Commentary: State’s upside-down tax system needs reforms

By Kerrie McLaughlin

Washington state is known for many things: beautiful scenery, delicious apples, rain … and the most upside-down state tax system in the country.

Washington working families pay disproportionately higher tax rates than the wealthiest families, in part because we rely too much on sales tax and because our tax code is riddled with special-interest tax breaks and deductions. For instance, Washington is one of only eight states in the U.S. with no tax on capital gains, while companies including Boeing, Microsoft and Amazon get huge tax breaks, among the largest in the nation, despite still shipping jobs out-of-state.

Meanwhile, small businesses get slammed and pay out the nose in taxes, while law firms, accountants and consultants get off scot-free, as they’re classified as providing services.

The message seems to be clear: If you can afford a lobbyist in Olympia or a personal, private attorney you get a special deal. Everyone else gets a big tax burden and has to pay. But here’s the deal: Our taxes pay to improve our communities, developing projects that benefit all Washingtonians.

We have great schools and teachers, some of the best public lands in the nation, and we’re developing much-needed new infrastructure to keep up with our state’s growth. Why should wealthy folks and corporations, who benefit from the same projects and infrastructure, not have to pay an equitable amount in taxes, leaving the burden on the shoulders of the folks who feel the pain of high taxes much more acutely than those who aren’t paying a proportionate share?

Yet, everyone can think of how the budget shortfalls impact us all, statewide. We have roads and bridges in dire need of repair. We are under Supreme Court order to dramatically increase our funding of education. We’d like to see greater investment in public safety as we head into what will likely be another hot, record-setting summer. The state Senate seems to think there are two ways to respond to this reality: Either pay for what we need by cutting other important programs like early-childhood education and mental health services, or don’t pay for them at all. But that’s a false choice.

It doesn’t have to be this way. Currently, we are leaving money on the table — many Washington residents simply aren’t paying what they owe. If we would join the other 42 states which have a capital gains tax at a modest rate, in line with the national average, that alone would generate close to $1 billion of new revenue every year. We can also deliver tax relief to small businesses and tell our largest companies to start paying an amount that isn’t insulting, which would start bringing in hundreds of millions in new money. We can consider a carbon tax, or start closing some of the nearly 700 special interest tax breaks that benefit only the wealthy and the powerful at the expense of everyone else.

Two roads diverged in the green Pacific Northwest. Down one path, a few thousand Washingtonians continue to get special treatment while the rest of us pay back-breaking taxes and are forced to suffer cuts to vital services that help our state run. Down the other, we consider basic, common-sense reforms to our tax code. We tell the powerful to pay what they owe so that we can deliver tax relief to the majority of Washingtonians while simultaneously being able to make needed investments in our state to continue making it an even greater place to live.

To me, the option seems pretty clear. Clean up the tax code, end the special deals, and join the rest of the country in sensible tax policy.

If you agree, call your state legislators. Encourage them to support the budgets proposed by Gov. Jay Inslee or the state House, and to vote against the budget proposed by the state Senate. If Washington’s elite will pay what they owe, it’ll be a better state for all.

Kerrie McLaughlin lives in Everett.

Talk to us

> Give us your news tips.

> Send us a letter to the editor.

> More Herald contact information.

More in Opinion

RGB version
Editorial cartoons for Saturday, Jan. 18

A sketchy look at the news of the day.… Continue reading

President Donald Trump and Vice President Mike Pence visit the Martin Luther King, Jr. Memorial in Washington, Jan. 21, 2019. (Sarah Silbiger/The New York Times)
Editorial: What would MLK Jr. do? What, now, will we do?

Monday marks the presidential inauguration and the King holiday, offering guidance on the way forward.

Eco-nomics: A brief history of how the climate crisis unfolded

A review of the facts and dates makes clear that ramping up fossil fuel use takes us in the wrong direction.

Comment: Everett Chamber a dedicated champion for business

A vital city needs the services and support of the return of the Greater Everett Chamber of Commerce.

Forum: The one thing that AI can replicate: our wondrous flaws

Anything that AI produces, such as music, is hollow in its perfection. Flaws breathe life into our work.

Open PUD grant program to all customers

Regarding “Snohomish PUD reopens appliance upgrade program,” Jan. 15, The Herald: It’s… Continue reading

Biden can still enact Equal Rights Amendment

In the United States, women and girls are not legally guaranteed equal… Continue reading

toon
Editorial cartoons for Friday, Jan. 17

A sketchy look at the news of the day.… Continue reading

Veterinarian Bethany Groves, center, performs surgery on a Laysan albatross on Feb. 15, 2023 at the Progressive Animal Welfare Society’s (PAWS) wildlife center in Lynnwood, Washington. (Photo courtesy Anthony Denice)
Editorial: Vet shortage requires more access at WSU school

Adding 20 in-state tuition slots can bolster veterinarian ranks and serve animals and people.

Schwab: Conspiratorial thoughts, conditional prayers for L.A.

Trump and the GOP take full advantage of a tragedy to shift blame and wring out concessions.

Brooks: In Hegseth, we gets the Defense secretart we deserve

With all that the U.S. faces from belligerent nations, senators focused on wokeness and infidelities.

Comment: Time to reconside our attitudes about drinking

A recent surgeon general warning about cancer calls for better guidelines on how to gauge our consumption.

Support local journalism

If you value local news, make a gift now to support the trusted journalism you get in The Daily Herald. Donations processed in this system are not tax deductible.