Seattle unanimously confirms Carmen Best at new police chief

After a bumpy selection process, she becomes the first African American woman to head the department.

Carmen Best was confirmed as the Seattle Police Chief on Aug. 13. (Seattle Police Department)

Carmen Best was confirmed as the Seattle Police Chief on Aug. 13. (Seattle Police Department)

An African American woman will head Seattle’s police force for the first time, following the Seattle City Council’s 8-0 confirmation of Interim Police Chief Carmen Best on Monday.

Best will be tasked with overseeing 1,400 officers, and ensuring that the police department sustains court-ordered reforms designed to reduce excessive force and improve its relationship with marginalized communities. The majority of city councilmembers voiced their confidence in Best’s ability to continue instituting police reforms, while Councilmember Kshama Sawant conceded that her “yes” vote was only in solidarity with her black and brown supporters.

The significance of the historic vote was not lost on members of the public, most of whom rose from their chairs when, at the start of the meeting, Councilmember Lorena Gonzalez asked people to stand if they supported Best’s confirmation.

“Take it in Chief Best,” Gonzalez said, as Best smiled and shook her head in agreement. “I think this is … a testament to the skill and to the work ethic, and to the commitment you have to every single face in this audience.”

Councilmember Teresa Mosqueda echoed praise for Best, noting that she showed vast knowledge of the police department and “roots here in the community that help create accountability.”

Court-appointed monitor Merrick Bobb, who is charged with overseeing Seattle’s police reform, also sat in the front row of the audience. His presence was noteworthy, given that U.S. District Judge James Robart ruled that the Seattle Police Department (SPD) had fully complied with a 2012 consent decree in January. Over the past six years, the police department has reformed its use of force policies, retrained its officers and worked to improve relations with citizens. Now Best will lead the department during a two-year monitoring period in which SPD must demonstrate continued compliance with reforms in order to end federal oversight.

Best became the interim chief shortly before the ruling in January, following Police Chief Kathleen O’Toole’s resignation at the end of 2017. A 26-year veteran of the SPD, Best served as deputy chief under O’Toole, where she oversaw the Community Outreach section as well as the Patrol Operations, Criminal Investigations, and Special Operations Bureaus. The Tacoma native will receive a Master’s in Criminal Justice Leadership from Northeastern University this year, according to the SPD website.

“I’m counting on all of you for your support,” Best said while facing the audience after her confirmation. “It’s great to be supported in the good times, but we’re going to have tough times ahead of us too. And during those times I look for all of us … to work together to make sure that we’re on the same page in doing what’s needed to keep the city of Seattle great, and the Seattle Police Department the wonderful and outstanding department that I know it is and that it will continue to be.”

Despite Best’s seamless confirmation, the selection process for SPD’s next leader was littered with hiccups. Her confirmation followed a circuitous route in which she was initially excluded from a list of three finalists in May, only to be nominated by Mayor Jenny Durkan less than two months later. The exclusion sparked public opposition from the community and the Seattle Police Officers Guild — Seattle’s largest police union — which is currently in contract negotiations with the city. In a stunning reversal, finalist Cameron McLay – Pittsburgh’s former chief of police— relinquished his spot as a candidate in July, forging a path for Best to join the running with Minneapolis Police Inspector Eddie Frizzell and Assistant Chief of Austin Police Department Ely Reyes. Mayor Jenny Durkan nominated Best as the next Chief of Police on July 17 after interviewing all of the candidates.

Yet the opaque process drew scrutiny from community members who wondered why Best was excluded as a candidate in the first place. On July 7, Senior Deputy Mayor Michael Fong partially explained the move to the search committee members in an email obtained by Seattle Weekly through a public records request.

“Following several conversations over the past several weeks about the importance of police reform, finalist and former Pittsburgh Police Chief Cameron S. McLay has informed Mayor Durkan that he is withdrawing from consideration for the role of Seattle Police Chief,” Fong wrote. “Chief McLay and Mayor Durkan agree that he can most effectively support our continued reform efforts outside of the Chief of Police role.” On July 6, Durkan asked the Seattle Department of Human Resources to reconvene the competitive examination needed to pick the three highest ranking candidates, the email continued. The next day, the assessors who included Fong, “recommended an additional candidate Interim Chief Carmen Best,” he wrote.

Councilmember Sawant also questioned Durkan’s selection process, calling it “a racist elimination of Carmen Best from the finalists” during Monday’s city council meeting. However, Sawant’s disapproval of the hiring process didn’t save Best from Sawant’s critcism. She chastised Best for not directly acknowledging the continued issue of racial bias and excessive use of force in SPD.

“I’m not convinced that Chief Best is prepared to carry out the kind of fundamental transformation that is needed, as I was not convinced with O’Toole, and I was certainly not convinced by any of the other finalists for the position this year,” Sawant said, explaining that her supporters asked her not to obstruct Best’s confirmation.

