Dionne: Trump’s state of the union is a contradiction

Trump has kept himself busy creating the perception of carnage from which he has vowed to save us.

By E.J. Dionne Jr.

The Washington Post

One should never feel sorry for anyone working in President Trump’s White House. They volunteered for this dreadful and chaotic administration. But it’s hard to envy those tasked with writing drafts of his State of the Union address.

Trump is an incumbent who behaves as if he is in the opposition. He relishes bemoaning the terrible things happening to the country on his watch — after two years of unified Republican government.

At the same time, it’s hard to recall a president more boastful about how great he is and how he has accomplished more than anyone who has ever held his job, which presumably includes Washington, Lincoln and FDR.

Trump is so in love with bragging that he even touts events that are anything but achievements.

On Jan. 4, 2018, Trump proudly tweeted: “Dow just crashes through 25,000. Congrats!” He recycled the same thought last Wednesday: “Dow just broke 25,000. Tremendous news!” Think about it: Taken together, the news from the two tweets is that the stock market is at the same spot it was a year ago, hardly joyous tidings for investors.

But recall that Trump told us years ago in “The Art of the Deal” that he engages in “truthful hyperbole,” which can “play to people’s fantasies.” The problem is that we never know for certain if the fantasist himself believes the tales he is spinning.

Tuesday’s delayed speech to a Joint Session of Congress thus promises to be an exercise in whiplash between despair and triumphalism.

The “crisis” at our southern border will be cast as an existential threat to the nation. It’s hard to imagine we won’t hear at least some of his staple references to “criminal aliens,” “drug dealers” and, of course, those “coyotes” he loves to summon. The president, as my Washington Post colleague Monica Hesse pointed out last week, regularly (and questionably at best) describes female migrants as being “tied up” with “duct tape” on their faces.

On Thursday, Trump even predicted that House Speaker Nancy Pelosi, who continues to resist his edifice-as-policy approach, would someday “be begging for a wall.” The president likes the idea that people — particularly, it seems, women — will “beg” him for things.

Amid the darkness, he’ll no doubt point to a few shafts of light, starting with Friday’s government report showing that the economy added 304,000 jobs last month. Trump may well talk about all the regulations he has scrapped (though probably not with a lot of specifics, since most voters don’t cotton to dirtier air and water, or less policing of shady banking practices). He might mention his corporate tax cut, even if it is unpopular and has fallen far short of all the promises made on its behalf.

But Trump can never get too upbeat, because he decided long ago that his political project depends upon inciting anxiety and anger as well as hostility toward (nonwhite) outsiders. This requires him to conjure a dystopian world because what he fears the most is a world in which fear is abating.

There was one truly unforgettable line in his inaugural address: “This American carnage stops right here and stops right now.” But the carnage can never end since Trump must argue that he and his wall are all that stand between us and chaos, duct tape, gangs and coyotes.

This isn’t working. Even members of that base he’s obsessed with expect the president they voted for to solve problems and not simply exploit them. That’s why his core support is shrinking. The survey number that should trouble Trump most is a recent Washington Post/ABC News poll finding that only 28 percent of Americans said they would definitely vote for him in 2020.

The Democrats’ choice of Stacey Abrams to respond to Trump will highlight his dilemma.

Selecting the party’s 2018 Georgia gubernatorial nominee certainly underscores the party’s diversity and the importance of African American women in its coalition, as the Post’s Eugene Scott noted. But as important is the fact that she describes herself with two words that are often miscast as polar opposites: “progressive” and “pragmatic.” She’s also an optimist who believes that “the further ahead we get, the harder it is to drag us back.”

The largest contrast on Tuesday night will thus not be the obvious disparity in the backgrounds of two speakers, but in their spirit: Hope vs. Carnage.

No matter how hard his speechwriters work to make him buoyant, Trump needs to depict a country facing a petrifying crisis. It’s the only way can justify what he does.

Follow E.J. Dionne on Twitter @EJDionne.

Talk to us

> Give us your news tips.

> Send us a letter to the editor.

> More Herald contact information.

More in Opinion

toon
Editorial cartoons for Wednesday, Dec. 4

A sketchy look at the news of the day.… Continue reading

The Everett Public Library in Everett, Washington on Thursday, Jan. 19, 2023. (Annie Barker / The Herald)
Editorial: What do you want and what are you willing to pay?

As local governments struggle to fund services with available revenue, residents have decisions ahead.

Burke: What will mass deportation look like in our hometowns?

The roundups of undocumented workers could thin specific workforces and disrupt local businesses.

French: Danger of Kash Patel as FBI head is loyalty to Trump

Patel wouldn’t come after criminals; he would come after those deemed disloyal or opposed to Trump.

Comment: Post-American world disorder gets jump on Trump’s return

Freed from U.S. authority, nationalists throughout the world are moving ahead with their plans.

Comment: Biden couldn’t keep personal, political separate

Unable to save his country from the return of Trump, Joe Biden saved his son from persecution.

toon
Editorial cartoons for Tuesday, Dec. 3

A sketchy look at the news of the day.… Continue reading

Children play and look up at a large whale figure hanging from the ceiling at the Imagine Children’s Museum on Wednesday, Oct. 26, 2022 in Everett, Washington. (Olivia Vanni / The Herald)
Editorial: Making your holiday shopping count for even more

Gifts of experiences can be found at YMCA, Village Theatre, Schack and Imagine Children’s Museum.

Stephens: Biden’s pardon of son a disgrace and a betrayal

Biden’s action to protect his son from consequences proves what Trump’s supporters believed all along.

French: Welcome stranger in by supporting homeless outreach

Feeding and sheltering those in need won’t alone fix homelessness, but it builds relationships that can.

Comment: Bipartisanship’s prospects, advantages to be tested

In Minnesota and D.C., lawmakers may find that little will get done without some give and take.

FILE — Bill Nye, the science educator, in New York, March 5, 2015. Nye filed a $37 million lawsuit against Disney and its subsidiaries on Aug. 25, 2017, alleging that he was deprived of extensive profits from his show “Bill Nye, the Science Guy,” which ran on PBS from 1993 to 1998. (Jake Naughton/The New York Times)
Editorial: What saved climate act? Good sense and a Science Guy

A majority kept the Climate Commitment Act because of its investments, with some help from Bill Nye.

Support local journalism

If you value local news, make a gift now to support the trusted journalism you get in The Daily Herald. Donations processed in this system are not tax deductible.