Commentary: Flocking back to the office may not be right move

It may be healthier — and cheaper — for those who can work from home to continue to do so.

By Sarah Green Carmichael / Bloomberg Opinion

The more I read and hear about what offices will be like as they reopen, the more dystopian it sounds: empty desks, no meetings, everyone keeping their distance from one another. I miss the thrum and hum of the workplace, but the need to maintain social distancing means reopening won’t bring that back.

And for all that offices will be quieter and emptier, they may not be much safer. Erin Bromage, a biology professor at UMass Dartmouth, compiled a useful list of several known Covid-19 super-spreading events that highlights the danger of being cooped up inside with a sick person. If a 90-minute restaurant meal, 120-minute choir practice or 180-minute birthday party is enough for one person to infect a roomful, how much more risk is in a 540-minute workday, even with precautions?

Rather than bring employees back anytime soon, organizations should settle into remote work for the long haul; as some are beginning to do. Google and Facebook have gone this route, telling employees to work from home for the rest of 2020. Microsoft is green-lighting WFH through October. Twitter has said employees can continue to log in from home indefinitely.

It’s a strategy that could be broadly popular. In an informal poll Bloomberg Opinion conducted across our social media channels, 52 percent to 63 percent of respondents said they’d rather keep working from home than return to the office. That mirrors Gallup’s findings: About half of people surveyed want to continue working remotely.

And why not? Allowing remote work is cheaper than arranging for office upgrades. By now, organizations and employees have already invested in essential remote-work gear: computer monitors, ergonomic chairs, sweatpants.

That’s just the hardware. Companies have invested in virtual collaboration apps like Slack, Zoom and their rivals. Teams that have grown accustomed to them will probably continue to use them.

Supporting work from home long-term requires a shift in the way many companies think, explains Jennifer Kaufmann-Buhler, an assistant professor at Purdue University who studies office design. Companies have long encouraged employees to see the office as a kind of home, stocking kitchens with snacks and providing seating that feels, if not exactly homey, then rather like a nice hotel lobby. Now, homes have become workplaces, even if it’s just a presentable corner of home. Companies have always been happy for people to take work home, but when there are no alternatives it means rethinking some basics; such as internet access, for starters.

Since the start of the shutdowns, many cities have seen slower internet speeds. Upgrading is tricky, however, explains Bhaskar Chakravorti, dean of global business at the Fletcher School at Tufts University and director of its Digital Planet initiative, because most connection problems occur between the curb and your house. Those problems are expensive to fix, and internet service providers have little incentive to fix them because there is so little competition at the local level. But if more people work from home, high-speed internet access will become a greater necessity, like reliable electricity or clean water, and public pressure might force some level of minimum access.

In the meantime, companies with employees working from home will need to find solutions that use less bandwidth, whether it’s for communication or data sharing or something else.

I know that not everyone can work from home indefinitely. It’s much easier for those in what’s broadly known as the knowledge transfer business: a category that includes technologists, journalists, researchers, consultants and lawyers. Still, that’s a lot of people. In one survey, as many as a third of workers who once commuted say they’re now working from home. Compare that with only about 3 percent of American workers who previously worked from home.

Those of us who can comfortably work from home should keep doing so. And that’s where managers should put their energies; not in reopening office buildings for people who don’t need to be there.

They should consider it the first step toward keeping employees safe. As Joseph Allen, director of the Healthy Buildings Program at the Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health, emphasized in a recent interview, the only employees who should be asked to return to the building are those who need to be there to keep the business functional.

Many companies are instead leaping ahead to solutions further downstream; improving ventilation and air filtration, staggering employees’ schedules and stocking up on personal protective equipment, including masks. Those things should be used only when working from home isn’t an option.

By working from home as long as possible, we do more to fight Covid-19. The fewer people who return to work, the safer the workplace will be for those who do.

Sarah Green Carmichael is an editor with Bloomberg Opinion. For more articles like this, go to

Talk to us

More in Opinion

Catherine Berwicks loads ballots into a tray after scanning them at the Snohomish County Elections Ballot Processing Center on Tuesday, Aug. 4, 2020 in Everett, Wa.  (Andy Bronson / The Herald)
Editorial: Remove unhelpful ‘advisory’ measures from ballots

The measures provide no useful information to lawmakers and offer no context to inform voters.

Editorial cartoons for Wednesday, Jan. 27

A sketchy look at the news of the day.… Continue reading

Ian Terry / The Herald

Brian Henderson, of Renton, plugs in his Kia Soul EV electric vehicle at a charging station in Sultan on Wednesday, June 7. Henderson and a group of fellow electric car drivers made the trip from Everett's City Hall to Spokane's City Hall late last week in an effort to raise awareness about convenient charging locations along U.S. Highway 2.

Photo taken on 06072017
Editorial: Yes to gas tax hike, but this has to be the last

Transportation needs must be funded, but the gas tax is dwindling as a sustainable revenue source.

Arlington Fire Chief Dave Kraski outside Station #46 downtown. (Arlington Times)
Editorial: Arlington voters should approve fire agency merger

Merger of its fire department with North County Fire will maintain those services affordably.

The U.S. Capitol building is prepared for the inauguration ceremonies for President-elect Joe Biden as the "Field of Flags" are placed on the ground on the National Mall on Monday, Jan. 18, 2021. in Washington, DC. Approximately 191,500 flags will cover part of the National Mall and will represent the American people who are unable to travel to Washington, for the inauguration. (Joe Raedle/Pool vias AP)
Editorial: The oath we must take after every election

We can’t address solutions to our challenges until we accept the election of those who represent us.

Comment: Biden’s amnesty won’t bring new wave of immigrants

Things have changed since Reagan’s amnesty. Economic conditions have improved and rules are tougher.

Saunders: BIden, seeking unity, should let Catholic charity be

Supreme Court decision should have ended efforts to force group to offer contraception to staff.

Vote in the Feb. 9, other elections

The Arlington Fire Department will ask Arlington voters to vote by Feb.… Continue reading

Sound Transit light rail’s detour Boeing no longer viable

I couldn’t help but laugh reading your article (“Sound Transit projects ahead… Continue reading

Most Read