Comment: Rescue plan still doing its work to boost economy

While enhanced jobless benefits have ended, state and local governments are just now spending their aid.

By Conor Sen / Bloomberg Opinion

As Democrats struggled to find agreement on a pair of infrastructure bills, some have been concerned that the waning impact of fiscal stimulus will act as a drag on economic growth just when the economy is struggling with supply-chain problems. But that thinking is too simplistic; while some pandemic relief programs are winding down, there’s still plenty of fuel in the system to keep this recovery moving ahead.

The American Rescue Plan passed in March was a massive $1.9 trillion, and while much of that has been disbursed or set to expire — such as the enhanced unemployment benefits last month — a large chunk of it has yet to be spent. State and local governments are still figuring out what to do with the $350 billion they were allocated. Child tax credit checks that started going out this summer will continue through the end of the year. Of the hundreds of billions of dollars sent out in the form of $1,400 relief checks, it’s unclear how much was spent versus saved. Household cash balances remain well above pre-pandemic levels thanks to multiple rounds of fiscal stimulus and a lack of spending on services like dining and travel, for instance.

Beyond Rescue Plan money, state and local government tax coffers are swelling from surging home values and sales tax revenue, a much different dynamic than we saw in the years following the 2008 financial crisis when plunging home values depressed local taxes. Tax receipts are up by 11 percent between the first quarter of 2020 and the second quarter of 2021, a surge that has continued into the third quarter.

The biggest challenge has been what to do with all that money. It’s going to come in handy now because of the urgent need to hire in a competitive labor market. Employment in state and local governments is down by 800,000 jobs from pre-pandemic levels, and openings, which were already at a record heading into the pandemic, have increased by an additional 36 percent. While evidence is still largely anecdotal, the passing of Labor Day and the beginning of the school year has seemed to make governments more aggressive in recruiting workers. My local school district, for instance, emailed all parents this week saying they need to hire school custodians and are offering signing bonuses of up to $2,000 for workers who come onboard before Nov. 1.

Something convenient about the types of jobs that need to be filled — school bus drivers, custodians, sanitation workers, teachers aides — is that they’re labor-intensive service jobs that don’t rely on supply-chain-dependent goods like semiconductors from Taiwan. Auto manufacturers and retailers might not be hiring while they can’t get the raw materials they need, but there should be no such constraint for local governments, assuming they’re willing to pay higher labor market rates.

This all looks a lot different from when fiscal stimulus was waning at the end of the 2008 financial crisis. Back then households needed to go through years of deleveraging following the borrowing binge during the housing bubble years. At the same time, state and local governments made deep budget cuts as they wrestled with their own deficits. With both households and local governments trying to balance their budgets, the early 2010’s on Main Street felt more like recessionary malaise than a real recovery.

Today, both households and state and local governments are flush with cash. All that money is going to get spent one way or another, and with a need to staff up after so many lost their jobs during the pandemic, a lot of it will go out to workers; signing bonuses today rather than job cuts in 2010. At the same time, households are flush with cash and in a position to spend down excess savings accumulated over the past 18 months.

The federal government may have done the heavy lifting to keep the economy afloat during the worst of the pandemic, but state and local governments and households are well-positioned to take things from here.

Conor Sen is a Bloomberg Opinion columnist and the founder of Peachtree Creek Investments. He’s been a contributor to the Atlantic and Business Insider and resides in Atlanta.

Talk to us

More in Opinion

Editorial cartoons for Tuesday, Oct. 4

A sketchy look at the news of the day.… Continue reading

Looking north, an aerial view of Paine Field in Everett. (Paine Field / Snohomish County) 20220605
Editorial: Right call made to keep Paine on light rail route

The industrial center’s 40,000 jobs is reason enough to protect a route serving southwest Everett.

Marysville voters should live with consequences of cuts

I share the concerns in a recent letter regarding our County Council… Continue reading

10th LD, House Pos. 1: Shavers supports abortion access

On June 24, the Supreme Court overturned Roe v. Wade. This decision… Continue reading

Snohomish housing tax break vote should have been 7-0

I attended the Sept. 20 Snohomish City Council meeting. The council was… Continue reading

Comment: DeSantis’ free-lunch conservativism may be over

The Florida governor is happy to criticize federal aid while raking it in. But how long can that last?

Comment: Here’s how to keep abortion debate out of weeds

Rather than debate heartbeats and what-ifs, can we keep the discussion to one of body autonomy?

Smiley should have answered editorial board’s questions

With elections coming it’s sometimes hard to find information about the current… Continue reading

Editorial cartoons for Monday, Oct. 3

A sketchy look at the news of the day.… Continue reading

Most Read