Washington justices void 1916 tribal rights ruling as racist

The case concerned Alec Towessnute, a Yakama Nation member arrested after using a gaff hook.

By Gene Johnson / Associated Press

SEATTLE — Washington state’s Supreme Court on Friday vacated a 1916 ruling that allowed a prosecutor to bring criminal charges against a tribal fisherman as racist and unjust.

The justices unanimously said they were compelled to void the decision because “such past opinions can continue to perpetrate injustice by their very existence.” Justice Raquel Montoya-Lewis, the state’s first Native American justice, read the decision from the bench in Olympia.

The 1916 case concerned Alec Towessnute, a Yakama Nation member arrested after using a gaff hook, a traditional tribal fishing method, near Prosser, about 5 miles outside the reservation.

Even though the Yakamas’ 1855 treaty with the United States allowed the tribe to fish in its traditional grounds, including the area where he was fishing, Towessnute was charged with multiple fishing crimes.

Like many tribal members prosecuted for fishing off reservations, Towessnute cited the treaty rights, and a Benton County Superior Court judge agreed, dismissing the charges. But the state Supreme Court reinstated them in a decision that disparaged tribes and belittled tribal sovereignty, describing Native Americans as “a dangerous child” who squandered “vast areas of fertile land before our eyes.”

“We take this opportunity to repudiate this case, its language, its conclusions, and its mischaracterization of the Yakama people,” the justices wrote in Friday’s order. “We cannot forget our own history, and we cannot change it. We can, however, forge a new path forward, committing to justice as we do so.”

Lawmakers six years ago passed a law allowing the vacation of pre-1975 tribal fishing convictions upon petition. One Yakama Nation member, Johnson Meninick, spent years trying to have the convictions of his family members — including Towessnute — overturned.

However, the state Supreme Court in 2015 declined to vacate Towessnute’s case because incomplete court records made it unclear that he was actually convicted after the charges were reinstated.

After Meninick died in April, attorney Jack Fiander, a Yakama tribal member who has worked on many cases involving tribal fishing rights, asked the high court to reconsider the case. The court agreed, and its decision Friday cited an open letter the justices issued last month calling on the legal community to help eradicate the racism that has pervaded the justice system.

“For many years, tribal members’ relationship with the state of Washington was being arrested for fishing violations, having children removed from home and being profiled for traffic stops,” Fiander said. “This ruling begins to restore tribal people’s faith in the court systems.”

Washington Attorney General Bob Ferguson noted that his office had argued against Towessnute in 1916 and said he embraced the effort to make amends. His office called the 1916 ruling “one of Washington’s most culturally insensitive court decisions regarding treaty rights.”

Talk to us

More in Northwest

Auburn police officer Jeffrey Nelson. (Auburn Reporter, file)
Auburn cop’s story conflicts with witness account of killing

Police officer Jeffrey Nelson has been charged with murder in the killing of Jesse Sarey.

State Sens. Joe Nguyen, D-White Center, lower left, Emily Randall, D-Bremerton, upper left, Andy Billig, D-Spokane, upper right, and Jamie Pedersen, D-Seattle, lower right, confer on the floor of the Senate, Wednesday, Jan. 26, 2022, at the Capitol in Olympia, Wash., during debate on a measure that would delay implementation of a long-term care program and the payroll tax that pays for it. The Senate passed the measure, which was passed by the House last week, and Gov. Jay Inslee is expected to sign the measure on Friday. (AP Photo/Ted S. Warren)
Legislature OKs pause to long-term care program and tax

Lawmakers want to address solvency concerns and other issues in the WA Cares fund.

Sen. Ron Muzzall, R-Oak Harbor, left, speaks on the floor of the Senate, Wednesday, Jan. 26, 2022, at the Capitol in Olympia, Wash., during debate on a measure that would delay implementation of a long-term care program and the payroll tax that pays for it. The Senate passed the measure, which was passed by the House last week, and Gov. Jay Inslee is expected to sign the measure on Friday. (AP Photo/Ted S. Warren)
Delay of Washington’s long-term-care program signed into law

The bill addresses concerns about the program’s solvency and criticism about elements of the underlying law.

FILE - In this Dec. 17, 2019, file photo, Amazon packages move along a conveyor at an Amazon warehouse facility in Goodyear, Ariz. Amazon’s pandemic boom isn’t showing signs of slowing down. The company said Thursday, April 29, 2021, that its first-quarter profit more than tripled from a year ago, fueled by the growth of online shopping. It also posted revenue of more than $100 billion, the second quarter in row that the company has passed that milestone. (AP Photo/Ross D. Franklin, File)
‘Sold by Amazon’ program ends following state investigation

Washington’s attorney general found the program was anticompetitive and violated antitrust laws.

This photo shows a sign at the headquarters for Washington state's Employment Security Department Tuesday, May 26, 2020, at the Capitol in Olympia, Wash. Washington state's rush to get unemployment benefits to residents who lost jobs due to the coronavirus outbreak left it vulnerable to criminals who made off with hundreds of millions of dollars in fraudulent claims. (AP Photo/Ted S. Warren)
Washington’s paid family leave program running short on cash

The program began in 2020, and in the first six weeks more than triple the amount of people expected applied.

During a June 2021 bust, Kent Police recovered nearly 800 catalytic converters, seized about $40,000 in cash and arrested multiple suspects after a lengthy investigation into numerous thefts. COURTESY PHOTO, Kent Police
Lawmakers urged to curb demand for stolen catalytic converters

Potential changes to Senate Bill 5495 could include recordkeeping, inspections and penalties for recyclers.

Logo for news use featuring Snohomish County, Washington. 220118
State high court to hear case about transit fare enforcement

The state Supreme Court will consider whether it constitutes an invasion of privacy.

University of Washington will begin in-person classes at the end of January. (Sue Misao / Herald file)
University of Washington to return to in-person learning

The school requires all students and staff to wear masks indoors and be vaccinated.

FILE - Bob Spalding, left, and Don Wilson of The Ventures perform at the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame Induction Ceremony in New York, March 10, 2008. Don Wilson, co-founder and rhythm guitarist of the instrumental guitar band The Ventures, has died. He was 88. The News Tribune reports Wilson died Saturday, Jan. 22, 2022 in Tacoma of natural causes, surrounded by his four children. (AP Photo/Jason DeCrow)
Don Wilson, guitarist with The Ventures, dies at 88

The band’s hits included “Walk, Don’t Run” and the theme song for “Hawaii Five-O.”

Most Read