Editorial: Lawsuit would penalize kids instead of lawmakers

By The Herald Editorial Board

In hauling seven Washington state school districts into court, including Everett School District, state Superintendent of Instruction Randy Dorn says he isn’t blaming the victim. But he risks penalizing another victim, in this case the children he is supposed to serve.

Dorn last week filed suit in King County Superior Court against seven of the state’s largest school districts — Everett, Seattle, Bellevue, Spokane, Tacoma, Puyallup and Vancouver’s Evergreen district — as well as the state of Washington, alleging that the districts were illegally using local levy-approved revenue for a significant portion of teacher, staff and administrator salaries.

The state Supreme Court in its January 2012 McCleary decision ruled that the state had to amply fund basic education using “dependable and regular sources” of revenue and sought to exclude property tax levies because they’re subject to the “whims” of local voters and are based on property values that vary broadly from one district to another, creating inequitable funding among districts. The court has given the Legislature a 2018 deadline to end its reliance on local school levies and fund basic education.

While Dorn has called the use of levy funds for teacher pay illegal, it has become commonplace at most of the state’s 295 school districts.

As the Legislature has shirked its responsibility to fully fund basic education, lawmakers have allowed districts to use levy dollars to supplement salaries for teachers and others for extra time, responsibilities and incentives in contracts that districts believe are key to providing good educations. And no state auditor has faulted a school district for using levy money in this fashion.

Dorn, justifiably unhappy with the Legislature’s pace in outlining a fix thus far, is attempting to force the issue with the lawsuit, asking a court to pull that portion of school district’s levy funds used to supplement teachers’ and others’ salaries in the hopes of mobilizing parents and taxpayers to light a fire under lawmakers. But the ruling that Dorn seeks would force school districts to drastically cut teacher salaries that have been negotiated in contracts and lead to walk-outs by teachers and others.

Spurring action by the Legislature hasn’t proved an easy task, as the Supreme Court discovered when it imposed a $100,000-a-day fine on the state in 2015 that was largely shrugged off. The I.O.U. now totals more than $28 million.

But Dorn’s latest push to force a resolution is a bad idea.

When Dorn asked state Attorney General Bob Ferguson for an opinion on the use of local levy funds for salaries, Ferguson declined because he said his question was too closely “intertwined” to the issues before the Supreme Court.

Dorn persisted and now plans to use $100,000 of his agency’s funds to hire an outside law firm. And the lawsuit will force the school districts themselves to spend tax dollars to defend against the suit, either separately or as a group.

And as we pointed out last month when Dorn advised the Supreme Court to consider this and other methods to convince lawmakers to act — including shutting down schools all together — cutting off levy funds risks too much in the uncertain hope that it might persuade the Legislature to act. Dorn has no guarantee that his gambit would work; with control already divided between Democrats and Republicans, the outcome of this November’s election only further clouds the expected actions of lawmakers.

The school districts know that their use of levy funds to supplement teacher salaries has created an inequitable and unsustainable system across the state. But, aside from allowing academic quality and achievement to suffer, it was the only option that the Legislature provided to school districts while lawmakers worked to resolve McCleary.

The Supreme Court has scheduled a hearing for Sept. 7, asking lawmakers to defend their plan to develop a plan to satisfy the McCleary decision. Dorn should withdraw his lawsuit and take the advice of his attorney general and allow that process to proceed.

Talk to us

> Give us your news tips.

> Send us a letter to the editor.

> More Herald contact information.

More in Opinion

RGB version
Editorial cartoons for Saturday, April 26

A sketchy look at the news of the day.… Continue reading

County Council members Jared Mead, left, and Nate Nehring speak to students on Thursday, Jan. 30, 2025, during Civic Education Day at the Snohomish County Campus in Everett, Washington. (Will Geschke / The Herald)
Editorial: Students get a life lesson in building bridges

Two county officials’ civics campaign is showing the possibilities of discourse and government.

Roberts: Gutting of scientific research will leave us blind

The Trump administration’s deep cuts to science and research will harm our economy and environment.

Comment: Funding delays jeopardize research of healthy aging

A freeze of NIH funding threatens research into aging and Alzheimer’s at the UW School of Medicine.

Comment: Meaningful law on rent requires bill’s earlier version

As lawmakers seek a deal, rent stabilization should keep a 7 percent cap and apply to single homes.

Forum: Trump cuts to museum funding hit Imagine Children’s

The defunding of a museum and library program means the loss of a science lab for preschoolers.

Forum: We strive for Belonging, then keep it to ourselves

From childhood we treat Belonging as something to be jealously guarded. What if others belong, too?

Comment: Higher tax on tobacco pouches could backfire

A proposed 95 percent tax on smokeless tobacco could lead some back to more dangerous cigarettes.

toon
Editorial cartoons for Friday, April 25

A sketchy look at the news of the day.… Continue reading

FILE - This Feb. 6, 2015, file photo, shows a measles, mumps and rubella vaccine on a countertop at a pediatrics clinic in Greenbrae, Calif. Washington state lawmakers voted Tuesday, April 23, 2019 to remove parents' ability to claim a personal or philosophical exemption from vaccinating their children for measles, although medical and religious exemptions will remain. (AP Photo/Eric Risberg, File)
Editorial: Commonsense best shot at avoiding measles epidemic

Without vaccination, misinformation, hesitancy and disease could combine for a deadly epidemic.

The Buzz: This week, the makeup tips of political powerbrokers

Who would have guessed that Kitara Revanche and Pete Hegseth used the same brand of concealer?

Schwab: Who saw this coming? said no one but Senate Republicans

Take your pick of agency heads; for those who advise and consent, there was no sign of trouble ahead.

Support local journalism

If you value local news, make a gift now to support the trusted journalism you get in The Daily Herald. Donations processed in this system are not tax deductible.