Seattle-area man is 3rd in U.S. with 2nd confirmed COVID case

The patient, in his 60s, tested positive in early March and got sick against nearly 5 months later.

By Sandi Doughton / The Seattle Times

The Seattle-area nursing home resident first tested positive for the novel coronavirus in early March. He spent more than 40 days in the hospital with fever, pneumonia and difficulty breathing before testing negative multiple times and being discharged.

Then, nearly five months later, he got sick again with COVID-19.

Now, genetic testing by a team of Seattle physicians and scientists has revealed that sexagenarian’s second bout of the illness caused by the coronavirus in July wasn’t a relapse but a new infection with a slightly different variant of the virus.

The patient is just the third person in the United States — and one of about 20 worldwide — confirmed to have experienced such a double whammy.

Since posting a preprint in late September describing their findings, which have not been peer-reviewed, the Seattle team has confirmed one additional local reinfection and is examining a handful of other possible cases, said Dr. Jason Goldman, an infectious-disease specialist at Swedish Medical Center.

“It’s not unexpected this would occur, because we know immunity wanes to other respiratory infections, like flu,” Goldman said. “But I was a little surprised to find it in my own hospital.”

“And we still don’t know what level of immunity you need to be protected,” he said.

The local patient wasn’t as sick the second time around and has since recovered, which suggests some level of protection even if it wasn’t strong enough to block infection, Goldman noted. That seems to be the case for most reinfections reported so far, he added.

But for a handful of patients, including a 25-year-old Nevada man whose experience was first made public in August followed by a full report published this week in The Lancet, the second infection was more severe. An 89-year-old woman in the Netherlands, who was also undergoing chemotherapy for lymphoma, is the first person known to have died from a repeat infection.

According to a site that tracks reinfections around the globe, the other U.S. case was a 45-year-old man who works at a military hospital in Virginia and who also was much sicker during his second bout with the virus.

Building on a collaboration between Swedish Health Services and the Seattle-based Institute for Systems Biology (ISB) to assemble a vast “biobank” of health data from COVID-19 patients, the Seattle team performed the most detailed analysis yet of a patient’s immune response to a second infection.

They found that the patient’s body was slow to produce antibodies, particularly the type most effective at neutralizing the virus.

They also determined through genetic sequencing that the initial infection was caused by the viral variant that hit Washington early in the pandemic and which is closely related to the original strain first discovered in Wuhan, China. The patient’s second infection was caused by a separate variant that triggered major outbreaks on the East Coast and arrived in the U.S. via Europe. That strain now predominates in the U.S.

In laboratory tests, the antibodies the patient eventually produced after his second infection were somewhat more effective at neutralizing the European variant than the first strain.

But the difference isn’t big enough to raise concerns about vaccines based on the original strain, or to suggest that the shift in viral strains was responsible for the patient’s reinfection, said Dr. Bill Messer, an infectious-disease physician and virologist at Oregon Health & Science University who was not involved in the analysis.

“This isn’t a case of the second virus escaping the immune response to the first virus,” Messer said.

What’s more likely is that the patient failed to develop a robust and lasting immune response to the first infection and so fell prey again, Messer said.

Some documented reinfections have occurred in people with compromised immune systems, like the Dutch woman who died. The Seattle-area patient also suffers from emphysema, and was treated with steroids, which can dampen immune response, Messer pointed out.

“There’s probably something about this patient’s immune system that isn’t really functioning well,” Goldman agreed.

But because no blood samples were stored from the man’s first infection, the researchers weren’t able to compare the two immune responses.

However, the Seattle team and their collaborators do have two sets of samples for some of the other possible reinfections they are investigating, said Dr. Jim Heath, president of ISB, a nonprofit biomedical research center known for its expertise in “big data” analysis.

One of the major unknowns about people who get reinfected is whether they are infectious enough to spread the virus to others, said Heath. “We just don’t know that yet,” he said. “I think it’s likely some people will be, but probably most people won’t.”

The local patient’s viral load was so low during his second infection that it’s unlikely he would have been infectious — but that not certain, Heath added.

It’s impossible to draw many conclusions from single case studies like this one, Goldman stressed. That’s why he and his colleague are now reaching out to researchers around the world in hopes of comparing all the data and looking for common features and clues to why some people’s immune systems falter.

He also expects to see more reinfections in the coming months, as transmission rates rise during the fall and winter and more people who recovered from earlier infections are exposed again.

