Convicted killer’s motions clog Island County court system

Convicted killer’s motions clog Island County court system

“It was Mr. Lambert’s excessive filings that brought Odyssey to its knees,” the prosecutor said.

By Jesse Stensland / Whidbey News-Times

A convicted murderer being held in Island County jail is making the most of the legal system.

Joshua Lambert, 36, is acting as his own attorney and inundated the court with around 200 motions ahead of his re-sentencing hearing. He appeared in Island County Superior Court last Friday to be sentenced, but Judge Vickie Churchill rescheduled it to June 15 because of confusion about whether the hearing was stricken.

Both Churchill and Island County Prosecutor Greg Banks said they’ve had trouble looking at Lambert’s motions in the online court system Odyssey. Banks contacted the company’s technicians about the problem.

“It was Mr. Lambert’s excessive filings that brought Odyssey to its knees,” he said.

The problem still wasn’t fixed ahead of another hearing Monday over Lambert’s motions.

The Appeals Court last year reversed Lambert’s convictions for the “felony murder” of his 80-year-old grandfather August Eisner and the first-degree burglary of his parents’ North Whidbey house in 2011. His convictions for the murder of his other grandfather, 80-year-old George Lambert, and the kidnapping of his great aunt and several other counts were affirmed by the court.

Lambert will be re-sentenced on the charges that were affirmed. Banks has yet to decide whether to retry him for the Eisner murder.

Churchill originally sentenced Lambert to 100 years in prison.

Lambert acted as his own attorney during the trial and is still pro se for the sentencing hearing.

Lambert has argued that he has schizophrenia and, therefore, is not culpable for the murders; he said he was diagnosed with the disorder while in prison.

Churchill went through a series of Lambert’s motions in court last week. Banks opined about why each should be dismissed, but Lambert invoked his Miranda right to silence. At the end of the hearing, however, he said he wanted to subpoena mental health professionals, Department of Corrections officers and others to testify at his sentencing hearing.

A community corrections officer with the state Department of Corrections conducted a pre-sentence investigation for the sentencing hearing. Lambert originally received an exceptional sentence, but the corrections officer recommended against an exceptional sentence. She recommended a sentence of 51 years and eight months in prison.

Talk to us

> Give us your news tips.

> Send us a letter to the editor.

> More Herald contact information.

More in Northwest

Masked federal agents arrive to help immigration agents detain immigrants and control protesters June 4 in Chicago. California in September became the first state to ban law enforcement officers from wearing face coverings, in response to immigration raids where federal agents wore masks. (Jamie Kelter Davis/The New York Times)
Ban on police face coverings pitched ahead of WA’s 2026 legislative session

The Trump administration is challenging a similar law passed in California, amid worries over masked immigration agents.

Police are failing to solve most violent crimes in WA

Over 49,000 incidents remain unsolved since 2022, including murders, rapes and robberies.

A Flock Safety camera on Oct. 28, 2025 in Lynnwood, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Washington lawmakers want to regulate license plate readers

Washington state lawmakers next year hope to rein in law enforcement’s use… Continue reading

Democratic state Rep. Shaun Scott of Seattle (left) is proposing a new payroll tax on large employers in Washington. He took part in a discussion on the state’s tax system during the Budget Matters Summit on Nov. 12, 2025 in Seattle. (Photo courtesy of Washington State Budget and Policy Center)
WA Dems’ latest run at taxing the state’s largest companies

Rep. Shaun Scott’s proposal mirrors an approach Senate Democrats drew up then discarded last session.

Washington Gov. Bob Ferguson appointed Colleen Melody to the state Supreme Court on Nov. 24, 2025. Melody, who leads civil rights division of the state Attorney General’s Office, will assume her seat following the retirement of Justice Mary Yu at the end of the year. (Photo by Jerry Cornfield/Washington State Standard)
Gov. Bob Ferguson makes his pick for WA Supreme Court seat

Colleen Melody, who leads the civil rights division at the state attorney general’s office, will succeed Justice Mary Yu, who is retiring.

Jsason Phipps of the City of Mount Vernon tightens straps on the flood wall along the Skagit River in downtown Mount Vernon on Thursday. The river is forecast to crest on Friday morning after several days of heavy rain pushed waterways in the region to record levels. (Grant Hindsley/The New York Times)
Record flooding forces rescues across Western Washington

Waterways crested at record levels in several flooded small towns across western… Continue reading

Florida Lt. Gov. Jay Collins, left, participates in the extradition from California of Harjinder Singh, accused of causing a crash that killed three people in Florida. (Photo via Collins’ X account)
WA erred in granting hundreds of commercial driver’s licenses to noncitizens

The issue has flared up after a fatal truck crash in Florida earlier this year.

The state ferries Klahowya (center right) and Hyak (left center) are taking up valuable space at the Eagle Harbor maintenance yard of Washington State Ferries. Both retired ferries have been for sale for more than four years. (Photo by Tom Banse for Washington State Standard)
For sale: Two retired state ferries. Dreamers need not apply

The vessels are lingering on the market as Washington State Ferries scrutinizes potential buyers. Past purchases haven’t always ended well.

Washington began selling a specialty plate honoring Pickleball on Nov. 19, 2025. This is a sample of a personalized plate. (Seattle Metro Pickleball Association)
It’s an ace. Pickleball gets its own Washington license plate

The design celebrates the state’s official sport. Other new plate designs are on the way.

Gov. Bob Ferguson signing Senate Bill 5480, a bill exempting medical debt from credit reports, on April 22. (Photo by Jacquelyn Jimenez Romero/Washington State Standard)
WA’s new ban on medical debt in credit reports at risk of federal override

The Trump administration wants to reverse Biden-era guidance on the issue.

The U.S. Capitol building in Washington, D.C., on May 7, 2025. (Photo by Jennifer Shutt/States Newsroom)
End of shutdown ignites sparring among congressional lawmakers

Meanwhile, U.S. Rep. Marie Gluesenkamp Perez was among six Democrats who sided with Republicans in voting the legislation out of the House.

Attorney General Nick Brown has proposed new advice for locales on how to interpret state public records law, with a focus on providing records faster. (Stock photo)
Need for speed: Plan to unclog WA public records system gets mixed reviews

Washington’s attorney general is seeking to reduce public record backlogs as concerns… Continue reading

Support local journalism

If you value local news, make a gift now to support the trusted journalism you get in The Daily Herald. Donations processed in this system are not tax deductible.