from nearby businesses confirm the witness’s claim that he picked up Nelson’s folding knife and put it on his car, Prosecuting Attorney Dan Satterberg said.

The statement given by the witness was recorded at the scene a few hours after the shooting happened. Although Nelson’s statement was read by him a month after the shooting, it is unclear when the statement was written.

Nelson is the first police officer to be charged with murder since Washington voters approved I-940, which changes the burden of proof for prosecution of police homicides, according to King County Prosecutor Dan Satterberg’s office.

Prior to I-940, a prosecutor would have to prove an officer acted with “malice” and “lack of good faith” when they killed someone, an impossible standard to meet. The new standard under I-940 is concerned with whether an officer’s actions were “reasonable,” Satterberg said.

Nelson will appear before the court on July, 27, 2022, for his trial in the murder and assault of Jesse Sarey.

This story originally appeared in the Auburn Reporter, a sister publication to The Herald.

Talk to us

More in Northwest

FILE - Randy Weaver, the object of the Ruby Ridge siege, visits with the media at the main FBI roadblock outside the Freemen compound in Montana on April 27, 1996. Weaver, patriarch of a family that were involved in an 11-day Idaho standoff in 1992 with federal agents that left three people dead and served as a spark for the growth of anti-government extremists, has died at the age of 74. His death was announced Thursday, May 12, 2022, in a Facebook post by daughter Sara Weaver, who lives near Kalispell, Montana. (AP Photo/Jim Mone, File)
Randy Weaver, participant in Ruby Ridge standoff, dies at 74

The 11-day standoff in the Idaho Panhandle mountains transfixed the nation in August of 1992.

FILE - Washington Attorney General Bob Ferguson speaks March 23, 2022, at the Capitol in Olympia, Wash. Months into a complex trial over their role in flooding Washington with highly addictive painkillers, the nation's three largest opioid distributors have agreed to pay the state $518 million. Ferguson announced the deal Tuesday, May 3, 2022. (AP Photo/Ted S. Warren, File)
DNA from 372 state sex offenders added to national database

Officials have been unable to collect samples from some offenders, including three in Snohomish County.

Andrew Cain Kristovich (Snohomish County Sheriff's Office)
Oregon fugitive with Snohomish County ties arrested in Nevada

Andrew Cain Kristovich escaped from a federal prison camp in April. He was considered armed and dangerous.

FILE - In this Monday, March 1, 2021 file photo, The first Alaska Airlines passenger flight on a Boeing 737-9 Max airplane takes off on a flight to San Diego from Seattle-Tacoma International Airport in Seattle. A Boeing pilot involved in testing the 737 Max jetliner was indicted Thursday, Oct. 14,2021 by a federal grand jury on charges of deceiving safety regulators who were evaluating the plane, which was later involved in two deadly crashes. (AP Photo/Ted S. Warren, File)
Alaska Airlines to keep canceling flights at high level for weeks

Flight cancellations since April will continue. The chaos has been damaging for Seattle’s hometown airline.

Barbara Williams, center, holds an umbrella for her mother, tribal chair Cecile Hansen, right, as they prepare to join other members of the Duwamish Indian Tribe in performing an "honor song" Wednesday, Feb. 27, 2008 near a location in Seattle where bones were found during construction activities near the Pike Place Market. The song was performed because the tribe felt at the time that the remains could have been from an ancient member of the tribe, but city authorities said later in the day that the remains appeared to have been from a small animal. (AP Photo/Ted S. Warren)
Duwamish Tribe sues again for federal recognition

Tthe lawsuit demands the court set aside the denial of recognition in 2015 by the Obama administration.

A pod of transient orcas, known as T124As, surfacing near Tacoma. (Craig Craker/Orca Network)
Sightings of mammal-eating orcas increasing in Puget Sound

The killer whales enjoy a diet of harbor seals, sea lions, porpoises and the occasional bird or squid.

FILE - Bill Gates discusses his book "How to Prevent the Next Pandemic" at the 92nd Street Y on May 3, 2022, in New York. Microsoft co-founder and billionaire philanthropist Bill Gates posted on Twitter on Tuesday, May 10, 2022, that he tested positive for COVID-19. He said he was experiencing mild symptoms and was following the experts' advice by isolating until he is healthy again. (Photo by Evan Agostini/Invision/AP, File)
Bill Gates says he has COVID, experiencing mild symptoms

The billionaire philanthropist said he will isolate until he is again healthy.

FILE - Idaho Lt. Gov. Janice McGeachin enters the house chambers at the state Capitol building on Jan. 10, 2022 in Boise, Idaho. McGeachin, a GOP candidate for governor, on Monday, May 9, 2022, called on incumbent Republican Gov. Brad Little to call a special session to eliminate rape and incest as legal exceptions to Idaho's abortion law. The law would go into effect if the U.S. Supreme Court overturns Roe v. Wade. (AP Photo/Otto Kitsinger, File)
Idaho lieutenant governor wants harshest U.S. abortion ban

Janice McGeachin is angling for state lawmakers to eliminate exceptions for rape and incest.

Crews finish clearing the roadway on SR 20. (Washington State Department of Transportation)
The North Cascades Highway is set to open Tuesday

Officials warn that it’s still wintery and avalanche potential remains in the backcountry.

50 dams in state — including 4 in Snohomish County — need repairs

Deferred maintenance and the changing climate may play a role in the dams’ deteriorating conditions.

(U.S. Department of Agriculture)
State’s 2nd outbreak of bird flu confirmed in Spokane County

Last week the disease was found in Pacific County, also in a backyard flock of chickens.

Tina Podlodowski, chair of the Washington State Democratic Party, is making a case for Washington to be among the first five states to host a presidential primary in 2024. (Washington State Democrats)
Washington Democrats seek to host early presidential primary

A letter of intent was sent to the Democratic National Committee’s Rules and Bylaws Committee.