“Our experience has been that once we start looking for it, we find it,” Goldman said.

At a briefing Wednesday, Washington State Health Officer Dr. Kathy Lofy said there have been about 100 people in Washington who tested positive for the virus, appeared to recover, then tested positive again more than 90 days later. It’s not clear if these are cases of reinfection or simply instances of people continuing to shed the virus or viral particles for long periods of time, she said.

The only way to confirm reinfection is to compare viral genomes, but many laboratories have thrown out the initial samples used to detect the virus. Lofy said the state is working with academic partners and the CDC to further investigate the cases when possible.

Because of the uncertainty about reinfection and what constitutes immunity and how long it lasts, public health officials urge people who have recovered from the virus to take the same precautions — including mask-wearing and social distancing — as everyone else.

Seattle Times staff reporter Evan Bush contributed to this report.

Talk to us

More in Northwest

Seattle Police Chief Carmen Best laughs during a light moment at a news conference, Tuesday, Aug. 11, 2020, in Seattle. Best, the first Black woman to lead Seattle's police department, announced she will be stepping down in September following cuts to her budget that would reduce the department by as many as 100 officers. (AP Photo/Ted S. Warren)
Seattle’s ex-police chief joins KING as law enforcement analyst

Carmen Best retired from the police department amid a controversy over proposed budget cuts.

CORRECTS NAME OF CANDIDATE AT LEFT TO MAIA ESPINOZA INSTEAD OF OF MONICA MARCHETTI - Maia Espinoza, a candidate for Washington state superintendent of public instruction, is shown at left in an undated photo taken by Monica Marchetti and provided by her campaign. Espinoza is challenging incumbent state superintendent Chris Reykdal, right, shown in an AP photo taken Oct. 2, 2020, in Olympia, Wash., in the upcoming November election. (AP Photo)
COVID and sex education frame the state superintendent race

Maia Espinoza, 31, is challenging incumbent Chris Reykdal, 48. They are both parents — with divergent views.

Washington State Climatologist Nick Bond. (University of Washington)
UW climate expert: We are moving into uncharted territory

State climatologist says the declining snowpack threatens water supplies as population grows.

Seattle Mayor Jenny Durkan, right, speaks, Monday, July 13, 2020, during a news conference at City Hall in Seattle. Durkan and Police Chief Carmen Best, looking on at left, were critical of a plan backed by several city council members that seeks to cut the police department's budget by 50 percent. (AP Photo/Ted S. Warren)
Police investigate threats, messages against Seattle mayor

Homophobic slurs and hateful messages were left outside the home of Seattle Mayor Jenny Durkan.

Seattle police depart at highest numbers in years

The 110 officers leaving marks the highest total since at least 2012.

Washington Supreme Court reverses 1960 cemetery decision

The old, already illegal rule allowed cemeteries to discriminate on the basis of race.

Health care workers and other staff walk out of Harborview Medical Center, a part of UW Medicine, during a noon hour break in a demonstration asking management to do more to protect staff, patients and the public amid the COVID-19 pandemic, Thursday, May 14, 2020, in Seattle.  (AP Photo/Elaine Thompson)
Harborview: COVID outbreak killed a patient, infected staff

Ten staffers at the Seattle hospital have tested positive for COVID-19 and are isolating.

Seattle-area man is 3rd in U.S. with 2nd confirmed COVID case

The patient, in his 60s, tested positive in early March and got sick against nearly 5 months later.

Washington unemployment rate drops to 7.8%

Most job growth occurred in leisure and hospitality, construction and other services.

Mountlake Terrace woman accused of hiring men to kill her ex

Police say there may be a financial motive behind the murder-for-hire plan involving “quite a bit of money.”

REMOVES REFERENCE TO NUMBER OF PEOPLE WHO DIED FROM COVID-19 - State Health Officer Dr. Kathy Lofy speaks to the media about the coronavirus outbreak, as Insurance Commissioner Mike Kriedler looks on, Thursday, March 5, 2020, in Olympia, Wash.  Kriedler has issued an order requiring health insurers in the state to not charge copays or deductibles for people who require testing for the coronavirus. (AP Photo/Rachel La Corte)
Washington’s top public health officer to leave position

Dr. Kathy Lofy says she plans to focus on her own health and to connect with friends and family.

Inslee: 5 Washington counties can relax virus restrictions

There has been a “leveling out” of coronavirus risk between the five counties and the rest of the state.