Although she received overwhelming support from communities of color, Best will also have to prove herself to leaders who fear that Best will maintain the status quo. KL Shannon, Police Accountability Chair for the Seattle/King County NAACP, wrote in a July 20 email to Seattle Weekly that she does not believe Best will drastically change SPD’s disproportionate policing of communities of color.

“Chief Best’s bread and butter is the Seattle Police Department … she is going to have to figure out how to balance the community, Durkan’s office, and SPD,” Shannon wrote. “It’s never going to happen. No matter how good her intentions will be.”

mhellmann@seatttleweekly.com

Talk to us

> Give us your news tips.

> Send us a letter to the editor.

> More Herald contact information.

More in Northwest

Alaska Airlines aircraft sit in the airline's hangar at Seattle-Tacoma International Airport Wednesday, Jan. 10, 2024, in SeaTac, Wash. Boeing has acknowledged in a letter to Congress that it cannot find records for work done on a door panel that blew out on an Alaska Airlines flight over Oregon two months ago. Ziad Ojakli, Boeing executive vice president and chief government lobbyist, wrote to Sen. Maria Cantwell on Friday, March 8 saying, “We have looked extensively and have not found any such documentation.” (AP Photo/Lindsey Wasson)
FBI tells passengers on 737 flight they might be crime victims

Passengers received letters this week from a victim specialist from the federal agency’s Seattle office.

Skylar Meade (left) and Nicholas Umphenour.
Idaho prison gang member and accomplice caught after ambush

Pair may have killed 2 while on the run, police say. Three police officers were hospitalized with gunshot wounds after the attack at a Boise hospital.

Barbara Peraza-Garcia holds her 2-year-old daughter, Frailys, while her partner Franklin Peraza sits on their bed in their 'micro apartment' in Seattle on Monday, March 11, 2024. (AP Photo/Manuel Valdes)
Micro-apartments are back after nearly a century, as need for affordable housing soars

Boarding houses that rented single rooms to low-income, blue-collar or temporary workers were prevalent across the U.S. in the early 1900s.

Teen blamed for crash that kills woman, 3 children in Renton

Four people were hospitalized, including three with life-threatening injuries. The teenage driver said to be at fault is under guard at a hospital.

Whidbey cop accused of rape quits job after internal inquiry

The report was unsparing in its allegations against John Nieder, who is set to go to trial May 6 in Skagit County Superior Court on two counts of rape in the second degree.

LA man was child rape suspect who faked his death

Coroner’s probe reveals the Los Angeles maintenance man was a Bremerton rape suspect believed to have jumped off the Tacoma Narrows Bridge.

Logo for news use, for stories regarding Washington state government — Olympia, the Legislature and state agencies. No caption necessary. 20220331
Edmonds rep’s bill would try to stop police from lying in interrogations

Rep. Strom Peterson’s measure aims to make statements inadmissible if police use deceptive tactics to get those statements.

The exterior doors of Boeing's 737 assembly factory are shown closed Wednesday, March 27, 2019, in Renton, Wash. (AP Photo/Ted S. Warren)
Boeing mechanics in Renton mis-installed piece that blew off plane, whistleblower says

A source says the fuselage panel that blew off an Alaska Airlines jet earlier this month was reinstalled improperly at the Boeing facility in Renton.

Yvonne Gallardo-Van Ornam, left, and Clyde Shaver
Arlington council member to run for state rep against Shavers

Yvonne Gallardo-Van Ornam called it a “little embarrassing” to have Oak Harbor Rep. Clyde Shavers “representing veterans.”

Sen. Marko Liias, D-Edmonds, chair of the Senate Transportation Committee, at right, looks over at Sen. Curtis King, R-Yakima, ranking minority member of Senate Transportation Committee, at left, after participating in a panel during a legislative session preview in the Cherberg Building at the Capitol, Thursday, Jan. 4, 2024 in Olympia, Wash. (AP Photo/Lindsey Wasson)
Edmonds senator wants LGBTQ+ history taught in public schools

Sen. Marko Liias, D-Edmonds, is the bill’s prime sponsor and one of the Legislature’s LGBTQ+ members.

Logo for news use featuring Whidbey Island in Island County, Washington. 220118
Island County pays $2.75M to former Navy chief shot after standoff

A lawsuit alleged the Island County Sheriff’s Office was responsible for “state-created danger.”

West Beach Road was closed and residents were evacuated during the wind storm Tuesday. (John Fisken / Whidbey News Times)
Whidbey homes damaged, road closed, ferry rocked in wild wind storm

A wind storm toppled a tree onto a house, canceled ferry trips and prompted evacuations Tuesday.

Support local journalism

If you value local news, make a gift now to support the trusted journalism you get in The Daily Herald. Donations processed in this system are not tax deductible.