At WSU-Everett, Professor Gordon Taub (shown in March, 2018) records many of his lectures and publishes them online so his students can review the subject matter and raise questions to him one-on-one. Taub uses a “lightboard studio” which allows him to face the camera and write lessons or other messages on a glass surface. The image is flipped for playback. Both WSU-Everett and Everett Community College now plan to offer most of the course offerings remotely this fall, with a few exceptions. (Dan Bates / Herald file photo)

At WSU-Everett, Professor Gordon Taub (shown in March, 2018) records many of his lectures and publishes them online so his students can review the subject matter and raise questions to him one-on-one. Taub uses a “lightboard studio” which allows him to face the camera and write lessons or other messages on a glass surface. The image is flipped for playback. Both WSU-Everett and Everett Community College now plan to offer most of the course offerings remotely this fall, with a few exceptions. (Dan Bates / Herald file photo)

Commentary: No good choices for gown or town

The outcomes from colleges going online or in-person will be felt by the cities that rely on them economically.

By Noah Smith / Bloomberg Opinion

College life this fall is going to be a potential source of trouble; both on campus and for the towns where colleges are located.

Meeting friends, dorm life, socializing and attending classes are among the highest-risk activities in terms of spreading Covid-19 because they involve prolonged indoor personal contact. A study from South Korea shows that young people in their late teens and early 20s spread the virus faster than people of other ages.

The most responsible thing universities could do in terms of protecting public health would be to close dorms, hold classes online and bar all in-person student social activities for the fall semester. On their own, young people are unlikely to be safe and responsible; even if classes enforce strict social distancing and masking requirements, parties and dorm rooms will become breeding grounds for the virus. Young people don’t often die of the disease, but they can suffer long-term respiratory, neurological and other effects. They can also infect more vulnerable populations such as professors, administrators, family members and other community members.

Unfortunately, many colleges are refusing to shut down in-person student life. The reason is probably financial. Coronavirus has hit university budgets hard; keeping out high-paying foreign students, reducing state education funding and making students wary of attending. Fear of losing additional revenue from dormitory fees appears to be overriding public health concerns for many institutions of higher learning; just one more way in which a concern for money over health has degraded the U.S.’s pandemic response.

Some will be responsible about holding classes online, at least some of the time. (Local editor’s note: Both WSU-Everett and Everett Community College currently plan to offer their courses remotely this fall, with limited exceptions.)

But some are insisting that classes be held in person. Colleges can charge full tuition for a semester of online learning, but students and their parents tend to dislike online classes, so some may simply decide to skip it. In addition, U.S. Immigrations and Customs Enforcement has said it will bar international students from entering the U.S. if their classes would be held entirely online.

And if some students find that a combination of distance learning and internet-enabled socializing is just as good as the traditional college life, it could spark a longer-term shift away from college campuses as an institution. If young people realize that they can get almost as good an educational experience with “Zoom university,” and satisfying personal growth and career networking experience via various social apps, they might start to question the need to pay hundreds of thousands of dollars for the high-end package of university life. Even before the pandemic, many Americans were beginning to question whether astronomical tuition was worth it; letting students get a taste of life without the full college experience might turn that trickle into a long-term flood.

So many colleges are likely to risk coronavirus outbreaks in order to save their pocketbooks. But ironically, they may end up getting the worst of both worlds. Just as premature reopenings of bars, stores and restaurants ended up causing big Covid outbreaks and hurting business activity in many Sun Belt states, virus outbreaks on campuses could cause a stampede away from universities eroding trust in universities as responsible stewards of young people’s health and safety. And at the same time, enough classes are online, and enough students are staying home, that a long-term shift toward distance education is unlikely to be staved off simply by having kids on campus in the fall.

So one way or another, a big hit to university tuition is coming; on top of the big hits from state budget cuts and the decline in foreign students. That triple whammy will end up closing many colleges that are barely profitable — a trend that began before the pandemic — and will force many others to cut salaries and services.

All of this also means big trouble for college towns, which serve as economic engines for many areas that otherwise would be in decline A research university increases the economy of the surrounding area by drawing in skilled workers, which in turn draws in private investment. Even colleges that don’t do much research generate significant amounts of economic activity simply from student and staff spending in the region. Public universities in small towns also redistribute wealth from the big cities via the tax system. As things stand, college towns tend to have higher wages and higher gross domestic product per capita than other places.

With some students staying home and universities themselves under both short-term and long-term financial pressure, all that is now at even greater risk. With stores, restaurants, bars and other businesses quiet or empty, college towns could face a very strange and difficult autumn. And many of those troubles may last long after the pandemic is gone.

Noah Smith is a Bloomberg Opinion columnist. He was an assistant professor of finance at Stony Brook University, and he blogs at Noahpinion.

Talk to us

More in Opinion

toon
Editorial cartoons for Friday, May 14

A sketchy look at the news of the day.… Continue reading

In this Wednesday, March 24, 2021 image from video provided by Duke Health, Alejandra Gerardo, 9, looks up to her mom, Dr. Susanna Naggie, as she gets the first of two Pfizer COVID-19 vaccinations during a clinical trial for children at Duke Health in Durham, N.C. In the U.S. and abroad, researchers are beginning to test younger and younger kids, to make sure the shots are safe and work for each age. (Shawn Rocco/Duke Health via AP)
Editorial: Parents have decision to make on vaccinating kids

With one vaccine now approved for kids 12 and older, parents shouldn’t wait for a school requirement.

Comment: What Cheney’s wearied expression says about GOP

The Congresswoman is mourning the loss of a party’s soul, not over policy but over expedience.

Comment: $6 trillion’s a lot of money; here’s why it’s a bargain

Biden’s plans would invest in infrastructure and families, solidifying American prosperity.

Snohomish magazine used for political purposes

I just received the latest glossy-print City of Snohomish Quarterly Magazine which… Continue reading

Tell Congress you support Medicare for All Act

People are waking to the possibility of Medicare For All, a transformative… Continue reading

Craig Jacobsen, a technician at Everett Transit, demonstrates how the electric buses are charged. The new system takes about four hours to charge the batteries. (Lizz Giordano / The Herald)
Editorial: Get shovels ready for Biden’s transportation plans

The state and Sound Transit have work to do to benefit from Biden’s infrastructure investments.

toon mothers day
Editorial: What Mom really wants is help for her family

For Mother’s Day, how about backing proposals for equal pay, child care and family tax credits?

A reporter watches the Maricopa County ballots cast in the 2020 general election being examined and recounted by contractors working for Florida-based company, Cyber Ninjas, who was hired by the Arizona State Senate at Veterans Memorial Coliseum in Phoenix, Thursday, April 29, 2021. (Rob Schumacher/The Arizona Republic via AP, Pool)
Editorial: Wyman right to object to Arizona ballot audit

An authority on election integrity, Washington’s secretary of state sees red flags in a rogue recount.

Most Read