Civil War was more about states’ rights

I must take exception to Hans Dunshee’s mischaracterization of the Civil War as being a about slavery (“Jefferson Davis Highway here? Legislator outraged,” Jan. 24 news story).

It was a war about states’ rights vs. federal rights. Slavery was the issue that President Lincoln used as justification to persuade the governors of the northern states to lend him troops and to sway public opinion to his cause. There was no standing army at this time, as George Washington was fearful of the oppressive power that a federal government would have if it were allowed to have a standing army and it was one of the powers that was specifically forbidden to it. The governors of the states had the armies. Given the amendments that were passed after the war (including giving itself the right to tax the income of citizens), there are some who feel that the wrong side won. We certainly would not have the all-powerful federal government and bureaucracy dictating so many aspects of our lives that we have today had Jefferson Davis and those who favor states’ rights prevailed.

Stanwood

Talk to us

> Give us your news tips.

> Send us a letter to the editor.

> More Herald contact information.

More in Opinion

toon
Editorial cartoons for Wednesday, Jan. 21

A sketchy look at the news of the day.… Continue reading

Pierce County Sheriff Keith Swank testifies before the Washington state Senate Law and Justice Committee in Olympia on Thursday, Jan. 15, 2026. (Screenshot courtesy of TVW)
Editorial: Find path to assure fitness of sheriff candidates

An outburst at a hearing against a bill distracted from issues of accountability and voters’ rights.

Welch: State of the state reflects continuing challenges

The governor was optimistic, but affordability, housing and flooding response remain unresolved.

Vote for students and the future with Lake Stevens school levy

Two years ago, I chose to move to Lake Stevens because of… Continue reading

Students deserve quality education, support Everett schools levy, bond

With school bonds and levies on the ballot, it’s a timely reminder… Continue reading

Everett High students’ protest offers lesson in democracy

Three cheers and a tiger to the students at Everett High School.… Continue reading

Practice radical love in MLK Jr.’s honor

Martin Luther King Jr. was a Christian minister with a message that… Continue reading

toon
Editorial cartoons for Tuesday, Jan. 20

A sketchy look at the news of the day.… Continue reading

Dowd: Nobels and nations; if Trump wants it, he’ll try to take it

Trump says his power is limited only by ‘my own morality.’ So, too, is his desire for possession.

Support schools bonds, levies for strong students, communities

Strong schools are essential to Everett’s success so I’m hoping you will… Continue reading

Schwab’s perspective on police panel valuable

Herald Columnist Sid Schwab’s service on the Everett Police Chief’s Advisory Board… Continue reading

Comment: Issue of transgender girls in sports best left to states

The apparent take of Justice Kavanaugh might be the best way to ensure dignity to all student athletes.

Support local journalism

If you value local news, make a gift now to support the trusted journalism you get in The Daily Herald. Donations processed in this system are not tax deductible.