Comment: We presume innocence of defendants; not for lawyers

Why are former defense attorneys seeking higher office accused of protecting the guilty?

By Patrick Murphy / Chicago Tribune

I have had a very satisfying 57-year legal career; with a few more to come, I hope. I was a prosecutor who sent a number of murderers to the penitentiary, I served an East African country as a Peace Corps volunteer, and I tried cases on behalf of poor people as a legal aid lawyer in Chicago, where I later served for many years as the Cook County public guardian. At the age of 32, I argued and prevailed in a landmark case before the U.S. Supreme Court. For the past 17 years, I’ve been a judge.

But based on positions taken recently by both major political parties, I guess I am forced to apologize for being a criminal defense attorney. During those years, I successfully represented at least seven people charged with murder.

Recently, Republicans attempted to eviscerate the reputation of U.S. Supreme Court nominee Ketanji Brown Jackson by pointing out that she had the temerity to represent people charged with crimes. The other day, I watched a commercial on television in which the other party attacks a candidate running for office in Illinois because he also represented people whom the state had charged with various criminal offenses.

But wait a second.

Our justice system is built on the bedrock presumption that anyone charged with a criminal offense is innocent and that the prosecution must prove that person’s guilt beyond a reasonable doubt. Our justice system can be successful only if qualified lawyers fight for their clients and insist that the prosecution prove its case.

Further, the attack on Jackson and the candidate running for office presupposes that everyone they represented was, in fact, guilty. Indeed, in some cases, the prosecution has unintentionally charged the wrong person. In others, the person may be overcharged, so the lawyer may work to get the client a more realistic penalty based on the facts. At times, there may be extenuating circumstances, self-defense, manslaughter rather than intentional murder, and insanity. Our system works best when competent defense counsel works to bring out these facts and defenses.

In some nations, of course, a person is presumed guilty if charged by the government. Defending that person is a facade. Indeed, if defense counsel is too aggressive he or she will end up in the gulag. And I for one would not want to live in such a place. Further, I suspect that no one attacking Jackson and the candidate would consider living in such a place.

Some of our most famous and patriotic politicians have acted in the highest traditions of our legal system and represented those charged with criminal offenses. John Adams, our second president and one of our nation’s Founders, famously — and successfully — represented British soldiers charged in the Boston Massacre.

Illinois’ most famous politician and citizen was also one of its most successful and sought-after criminal defense lawyers: Abraham Lincoln.

The history of anyone seeking a higher office should be scrutinized, of course. But criticizing a lawyer for representing a person charged with a crime is an obvious cheap shot.

How the attorney represented that defendant may be a proper consideration; but not the representation itself.

Patrick Murphy is a Cook County Circuit Court judge. He is also a onetime Cook County public guardian and worked with the Cook County state’s attorney’s office.

Talk to us

> Give us your news tips.

> Send us a letter to the editor.

> More Herald contact information.

More in Opinion

toon
Editorial cartoons for Saturday, Feb. 8

A sketechy look at the news of the day.… Continue reading

bar graph, pie chart and diagrams isolated on white, 3d illustration
Editorial: Don’t let state’s budget numbers intimidate you

With budget discussions starting soon, a new website explains the basics of state’s budget crisis.

Comment: Democracy depends on support of local journalism

A state bill provides funding to support local news outlets through a modest tax on tech businesses.

Comment: Love is intoxicating; romance doesn’t have to be

Navigating sobriety while dating, with Valentine’s Day coming up, is possible and fulfilling.

Comment: State attempt at single-payer health care bound to fail

Other states have tried, but balked when confronted with the immense cost to state taxpayers.

Forum: Requiem for a lost heavyweight: Sports Illustrated

SI, with Time and NatGeo, were a holy trinity for me and my dad. Now, it’s a world of AI clickbait.

Forum: Political leaders should leave trash talk to ballplayers

Verbal intimidation is one thing on the basketball court; it shouldn’t have a place in our politics.

The Buzz: Why, no, we have complete trust in Elon Musk

But whatever he and Trump are doing to the country, could they please wish it into the cornfield?

Curtains act as doors for a handful of classrooms at Glenwood Elementary on Monday, Sept. 9, 2024 in Lake Stevens, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Editorial: Schools’ building needs point to election reform

Construction funding requests in Arlington and Lake Stevens show need for a change to bond elections.

FILE- In this Nov. 14, 2017, file photo Jaìme Ceja operates a forklift while loading boxes of Red Delicious apples on to a trailer during his shift in an orchard in Tieton, Wash. Cherry and apple growers in Washington state are worried their exports to China will be hurt by a trade war that escalated on Monday when that country raised import duties on a $3 billion list of products. (Shawn Gust/Yakima Herald-Republic via AP, File)
Editorial: Trade war would harm state’s consumers, jobs

Trump’s threat of tariffs to win non-trade concessions complicates talks, says a state trade advocate.

A press operator grabs a Herald newspaper to check over as the papers roll off the press in March 2022 in Everett. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald file photo)
Editorial: Push back news desert with journalism support

A bill in the state Senate would tax big tech to support a hiring fund for local news outlets.

toon
Editorial cartoons for Friday, Feb. 7

A sketchy look at the news of the day.… Continue reading

Support local journalism

If you value local news, make a gift now to support the trusted journalism you get in The Daily Herald. Donations processed in this system are not tax deductible.