Comment on wealth taxes more failed ‘bootstrap’ economics

The recent column by Washington Post columnist Megan McArdle is a great example of the “common-sense” misdirection on wealth taxes popular in neoliberal circles. She (sarcastically?) implies that these taxes will literally take billionaire’s yachts and homes and giving them to the poor. Her solution? “Aggressively taxing consumption.”

Unfortunately, as she correctly points out, ultra-wealthy people consume very little as a proportion of their total wealth. There are only so many yachts one needs, after all. Poor people, on the other hand, spend a much higher amount on goods and services, and sales/value-added taxes don’t fluctuate depending on the purchaser’s total wealth. They are flat, and therefore regressive. They hit poor people harder.

This privileged take isn’t surprising, as conservatives like McArdle have consistently trumpeted a “bootstrap” American mythology which simply doesn’t exist anymore. As the World Economic Forum rightly pointed out, the American Dream is alive and well; in Denmark.

Most wealth taxes that I’ve seen proposed will affect a very small percentage of this newspaper’s readership. Biden’s income tax hikes would affect those who make more than $400,000, for example, while Elizabeth Warren’s wealth tax would only hit those with more than $50 million in assets. This somehow strikes people as “unfair,” neglecting to understand the deep subsidies the government has provided to allow the gain of that wealth in the first place.

It’s time to reject the hazy logic of trickle-down economics and bootstrap economics, which have allowed billionaires and corporations to effectively capture our economy and government. Don’t allow McArdle’s poorly argued talking points distract you from the core of real American values: egalitarianism and social mobility.

Johnny Miller


Talk to us

More in Opinion

Editorial cartoons for Thursday, Aug. 18

A sketchy look at the news of the day.… Continue reading

FILE - In this Jan. 6, 2021, file photo, violent insurrectionists loyal to President Donald Trump scale the west wall of the the U.S. Capitol in Washington. Two Seattle police officers who were in Washington, D.C., during the January 6 insurrection were illegally trespassing on Capitol grounds while rioters stormed the building, but lied about their actions, a police watchdog said in a report released Thursday, July 8, 2021. (AP Photo/Jose Luis Magana, File)
Editorial: Electoral Count Act needs bipartisan reforms now

Changes to the 135-year-old law may prevent future attempts to overturn elections.

If voting for Republicans, choose wisely

I happen to be a fan of The Daily Herald and value… Continue reading

State constitution applies too regarding firearms

Don’t ignore the Washington state constitution. I suggest that the author of… Continue reading

Abortion laws being written with little knowledge

It is beyond comprehension how abortion rights opponents feel they can interfere… Continue reading

Comment: Dignity is Cheney’s reward for unflinching defiance

Cheney knew her opposition of Trump would cost her her return to Congress. She stuck to her values.

Comment: Poor funding isn’t only reason for an antiquated IRS

Yes, the agency has been starved for support, but it still should have been able to make some moves to modernize.

Comment: Facebook’s openness on its chatbot gets it right

While other tech giants are secretive about their AI work, Meta has been transparent and inviting.

Editorial cartoons for Wednesday, Aug. 17

A sketchy look at the news of the day.… Continue reading

Most Read