Beyond marijuana: Legalize all drugs

Thirty years ago, a college kid in Kentucky was caught growing marijuana plants in his closet. That turned him into a convicted felon, and though he’s been on the right side of the law ever since, he still can’t vote. On any job application, he must check the box next to “Have you ever been convicted of a felony?”

All this misery for growing a plant whose leaves the past three presidents admit having smoked.

We know this story because Sen. Rand Paul of Kentucky keeps telling it. That a Southern Republican probably running for president is condemning such prosecutions as unfair speaks volumes on the collapsing support for the war on marijuana — part of the larger war on drugs.

Two states, Colorado and Washington, have already legalized recreational pot. And the Colorado Supreme Court has been considering a question no one would have dreamed of asking two decades ago: whether an employer may fire a worker for smoking pot.

So what do we do about the rest of the war — the war on heroin, cocaine, methamphetamine and the other nastier stuff? The answer is legalize them, too.

“What is the benefit, what have we derived from this drug war that even begins to offset the horrors we inflict on ourselves via this policy?” asks Dean Becker, a legalization advocate. He is editor of “To End the War on Drugs,” a collection of politically diverse views published by Rice University’s Baker Institute for Public Policy.

Over the past 40 years, the war has put more than 45 million Americans under arrest and cost taxpayers $1 trillion. And what do we have to show for it? Drugs on the street are cheaper, more powerful and more abundant than ever.

The war has fueled gang wars in our cities and enriched the criminal foreign cartels. It has created a vile class system, turning millions of poor and working-class Americans into felons while largely turning a blind eye toward users of the same drugs in suburban cul-de-sacs.

And again, it’s all been for naught. This summer, counties circling Houston, where Becker lives, have seen eight busts of major marijuana growing operations. Law enforcement just stumbled across them.

“There are some indications they were run by Mexicans sent by the cartels,” Becker, formerly a member of the U.S. Air Force security police, told me.

And what does the arrest of a drug trafficker do? It creates more business for the other drug traffickers.

As the conservative economist Milton Friedman once put it, “if you look at the drug war from a purely economic point of view, the role of the government is to protect the drug cartel.”

Wouldn’t legalizing all drugs set off a new explosion of drug use? Good question. Undoubtedly, some would try drugs for the first time. But regulating the sale could limit the problems. Portugal decriminalized drugs in 2000 and saw little rise in use.

Becker is not a big fan of small steps in easing the drug laws, though he thinks that’s better than nothing. He wants full legalization.

Just decriminalizing drugs — that is, not arresting people possessing them but keeping their sale illegal — does not take criminals out of the business. And it stands in the way of regulating the drug-making now done by untrained chemists in primitive labs. Furthermore, illegal businesses don’t get taxed.

Prohibition of the 1920s was “decrim.” Alcoholic beverages couldn’t be legally sold, but one could drink them at home. A lot of good that did.

Make drugs legal; regulate them; and tax them. The final destination for the war on drugs should be oblivion, the sooner the better.

Froma Harrop is a Providence Journal columnist. She can be reached at fharrop@gmail.com.

Talk to us

More in Opinion

CMYK version
Editorial cartoons for Sunday, July 25

A sketchy look at the news of the day.… Continue reading

Election thing
Editorial: Schwab, Zarlingo for new Everett council positions

In a field of strong candidates, both have experience to help a newly formed council begin its work.

Election thing
Editorial: Frizzell best choice for mayor of growing Lynnwood

Of three closely matched candidates, Frizzell is the best choice to succeed the current mayor.

Toons

A sketchy look at the news of the day.… Continue reading

Toons
Editorial cartoons for Friday, July 23

A sketchy look at the news of the day.… Continue reading

Cydney Gillis
Cydney Gillis: Land mine tripped in covid’s office battlefield

An office policy that allowed those vaccinated to remove masks intensified the pandemic’s politics.

Ken White: Analogies are useful tools but they can be misused

Comparing mask mandates and vaccine rules to the oppression of the Holocaust is pure propaganda.

The ignorance and lies that live Nextdoor

Fake news about the author turns up on the hyperlocal social media platform.

Comment: Homelessness was on decline, until we changed course

Housing First was reducing homelessness until the Trump years. We need to resume those programs.

FILE - In this April 11, 2011 photo, Grover is posed on the set of "Sesame Street," in New York. The popular children's TV series is celebrating their 50th season. (AP Photo/Richard Drew, File)
Viewpoints: Selling Sesame kept a ‘public good’ on the air

As public funding was cut over the years, Sesame Streets creators turned to corporate deals.

tooon
Editorial cartoons for Thursday, July 22

A sketchy look at the news of the day.… Continue reading

Election thing
Editorial: Eck and Coehlo, Decker, Binda best on Lynnwood ballot

A growing and vibrant community can add to the city council’s experience, knowledge and diversity.