Book is gone with the judge

  • Ellen Goodman / Boston Globe columnist
  • Monday, May 7, 2001 9:00pm
  • Opinion

BOSTON — I’ve just finished a book that you can’t read.

I’m not bragging about my literary prowess. The book wasn’t "Finnegan’s Wake" in the original Joyce or "The Odyssey" in ancient Greek. The problem isn’t a language barrier but a legal barrier.

A judge in Atlanta has stopped publication of Alice Randall’s "The Wind Done Gone" on the grounds that it violates the copyright of the book that it mocks: "Gone With the Wind." Her new novel can’t be sold in bookstores, it can’t be sold on eBay, indeed, the publisher has actually been asked to round up advance reading copies like the one in my hands.

But I intend to send my copy to Judge Charles Pannell. I can’t imagine that anyone could read this fictional memoir of Scarlett O’Hara’s mulatto half-sister Cynara and believe that it "merely summarizes most of the earlier work without commentary or fresh ideas that challenge the reader’s understanding of the earlier work." I can’t imagine anyone would read it and believe that the author wrote a sequel rather than a parody.

Ashley is gay and Melanie is a serial killer and Belle is running a whorehouse filled with lesbians and this is not a parody? It may not be a comedy, but Randall has written a story turning the world of Tara into Tata, creating and re-creating leading roles for former slaves.

Nevertheless, the judge ruled that only Margaret Mitchell’s heirs had the right to what he called — listen closely — her "beloved characters and their romantic, but tragic, world."

Whose beloved characters? Whose tragic world? "Gone With the Wind" rewrote antebellum and Reconstruction history into a myth of epic and classic proportions. Mitchell’s South was a place of happy slaves and white plantation owners struggling nobly to maintain their way of life.

It was so powerful a story that novelist Pat Conroy, whose mother modeled her life on Scarlett, says: "GWTW suffused the world of my childhood like no other book with the possible exception of the Bible."

This Confederate flag of a story was so compelling on stage and screen that even African Americans could be as shamefully seduced by it as Jews could be in watching "The Merchant of Venice." Indeed, Randall herself admits, "When I was 12 I read ‘Gone With the Wind’ and fell in love with the novel."

But it was, she adds, "a troubled love from the beginning. I had to overlook racist stereotyping and Klan whitewashing to appreciate the ambitious, resilient, hard-working, hard-loving character who is Scarlett." And at some point, Randall, a song and screenwriter whose father had told her "to speak for those who cannot speak for themselves" began to imagine a half-sister, and her life and her version of history.

It’s surprising that no revisionist "Gone With the Wind" was tried before. But maybe others were warned off by the Mitchells’ litigious nephews, who not only regard "Tara" as their own plantation and cash cow, but protect the myth as property.

When Conroy himself was once asked by the Mitchell estate to write an official sequel, he says he was told of two conditions: no miscegenation and no homosexuality. He rejected signing any pledge and wrote back in high dudgeon with this first line to ‘his’ sequel: "After Rhett Butler made love to Ashley Wilkes, he lit a cigarette and said, ‘Ashley did I ever tell you my grandmother was black?’ "

Now, maybe if Randall’s humor had been that broad, the judge would have gotten it. But in fact her novel is less a farce than a political correction. Using Cynara — Mammy’s daughter as well as Scarlett’s half-sister — Randall mines the complex love triangle between a black caregiver, the girl she gave birth to and the girl she raised. Her South is not black and white but gray in every sense of the word.

This book you cannot read is fictional commentary, at times clever, at times obvious, at times arresting, at times flat, but always pointed like a cannon at the original. The 25,000 copies slated for print might have circulated from one anti-antebellum hand to another or been used as a deconstruction tip sheet in literary classrooms.

But Mitchell heirs have declared that the fantasy behind "Gone With the Wind" is their protectorate and anything that mocks "the romantic but tragic world" devalues it. So, on May 25, the case goes to the 11th Circuit Court of Appeals. If the right to make a mockery isn’t protected there, then neither is any critical essay or political satire.

In a perverse acknowledgement, Randall writes, "Margaret Mitchell’s novel inspired me to think." Now Mitchell’s heirs are making us think. I hope they don’t take this as a compliment.

Ellen Goodman can be reached at The Washington Post Writers Group, 1150 15th St. NW, Washington, DC 20071-9200 or send e-mail to

Talk to us

> Give us your news tips.

> Send us a letter to the editor.

> More Herald contact information.

More in Opinion

Editorial cartoons for Thursday, June 13

A sketchy look at the news of the day.… Continue reading

The City of Everett is set to purchase two single sidewalk restrooms from Romtec, a company based in Roseburg, Ore., for $315,000. (Romtec)
Editorial: Utilitarian but sturdy restrooms should be a relief

Everett is placing four stalls downtown that should be accessible but less prone to problems.

Stephens: Only way that Biden can win is not to run

The president can only commit to managing threats; his best chance for victory is to leave the ticket.

Krugman: The wealthy’s support of Trump isn’t just about money

They’re also not crazy about those who — like Biden — don’t pay sufficient deference to them.

Bouie: Should wealthy and powerful again put trust in Trump

They stepped away after Jan. 6, but — ignoring their own need for democratic norms — are drawn to autocracy.

Everett principal Betty Cobbs served kids, community for 51 years

Education and community. Those words are the best America has to offer;… Continue reading

Artist Natalie Niblack works amongst her project entitled “33 Birds / Three Degrees” during the setup for Exploring The Edge at Schack Art Center on Sunday, March 19, 2023, in Everett, Washington. The paintings feature motion-activated speakers that play each bird’s unique call. (Ryan Berry / The Herald)
Editorial: For 50 years Schack Art Center there for creation

The art center is more art studio than museum, supporting artists and fostering creativity in kids.

Snohomish School District’s Clayton Lovell plugs in the district’s electric bus after morning routes on Thursday, March 6, 2024, at the district bus depot in Snohomish, Washington. (Ryan Berry / The Herald)
Editorial: Money well spent on switch to electric school buses

With grants awarded to local school districts, a study puts a dollar figure on health, climate savings.

Mangrove trees roots, Rhizophora mangle, above and below the water in the Caribbean sea, Panama, Central America
Editorial: Support local newspapers work to hometowns’ benefit

A writer compares them to mangrove trees, filtering toxins and providing support to their neighbors.

Tufekci: Covid a lesson for officials on fragility of trust

In seeking to manage the message, scientists and officials took risks that have cost the public’s trust.

Collins: Republicans’ zeal against Biden’s son a double-standard

While they’re attacking Hunter Biden’s gun possession, they’re working to relax similar gun measures.

Editorial cartoons for Wednesday, June 12

A sketchy look at the news of the day.… Continue reading

Support local journalism

If you value local news, make a gift now to support the trusted journalism you get in The Daily Herald. Donations processed in this system are not tax deductible.